Alice ‘had never before seen a rabbit with either a waistcoat-pocket or a watch to take out of it, and, full of curiosity, she hurried across the field after it, and was just in time to see it pop down a large rabbit-hole under the hedge. In a moment down went Alice after it, never once considering how in the world she was to get out again . . . she found herself falling down what seemed a deep well.
Down, down, down. Would the fall never come to an end? . . . “I wonder if I shall fall right through the earth!” . . . Down, down, down: there was nothing else to do . . . suddenly, bump! bump! down she came upon a heap of sticks and shavings, and the fall was over.’
These words, from the opening of what was originally ‘Alice’s Adventures Under Ground’, written by Lewis Carroll between 1862 and 1864, are often said to have been in part inspired by his stays in Ripon. It has been argued that the young Charles Dodgson was influenced by two Ripon sights – the gypsum sink holes (in particular the large one near what was formerly the station, which opened in 1834) and St Wilfrid’s crypt below the cathedral.
By having Alice have her adventures ‘Under Ground’, Carroll was tapping into a vein of human fascination with what goes on beneath the surface of the earth. Where does this fascination come from? Part of it must come from a collective memory of our distant ancestors, who used caves as dwellings and were used to experiencing the darkness that goes with underground living – a darkness that easily gave rise to stories and legends.
There must be, too, a frisson of fear that comes from the fact that most races have buried their dead in the ground or in rock-hewn tombs – the sort of tomb that Jesus was laid in after his crucifixion. The fear of being buried alive (which kept many 19th-century inventors busy patenting devices that would enable the awakening ‘corpse’ to signal its revivication to people still above ground) was a powerful influence, too.
But there have been other influences, too – and many theories about what actually does go on below the earth’s surface. These days we have a pretty good idea of the geology of the earth and the forces that drive the inner mechanics of the plane, though it was not until the 1960s that the theory of plate tectonics – the drifting of the continents on the asthenosphere, the viscous upper mantle – was widely accepted.
In the past, though, there have been many whacky theories about the earth’s interior – and none more whacky than those of John Cleves Symmes, an American Army captain born in 1780. In 1818 he came out with the theory that the earth was hollow (an idea that Edmund Halley had also had in the 17th century, when he was Astronomer Royal), and that within it lived a variety of creatures whose ways were not dissimilar to our own. Access to this inner world was at the poles, which were not ice-bound but had clear spaces surrounded by a ring of ice, so that air and light could penetrate the interior and, if they wished, the inhabitants could come and go (though none, it seems, ever did so).
Symmes published his theory on 10 April 1818 (some said it should have been 10 days earlier) to much ridicule – though when in 1822 he tried to persuade the US Senate to back an expedition to prove its truth, 25 of the then 48 members voted in favour. Over the next 11 years, until his death, he developed the theory further, eventually deciding that the interior was in fact made of seven concentric spheres, which revolved at different speeds and, with reflected sunlight would be ‘a warm and rich land, stocked with thrifty vegetables and animals if not men’. Although he was deadly serious, most considered him eccentric – for a time a common expression of disbelief was ‘Symmes Holes!’
Another tack was followed by Arthur Conan Doyle, whose irascible scientist character, Professor Challenger, believed that the earth was a living being and sank a shaft miles deep into its living flesh. The story is called ‘The Day the Earthy Screamed’, so you have an indication of the outcome. And before him, of course, Jules Verne had written ‘Journey to the Centre of the Earth’ in 1864; Professor Otto Lidenbrock, his nephew Axel and their guide Hans enter the Icelandic volcano Snaæfellsjökull to descend volcanic tubes toward the centre of the Earth. They encounter prehistoric animals, giant mushrooms and many natural hazards – and then resurface through Stromboli in southern Italy.
Much of our modern subterranean work, though, has practical applications. Tunnelling has been one of the ways in which we overcome natural obstacles and make travel easier; think of the tunnels that carried water to ancient civilisations, or, much more recently, of the canal and railway tunnels dug through mountains by the pick-and-shovel work of the navvies. Modern tunnel-boring techniques (pioneered by Marc Brunel at the Thames Tunnel at Rotherhithe between 1825 and 1843) now use huge machines to gouge out the strata below the surface. The Channel Tunnel is a fine example and the current Crossrail project includes not only the tunnelling but also many new or redeveloped underground stations.
But it has not always been this large-scale exploration or engineering that has fed our delight in the wonders of the earth; in the Renaissance and until the 19th century there was a domestic way of experiencing it – you built a grotto. Excavate a space, cover it with rocks, decorate it with seashells, shiny minerals and slivers of mirror or with classical sculpture and you had your own bit of subterranean gloom to impress your friends – though whether it would have been a suitable place to spot a white rabbit is doubtful.
