It is good news that Harrogate Borough Council is looking again at a new swimming pool for Ripon. It is certainly something that the city needs, and, all things being equal, a site adjacent to the leisure centre seems a logical location. So far, so good.
Ripon Civic Society is fully behind the wishes of people with an interest in swimming – and especially those who help young people to enjoy the water, as well as older people who swim for pleasure and groups that enjoy water sports. Ripon needs – and deserves – good swimming facilities. But the report of the council’s plans in this newspaper last week did not cover one important aspect of the plan – what will happen to the existing building.
Seven years ago, when the plans for a new pool were last mooted, several groups came together to examine the plans. There were the swimmers, some of whom wanted a much larger pool, either on the site of the current one or elsewhere. There were those opposed to adding any more building to the Camp Close site, which was given to the city as open space. And there were those, including Ripon Civic Society, who were anxious for the future of the Spa Baths buildings.
It can come as no surprise that, with the prospect of a new pool, the Society must again look carefully at what happens to those buildings. The Spa Baths is a Grade II listed building – that means all of it, not just the frontage. Buildings that are listed Grade II are, notes the website for Historic England (formerly English Heritage), ‘of special interest, warranting every effort to preserve them’, a definition endorsed by the Listed Buildings and Conservation Areas Act 1990.
Grade II-listed buildings can be listed for their own intrinsic worth, as well as for their particular value to the community in which they are found. Ripon Civic Society would argue that the Spa Baths are important on both counts.
The official Listing says that the Baths consist of ‘a relatively utilitarian structure with an exceptionally elaborate front . . . exceptionally inventive moulded terracotta ornament covering the whole front, mainly Arts and Crafts in character, but in parts distinctly Art Nouveau.’ Inside, there is ‘a pyramidally roofed foyer with an ornamental glazed tile interior’ which is also considered of high value.
The 2009 edition of ‘The Buildings of England’ – the ‘Pevsner’ guides, published since the last round of the Spa Baths controversy – describes the ‘floridly detailed façade in red brick and orange terracotta, with prominent porte cochère, the style “an oriental rendering of the Renaissance, suggestive of luxury, opulence and refinement”.’ Whether we consider the style to be oriental, Renaissance, Arts and Crafts or Art Nouveau, there is no doubt that Ripon’s Spa Baths are distinctive and, we suggest, much loved.
They are the most important Edwardian structure in Ripon – we might argue that, of their style, they have no equal in North Yorkshire. They are an exemplar of Ripon’s civic pride; 1904 was the tercentenary of Ripon’s 1604 charter from King James I, and the City Council wanted an appropriate commemoration. They decided that, if Harrogate could have a spa, so could Ripon. They identified a source of water – some distance away at Aldfield – and commissioned Harrogate’s Borough Surveyor Samuel Stead to design the sumptuous building, very much of its time, with its bizarre terracotta masks built into the façade.
Not only is the outside ornate; so in the interior. Go through the doors, with their carvings of pomegranates, into what is now the foyer but was formerly the Pump Room; the pump basin and outlet, from which patrons took the waters, survive behind the pay desk. The whole room is decorated with highly-glazed and moulded Burmantofts faience tiling, and there are stained glass windows showing parts of Ripon’s history. Smaller windows have Art Nouveau motifs. In the wings there are Art Nouveau tiles behind modern cladding.
The city fathers were proud of the new spa; but any success was short lived, so eventually the City Council spent £11,600 in converting the treatment areas and adding a swimming pool; until then Riponians bathed in the River Ure. And now, as is widely recognised, the pool is not up to a sufficiently good standard to warrant spending money on long-term refurbishment.
So, with political determination and a following wind, Ripon might yet have a new pool. This does not mean that the current building can be sold off for housing, as was intended last time round. This is a public building, paid for by the ratepayers of Ripon and, in theory at least, maintained by their taxes. The 1904 buildings deserve to be kept in public ownership, though there are, perhaps, sound arguments for demolishing the 1930s ‘shed’ that houses the pool.
What should it become? There are many imponderables here; what are the plans for the adjacent hospital, and could the Spa Baths building play a part in its future? Could there be a new life for the 1904 building in relation to the Spa Gardens, as a new ‘pavilion’ and public spaces? Or, more excitingly, could a new public hall for Ripon be constructed where the pool structure now is, offering modern facilities approached through the Edwardian foyer? That’s certainly something Ripon desperately needs for the future.
So, a welcome for a new pool – but a watching brief on the future of the past, our iconic Spa Baths.
