In 1965 the comedian Spike Milligan wrote a satirical article under the headline ‘Pull Down St Paul’s’. In it he suggested that Sir Christopher Wren’s cathedral be demolished so that passers-by would have an unhampered view from which to appreciate the proposed Juxon House, a concrete office block designed by Sir William Holford as part of the redevelopment of St Paul’s Churchyard.
Milligan’s point was, of course, that modern building should respect architectural masterpieces. In the event, Paternoster Square at the west front of St Paul’s was built to designs by Holford and other architects. It was not liked – views of the cathedral’s façade up Ludgate Hill were partly obscured by the new structures.
Only 20 years after the scheme’s completion there were plans to redevelop the square in the post-modern style of the day; it was of this proposal that the Prince of Wales controversially said, ‘You have to give this much to the Luftwaffe. When it knocked down our buildings, it didn’t replace them with anything more offensive than rubble.’ This scheme was abandoned in favour of a pastiche neo-classical design favoured by the Prince; this was not built, either. In its current manifestation, Paternoster Square is a rebuilding from 2003 onwards to a masterplan by Sir William Whitfield.
Demolition of little-appreciated buildings has gone on ever since our ancestors began to construct shelters; and in our major cities it continues at what seems an increasingly-fast pace. Such haste can make for flawed judgement. There is a litany of what we should now consider nationally-important buildings that have been demolished either as a result of changing tastes or of royal or governmental whim (or, often, a combination of the two causes).
So we have lost, for example, Henry VIII’s great, if eccentric, Nonsuch Palace near Epsom, demolished on the orders of one of Charles II’s mistresses; much of Sir John Soane’s innovative and impressive Bank of England, rebuilt from 1921. Gone also are George’s Dance’s fearsomely-massive Newgate Goal (replaced by the Old Bailey), the Greek-style Euston Arch and, in Leeds, Sir Gilbert Scott’s Beckett’s Bank in Park Row. Many great churches have also vanished including, as noted before in this column, Holy Trinity in Bingley, designed by Norman Shaw and described by a perceptive critic with the words ‘no modern church I know is finer.’
And it’s that word ‘modern’ that brings us to the nub of the demolition question. Modern is a slippery word – modernity can be admired (though not by all, as Prince Charles has demonstrated), but our modernity is tomorrow’s old-fashioned or just plain ugly. As you might expect, there is a name for the process whereby a building loses its status. It is called ‘The Gordon Curve’.
The Curve was suggested in the 1930s by a conservationist from Baltimore in Maryland, Douglas Huntley Gordon. From his own observations of what was happening to the buildings in his city, he worked out that, if a new building is 100 per cent appreciated, such appreciation declines by 1.5 per cent each year. When it is seventy years old it warrants demolition. If it survives this critical moment, its stock then increases rapidly so that another 30 years later – in its centenary year – it will be back at 100 per cent and worthy of preservation.
We may think that the Gordon Curve has now sped up, certainly in our cities, where some buildings are lucky to survive twenty years before demolition (though that may be as much to poor construction as to changed aesthetic taste). And there is, too, another danger – that everything that does succeed in bottoming the Gordon Curve and attaining the sunny uplands of renewed appreciation is worth saving. This is plainly not the case – yet judging what is to be preserved and what demolished is, inevitably, a matter of the taste of the time; the Victorians despised and demolished Georgian buildings; for much of the 20th century Victorian architecture was hated. At the moment 1960s Brutalism is (mostly) disliked and much is being demolished. Future generations may look on us as architectural vandals at least equal to our forebears.
In a place the size of Ripon our buildings are much less under threat. There have, of course, been notable losses – the fine, ornate Claro Bank in the Market Square was replaced by the NatWest (the 70-year rule of the Gordon Curve was about right here); its replacement was later compromised by the insertion of a pseudo-Victorian shopfront in its lower façade. Lost, also, is the chapel at the former training college, with its hyperbolic roof and an interior typical of its 1963 date.
Demolition is now under way on many of the flats at the top of Allhallowgate. They are to be replaced with cottages more in keeping with the rest of the street, and with the Workhouse opposite. As minor buildings these can, perhaps, be allowed to vanish, as long as there is sufficient record of their existence in terms of photographs and archives.
Active demolition is one thing; demolition by attrition is quite another. A number of Ripon buildings are currently under threat from neglect; the former Station Hotel on North Road, the Maltings on Ure Bank Top and the small building behind Sainsbury’s that may have been a maltings or a laundry all come into that category. The former Girls’ High School on the College site has been stripped of some of its roof tiles, which cannot be good for the structure (though there is new planning application for this building).
Allowing a building to become dangerous and then ask for its demolition is common, but local authorities have powers to force owners to take care of such buildings. Ripon Civic Society is active in encouraging the care of these and other threatened structures in and around the city – and welcomes your support and encouragement in its work.
