SETTING OUT THE CHURCH – PART 2: FROM CRANMER TO CROMWELL – AND BEYOND

‘This church, strongly constructed in the Gothic style and pleasingly ornamented, had stood there for several centuries . . . and it made a solemn impression, although the redecoration of the interior for the Protestant service had robbed it of something of its repose and majesty,’ wrote Goethe in 1809, long after the momentous changes that took place in churches across Europe, and notably in England, in the mid-16th century.

In last week’s column we left the English church on the cusp of those changes. Henry VIII broke with Rome and set up his own church, with himself as a somewhat vacillating head; at times he was all in favour of radical evangelical reform, at others he insisted on keeping everything from the past. Influenced by the reformist Archbishop Cranmer and, until his fall (chronicled in Hilary Mantell’s novels), by Thomas Cromwell, Henry allowed an English bible, but services continued to be in Latin. In his reign the monasteries were closed and the private chantries supressed, though this was as much a financial as a religious act; the funds that flowed to the royal coffers from rich establishments like Fountains Abbey were vast.

Not everyone approved, of course; the Duke of Norfolk wrote ‘I would all things were as hath been in times past.’ But under Henry’s successor, the young King Edward VI, things moved much more quickly. In came a new prayer book, in English; the Mass was abolished and replaced by the Holy Communion service, along with a conflation of the other multiple daily services into Matins and Evensong.

This had an effect upon the look of churches, too. Out went the stone altars of the past – there is a record of anger when, during a heresy hearing in St Paul’s Cathedral, Cranmer sat on a platform above the disused altar formerly dedicated to Our Lady. Instead, wooden communion tables were ordered. They did not have a fixed location, but were brought out and placed in a convenient spot when Communion was held. They were often placed lengthwise in the chancel, with the narrow end toward the east, so that people could sit in the former clergy and choir stalls or on moveable benches; the minister stood on the north side. And because Matins and Evensong were much more frequent than Communion, the pulpit and the reading desk became more prominent in churches.

Images of all sorts were removed; it was at this time that many of the fine religious carvings in alabaster were taken away – Ripon Cathedral has a series found after three hundred years of being hidden; one of them is now in St Wilfrid’s crypt. The rood – the figure of the crucified Christ, with the Virgin and St John over the screen – was banished. Some of these images, along with stone altars and some of the panoply of the medieval church, returned briefly during the reign of the Catholic Mary Tudor, but under her half-sister Elizabeth the country returned to a reformed religion and a simpler way of doing things.

At this time the interiors of churches were often whitewashed to hide medieval ‘superstitious’ wall-paintings, and it was decreed that at the east end, boards should be erected with the words of the Ten Commandments and the Lord’s Prayer painted on them. Sometimes there were other texts in the walls, too, but these have mostly disappeared in later decorative changes. The Communion tables had now to be covered with a linen cloth and a ‘frontal’ of some rich material. It was recommended (though not compulsory until the Restoration in 1660) that the Royal Arms should be displayed; they were often placed on a screen – where the rood once stood.

In the 17th century, Charles I’s Archbishop of Canterbury from 1633, William Laud, wanted to restore ‘the beauty of holiness’; under him, altars (called that once again) went back to a fixed position against the east wall of the chancel. He encouraged candlesticks (with candles lit during services) to be placed on them, and they were surrounded with rails. Their original purpose was to protect the altar from dogs; there was a salutary story from a Cambridgeshire church in 1630, where the Christmas communion service had to be abandoned when a dog ate all the bread about to be consecrated.

The rails soon proved useful for the distribution of communion: Laud didn’t approve of the Low Church way of having the bread and wine taken around to the people sitting in their pews, and encouraged them to kneel reverently at the altar rail; there is an unusual example in Coxwold Church, where the rails are elongated down the length of the chancel. There was also an increased richness in furnishings; Bishop John Cosin of Durham provided rich woodwork in his cathedral and in some of the churches in his diocese.

Then came Oliver Cromwell; it was back to the simplicity of the Puritans. His followers threw out many of the Laudian furnishings, including altars and rails. They also destroyed organs and remaining images. Christmas was, famously, banned. For the Church of England – certainly for those less-fanatically Puritan – this was a dour, cheerless time.

At the Restoration in 1660, things changed again. The Church perked up – but the emphasis was increasingly on preaching rather than on the sacraments. Altars were restored to the east end, behind decent rails, and were given heavy baroque surrounds of carved wood; there are plenty of good examples in the parish churches of York. Ceilings were sometimes painted elaborately. And churches ceased to be of the traditional ground plan – architects like Wren designed square, circular, octagonal or even less-regular shapes. These focused on the pulpit, and such churches have been called ‘preaching boxes’.

It was these ‘preaching boxes’ that would dominate the next century, when the Church of England seemed to slumber and the Nonconformists started to flex their architectural muscles – a story to which we shall return next week.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.