WHAT IF THE ROMAN EMPIRE NEVER HAPPENED?

The architectural world we live in has been largely dominated by the classical civilisations of Greece and Rome. We have only to take a walk through the centre of Ripon to see their legacy all around us.

The Town Hall, with its Corinthian columns, of course, and Prezzo with its Ionic columns. There’s a semi-circular Diocletian window in the attic storey of the Town Hall’s next-door-but-one neighbour and another in the back wall of the Town Hall itself, their inspiration taken directly from the Baths of Diocletian in Split. And did you notice that word ‘attic’? It started as an adjective derived from ‘Athens’, and first described a sort of square column used in low upper storeys of buildings, before meaning a decorative strip at the top of a façade, and eventually the rooms behind that ‘attic strip’.

Even if our buildings don’t have such obvious clues as columns to suggest their classical antecedents, much of Ripon still betrays the Graeco-Roman past that lies behind the architecture of the 18th and 19th centuries, particularly in the spacing of windows and the proportions of facades. Don’t be fooled by those with ‘Tudor’ beams added in the 1930s; the buildings they decorate are just as classical beneath their ‘olde-worlde’ dress. And when The Arcade was built two dumpy Tuscan columns were placed at the entrance from the Square to herald its arrival – the architect believed he knew the value of a classical allusion.

Some of our financial institutions show the influence, too – the Skipton Building Society’s Palladian-style building most obviously, but also HSBC, where the Greek style is transmuted through eyes of the Arts and Crafts movement, and Barclays, where Roman architecture has undergone a Renaissance-style make-over.

Ah, you may be thinking, but what about the Cathedral and our churches? Aren’t they Gothic? Certainly they are – but even Gothic has its roots in the Classical. The earliest churches were based on Roman basilicas, where the law was dispensed – the seat of the judge was replaced by the altar when the Christians took over. The earliest churches were in Classical style, and as Christianity spread northwards it was natural for church builders to copy the style as best they could. So when St Wilfrid built his Ripon church it had the round arches of a Roman construction – we can still see some of them in the crypt, the only remnant of his work.

Round arches were still the fashion for the Normans – what we in Britain call the Norman style is more generally known as ‘Romanesque’ (unless you’re German, when it’s the Rundbogenstil – the round arch style). And it wasn’t just the arches; the proportions, too, were retained from the classical styles, including the spacing of the columns. When it was realised that a pointed arch was more efficient in distributing the weight of a wall above it, the Gothic style came in – but much of the classical thought underlying it was kept.

So when the Renaissance began, with its looking back to the golden age of the Classical civilisations, it was not so great a jolt as might be thought; all through the Middle Ages there were elements of Greek and Roman principles behind the architecture. We could say that we have at least 2000 years of Classical civilisation behind Britain’s – and the western world’s – architecture.

But what if the Romans had done nothing for us – if they had not developed their all-conquering empire that brought what we call civilisation to supposedly-uncultured barbarians like the Britons? Where would our architecture be then? It’s a question that’s impossible to answer, of course, but we might speculate.

If we had continued to live under a Celtic system, our architecture might have developed a style based on the simple stone structures like beehive-shaped huts, pencil-like tower and circular brochs. Would we have developed from them an architecture that coped with modern life? Or would our civilisation have been shaped by the buildings which we would have constructed as a result?

Or what if we had been entirely taken over by Viking civilisation, with their architecture based on the use of massive wooden logs that they shaped into huts and mead-halls? Would we now have a Market Square lined with grass-roofed wooden structures – an oak Town Hall, a series of pine financial institutions, walls of woven hazel? A wooden cathedral, like the Scandinavian stave churches, with lots of sloping shingle roofs and decorations like the prows of longboats? It would be a very different city.

Or, to take speculation wider, what if, instead of our being part of a Roman Empire, the Assyrian or the Persian Empires had been the dominant force in Western Europe – as, by a twist of fate, they could have been. What then for our architecture? The Persians would certainly have given us imposing buildings with columns, through the form of the columns would have been very different – they might have been heavily fluted and decorated with bulls, unicorns or griffons. The Assyrians would undoubtedly have imported their massive, intimidating bas-relief sculptures, usually carved on alabaster slabs, as well as their fully-three-dimensional statues of such monsters, which would be brilliantly coloured. The buildings probably would be made of brick.

We are conditioned by the architecture that surrounds us, whether we like it or not. We live our 21st century lives in part constrained by the architecture of civilisations from more than two millennia before us. Like everything in our modern world, our architecture depends on what has gone before – and by the accidents of history that brought some influences to the fore and left others in the ‘might have been’ category. We can do nothing about it – but it’s fun to speculate. Let’s finish by re-imagining Ripon with a ziggurat in place of the Cathedral and a Market Square dominated not by the elegant Town Hall but by an Assyrian palace decorated with marching troops and a winged bull in red, black and gold. It’s an interesting image . . .

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.