One of the roles that Ripon Civic Society undertakes is to look at planning applications in the city and the surrounding area. Harrogate Borough Council (HBC) provides the Society with its weekly lists of planning applications, and the Society’s Planning Committee submits its comments where it considers that the Society has something pertinent to say.
This voluntary work is undertaken by the Society in pursuit of its stated aims:
• promoting heritage protection and conservation projects in the city and area
• promoting the highest levels of architecture, planning and design
• stimulating public awareness of the best qualities of Ripon and the surrounding area
• acting as a leading voice in the development and prosperity of the city and the surrounding area
The Society’s Planning Committee includes people with professional experience in planning and conservation, as well as others who also have a similar keen interest in the future of the city. HBC has undertaken to consult formally with the Society when planning applications that affect listed buildings within the local Conservation Area are submitted; this covers the most important buildings within the city’s historic core. Other applications are considered by the Society as they appear in the weekly lists.
There have been comments from some, including city councillors and former councillors who should be better informed, that the Society is always opposed to planning applications. This is far from the truth; of the 15 applications on which comments have been made this year, the Society has supported almost half – though sometimes with observations that were aimed at improving the schemes. Some schemes were just commented on. For the others – some of them the major applications in the area – the Society has sent detailed objections.
In January objections were made to the application to build 150 houses on land off Bellman Walk; the objections include the fact that the site is outside the city development limit, which remains the same as in Harrogate’s 2001 Local Plan; that the layout of the existing Doublegates estate would mean difficult access to the site, nor could it realistically be proposed to provide access from Bishopton Lane; that the development would increase the already-heavy traffic in the west of Ripon, which would be even greater if the neighbouring military estate is eventually developed for housing and the military road reopened; and that the area provides a valuable asset on the city’s countryside edge. It is regretted that the application was approved.
The next major objection was to one of the largest applications currently before the planners – to build 450 new houses at West Lane. Among the points made in a detailed response to the application, the Society pointed out that this was timed when the city’s strategic planning context for any growth of our city is being determined through both the review of a new Local Plan for the Harrogate District and by the preparation of Ripon’s own Neighbourhood Plan, known as the Ripon City Plan. It is understood that HBC’s planning officers currently consider that there is a demonstrable five-years’ supply of housing sites for the district; this should support a case for arguing that the application is, at least, premature.
The vision for Ripon in 2021 contained in the HBC Core Strategy, which remains in place, states that ‘The City of Ripon will continue its successful regeneration and the redevelopment for housing of its underused and vacant land will minimise or possibly avoid the need to develop green-field land. ….’ With other sites and premises within the current development limit already being developed, and with sites at Red House on Palace Road and at the former Cathedral Choir School also candidates for housing, the Society has argued that to build on green-field land is not the way forward. This application has not yet been determined.
Plans to demolish the Police Station on North Street and replace it with a development for retired people by McCarthy and Stone, was the subject of comment in March. The Society has had no objection to the demolition of the existing building, which is unworthy of the site; it has, though, serious concerns about the proposed replacement. The Society pointed out that this is a sensitive location, within the Ripon Conservation area, very close to a major road junction at the Clock Tower and on the main approach to the city centre from the north; the proposal put forward is overwhelming in its bulk and pedestrian in its detail. It does little to match the Victorian terraces adjacent to the site and across the road, and the proposed residential blocks, with their clad upper storey, are both dull and intrusive.
The Society pointed out that the access arrangements are unsatisfactory and that the suggested traffic flows seem low. More thought is required about the arrangements for pedestrians and cyclists, with a proper link through the site to enable walkers and cyclists to move with safety from Tower Road to North Street. Trees on the site need stronger safeguards to protect them than are proposed. This application is still awaiting a decision.
On a positive note, the Society commended a proposal for a new, modern house on Steven Way, on the former College site; in its comments the Society said that it ‘is always looking to encourage good modern building, as opposed to the tame, often pastiche designs that are too commonly built. This is a good, contemporary design, which respects its surroundings but is definitely a building of the 21st century. We believe that its scale and layout are appropriate, and that such a new building will be an excellent pointer to how new buildings can be produced in such sites in the future.’
All the responses the Society makes to planning applications can be found on the Ripon Civic Society website at www.riponcivicsociety.org.uk; click on the ‘News’ tab and then on ‘Planning’ to see them.
