ARCHITECTURE AND ‘CULTURAL APPROPRIATION’

A recent American speaker on BBC Radio 4 introduced a concept that is probably unfamiliar to most British people, though it seems to be gaining ground in the US. It is the idea of ‘cultural appropriation’.

So what is ‘cultural appropriation’? It apparently means members of the cultural majority using elements of a minority culture, so (apparently) leading to the oppression of the minority culture or robbing it of its identity and rights. The examples the Radio 4 speaker quoted seemed rather minor – American students being frowned on for wearing sombreros at a Mexican-themed party, an art gallery censured for allowing visitors to be photographed in a kimono, copied from of one of its paintings. He also said that performances of Gilbert and Sullivan’s ‘The Mikado’ had been banned in the US because the humorous ‘mocking’ of the Japanese was perceived as a slight on that nation.

To many of us, this may seem trivial – should we go on to ban ‘The Pirates of Penzance’ as an affront to the people of Cornwall, or forbid any other nation to perform ‘The Yeomen of the Guard’ in case it is seen to insult the British? Where does it leave ‘The Merchant of Venice’, ‘Carmen’, ‘Les Miserables’, all war films, television programmes about Africa, or Australia, or even the US itself? Do we stop eating curry, pizza, Chinese takeaways . . . ?

The proponents of ‘cultural appropriation’ (by which they seem rather to mean ‘misappropriation’) are sincere in their beliefs, and feel they are protecting the integrity of other nations (though one cannot help thinking that by doing so they are guilty themselves of a certain paternalism). But take it to its logical extreme and modern culture would be almost impossible.

And where would it leave architecture, the usual subject of this column? How would we live without the foreign influence on our buildings?

Britain in particular has always been a mongrel when it comes to architecture. From at least the time of the first Roman invasion we have been subject to, and have absorbed, a great many architectural influences. The Romans were the conquering race, of course, so they brought with them their own style of building, which we can still see from the remains of their structures – think of the Multangular Tower in York, for example, or the palace at Fishbourne in West Sussex – or, nearer to us, the mosaic pavements at Aldborough.

After the Romans left we had Anglo-Saxon and Viking invaders, all of whom brought their own styles with them – there is little left for us to see except for some Saxon churches, like Kirk Hammerton near York and Escomb in Country Durham – but their influence was felt in later buildings, not least in the semi-circular arches that in England we call the ‘Norman’ style. And, of course, the Normans were originally Vikings.

So what if ‘cultural appropriation’ meant that Saxon and Norman architecture was banned as being not sufficiently respectful of its origins? Would we have to lose Durham Cathedral, the Tower of London, other cathedrals, churches, castles and manor houses throughout Britain? Parts of Ripon Cathedral would go, too, including St Wilfrid’s Crypt and two of the four arches of the crossing.

But could we perhaps keep the Gothic parts? Probably not. Although there is a good case for saying the pointed arch, the most characteristic sign of Gothic architecture, was invented for the roof vaults of Durham Cathedral, it was really a French invention, particularly developed in the early 12th century by Abbot Suger at the abbey of St Denys. It also has influences from German and Italy. We can’t claim it as a native British style – so most of it has to go.

We could, perhaps, make an exception for the Perpendicular style, which was definitely an English development; so although Ripon Cathedral might need to lose its towers, the east end and some of the crossing, we may salvage the nave aisles and a few other bits of the structure. Elsewhere, we’d lose Markenfield Hall and many of our ancient churches.

Then comes the Renaissance, and we’re back to the foreign influences – Roman and Greek architecture filtered through Italy. No hope for that either, nor for the Classical revival that swept Britain in the 17th and 18th centuries. Ripon Town Hall would have to go; indeed, the whole Market Square, which the architect Hawksmoor laid out as a Roman Piazza with its central obelisk, is a candidate for removal on cultural grounds, too. Even modest Georgian houses in the Palladian style would be swept away in this zeal for cleansing the nation of its cultural sins.

And despite the arguments of the 19th century Gothic Revival architects that their style was the real native architecture of Britain, and the only Christian style, we’ve already seen its foreign antecedents, so all that would have to go, too – farewell St Wilfrid’s Church and Holy Trinity Church, for a start.

Perhaps we’re allowed to keep our 20th-century architecture. Well, maybe. But we may detect traces of German influence from Walter Gropius and the Bauhaus and from Mies van der Rohe, American from Frank Lloyd Wright, or French in Art Deco, so perhaps the architecture of the last century’s not safe, either.

So what have we left? Not a great deal, it seems. Perhaps our modest houses might be safe (better take a critical look at yours, just to be sure) and the boring brick boxes that house many commercial premises today may be spared too. This is not a very appetising prospect.

Let’s hope, therefore that those who would criticise our ‘cultural appropriation’ of the heritage of other nations come to appreciate that virtually all civilisations take influences from their neighbours, their conquerors and those they conquer or trade with. However high-minded they think they are being, the critics are, on most of these matters, probably misguided; our buildings are likely to be safe from them.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.