A recent website article suggested that architects lack a sense of humour and cannot find it in their hearts to be whimsical. It’s a very sweeping statement, and like all such statements is hardly a scientific survey.
So is there any truth in it? And would we want our architects to display a sense of humour in their work? Is their role not just to design buildings that do their job, without trying to make a joke of it? In most cases our answer to the last question is probably that we need workmanship and thoughtfulness above whimsy and humour.
But that doesn’t mean to say that architects cannot find space for amusement in their buildings; indeed, many of them have done so, throughout the ages – though we might not always recognise it. Who knows whether the builders, consulting with St Wilfrid in planning his great church in Ripon in the 7th century, suggested humorous touches – ‘How about a very winding approach to the crypt, disorientating the visitors?’ they might have said.
Certainly, builders in the Middle Ages (we can’t yet speak of them truly as architects) were not averse to allowing their workmen the individual touches of humour; again, we have only to look at some of the carvings in Ripon Cathedral to see what they came up with, not only in stone but also in wood, with the outstanding series of misericords – the tip-up seats in the stalls – and the elephant and monkey on the bench ends.
By the time of the Renaissance architects began to work to the rules of classical architecture – perhaps, it seems, with little ability to introduce individuality and humour. But not always. Michelangelo, as well as being a great sculptor and painter, was a great architect, too. He took the rules of classical architecture and played with them; columns did not support the right arches (sometimes they supported nothing at all); monster-sized sculpted figures perched themselves on the top of triangular pediments, which themselves broke the rules. Giant columns stretched the full height of tall buildings; facades projected and receded seemingly at random.
A century later in Britain, Christopher Wren was doing something similar in his City of London churches, with their great variety of designs and steeple shapes. He even imported humour into his designs for St Paul’s Cathedral; having had his first plan turned down, he produced a very odd design in which the dome was topped by a spire in the shape of a thin pagoda. This was approved by the King, but it seems Wren did not intend it seriously; he immediately altered the design to something more like what we see today.
The century after Wren, architects were still playing with the possibilities of design. If they couldn’t actually construct their whimsical buildings, they could at least draw them as imaginary schemes; one such ‘capriccio’ by Robert Adam, showing a ruined basilica, may have been the inspiration for ‘The Ruin’, one of the follies at Hackfall.
The design of follies, of course, was one of the pre-eminent ways in which architects could express their humour; all they needed was a client in tune with their ideas. One such was the Marquess of Rockingham at Wentworth Woodhouse, where the otherwise very-correct architect Henry Flitcroft designed the triangular oddity called Hoober Stand. Other 18th-century follies of note include Mow Cop Castle in Cheshire, a whole series of different styles of building at Hawkstone in Shropshire and, perhaps the best, ’The Pineapple’ at Airth near Stirling, where a 53-foot-high stone fruit towers over the former walled garden of the Earl of Dunmore’s estate, supposedly a wedding present to his new bride.
When Gothic came back into fashion in the 18th and 19th centuries, architectural humour was given a freer reign. The writer Horace Walpole was one of its earliest proponents, with his Twickenham house, Strawberry Hill, an undoubtedly-humorous confection of medieval-inspired interiors. Walpole was not a professional architect, of course, but James Wyatt (designer of Ripon Town Hall) was, yet his short-lived Fonthill Abbey was as much a Gothic joke as Strawberry Hill.
Another Gothic joker was the architect William Burges, designer of the churches at Skelton-on-Ure and Studley Royal. The designs of these two churches are quirky – especially the Gothic dome over the quire of St Mary’s, Studley. Equally odd were his designs at Cardiff Castle, where the interiors he designed for the Marquess of Bute are a riot of colour, with elaborate fireplaces (one like a castle with damsels waving from its turret and armed knights riding to the door, another topped by figures of angels), rooms not just in the Gothic style but influenced by Moorish design, too, and, on a smaller scale, a porphyry bath inlaid with metal fish and a bell in the shape of a monkey, where you push the nut in its mouth to summon the staff.
Humour didn’t stop with Burges; Sir Edwin Lutyens was a great joker in his buildings, with imaginative touches like cupboards with circular doors and clocks in the shape of pompous butlers. Last century even ‘modern’ architects came up with humorous buildings, like the famous ‘Cube Houses’ in Rotterdam put up in the 1970s. And you could argue that structures like the Lloyd’s building in London and the Pompidou Centre in Paris, with their internal services exposed on the outside, are as much ‘Mannerist’ buildings, subverting the norm, as any of Michelangelo’s works.
Are the architects of today showing their humour? Certainly. Terminal 3 of Copenhagen airport is designed to look like a paper aeroplane. Buildings such as the Gherkin, the Cheesegrater and the Walkie-Talkie in London and the Armadillo in Glasgow suggest that architectural humour is not lacking, and that the public appreciates it by inventing familiar names. Perhaps all we need are imaginative clients to give architects more freedom; something we – and our planners – could take to heart, even in Ripon.
