At the beginning of March members of Ripon Civic Society heard a talk on the model village of New Earswick, built from 1902 onwards by the Rowntrees as an enlightened and modern estate of houses and supporting facilities.
But New Earswick was by no means the first model village to be built in Yorkshire. For more than 250 years progressive (or sometimes self-serving) landowners have provided housing for their workers – or as alternatives to cottages that were in the way of their ambitions.
The earliest plan for a new village that has survived anywhere in England was provided in about 1699 for the Earl of Carlisle’s new Castle Howard by George London, the Royal Gardener. It’s significant that it was a gardener who came up with the plan; the new village, which would have had an unusual circular layout, would have replaced the ancient village of Henderskelfe, which was in the way of London’s scheme for a grander approach to the great house and a more magnificent landscape. The replacement settlement was not built, however; we must assume that the displaced villagers had to shift for themselves.
At Harewood the village was removed from the park in about 1760, but the villagers fared better than those at Henderskelfe, for the 1st Earl of Harewood provided them with new homes in grand terraces, designed by John Carr, which still make an imposing introduction to the great house. The house sizes emphasised the social status of the occupants; the village doctor, for example, had a distinctly larger house than the norm.
Although Harewood had some pretensions to looking after the social welfare of its inhabitants, Yorkshire’s first attempt to create an ideal community came from the Moravians, the German Protestants whose first village in Britain was at Fulneck, just outside Leeds. Built in 1748 and based on their original settlement at Herrnhut in Germany, its long terrace, which incorporates school and religious buildings, and the associated housing for the brethren, cost the enormous sum of £15,000, largely because of its difficult sloping site.
Fulneck was unique in Yorkshire as a cooperative venture, in which all had a share in the common good. By the beginning of the nineteenth century the Industrial Revolution had begun to make its mark, and although there were still landowners like the Ingilbys at Ripley Castle who in 1827 could rebuild the village at their gate in a jolly Tudor style for its picturesque qualities, it was the great mill owners who dominated new housing policy in the next decades.
Colonel Edward Akroyd, MP for Halifax, had a genuine desire to help his employees by housing them in decent conditions. In his village of Akroydon, built between 1861 and 1863, he tried to ensure a good social mix, selling the houses (which could be purchased with help from the Colonel) at prices from £100 to £250. They were not back to back, and all faced a grassy square with trees and a central feature like a medieval market cross. The whole arrangement was supervised by Sir Gilbert Scott, whose church of All Souls nearby still has a statue of Colonel Akroyd standing beside it.
Soon, other industrialists recognised that that looking after the workforce was both a moral duty and financially advantageous. Sir Titus Salt’s model village, Saltaire, was set in open countryside, well away from industrial Bradford. First, in 1850, he built his mill, and then came the houses, by 1863 almost 800 of them, mostly set in a grid pattern, but with wide streets and back alleys. Rents were in accord with house size – which in turn went with social status.
Salt provided an institute, almshouses, hospital, steam laundry and canteen, everything he thought his workers needed – except a pub, to which he was implacably opposed. Its countryside setting, and the park Salt provided just across the river, made it a pleasant and successful village. With it, he anticipated the Garden City movement of the end of the 19th century.
The chief theorist of the movement was Ebenezer Howard, whose book, ‘Garden Cities of Tomorrow’, set the standard for new communities in the twentieth century. They would be ‘designed for healthy living and industry; of a size that makes possible a full measure of social life, but not bigger; surrounded by a permanent belt of rural land; the whole of the land being held in public ownership or held in trust for the community’.
Yorkshire developed no true Garden City, like Letchworth or Welwyn; but it has New Earswick, one of the most successful of new villages laid out on the same principles.
Joseph Rowntree built New Earswick as a direct response to the depths of poverty he saw in York. It was not to be a company village: not all the villagers worked at the nearby Rowntree Cocoa Works. Rowntree’s architects were Unwin and Parker, and New Earswick was started in 1902 with 28 houses, designed in the English cottage style. Since much expanded, the village still keeps faith with the original vision pioneered by Rowntree and Unwin; the houses are well spaced and surrounded with generous planting, many of the streets are cul-de-sacs and there is good playing space for children.
There are lessons to be learned from such communities by the developers who look to create new ‘communities’ today. They should look at siting them away from existing communities, instead of endlessly expanding older settlements. They should provide generous countryside for recreation for both body and soul, ensure local management, guarantee that the layout, landscaping and architecture are of the best possible quality, and make good provision for houses that a wide range of people, not just the wealthy middle classes, can afford. Today’s preoccupations with carbon footprint also mean that environmental soundness and energy efficiency must be high priorities, and that inexpensive public transport is accessible and efficient.
The days of the paternalistic developer, the likes of Ackroyd and Salt, are long over. Those who build the new villages for tomorrow will need to balance commercial considerations with social well-being. For those who realise that the final figure in a balance sheet is only half the story, there is the opportunity to build the better communities of tomorrow.
