DESIGN – A MATTER OF TASTE?

One of William Morris’s most famous dictums is ‘Have nothing in your house that you do not know to be useful, or believe to be beautiful.’

Morris spent much of his life talking about design. For him, a taste for good design was something that comes naturally, but he recognised that not everyone had it. There is a story that when, as a young man of 17, he visited the 1851 Great Exhibition at the Crystal Palace he refused to enter, because of the vulgarity of nearly all the designs.

We can sympathise if we look at illustrations of what was on display. Mid-Victorian ingenuity at its worst, we may think – hideous carpets, over-decorated cutlery, teapots and vases encrusted with moulded flowers, shells, or semi-clad figures. It’s not surprising that Morris found the whole thing repulsive. He wanted logic and simplicity in design.

But talking about design is never easy. Our tastes must differ, and taste is something that is very personal. So is design just a matter of taste? Well, maybe. But there are some general principles of design, and especially design for buildings, that we can perhaps share – though, of course, taste in design changes with time.

It used to be so easy in the past, we tend to think; design was something universal (or at least, common, in the West). You designed and built in the style of your age. If you were Greek, you knew the columns and the architraves that were in use; you might tweak them a little if you were feeling adventurous, but you built nothing that would frighten the Parthenon horses. Romans, too, knew their style – and they had the writings of the late-Roman architect Vitruvius to keep them on the straight and narrow.

The builders of the Middle Ages began with a sort of Roman style – the Romanesque, with semi-circular arches and with massive columns to take the weight of their great buildings. Eventually the Gothic pointed arch took over – it was quickly recognised as a technical advance, and held sway in its various forms for several centuries.

But then, you might argue, the rot set in. The Renaissance didn’t develop Gothic, but turned backwards to classical styles. We might have had an advanced Gothic style that relied on a development of English Perpendicular – but it all got swept away by the revival of Roman styles.

In England Inigo Jones, Wren and Vanbrugh built in the Roman tradition. They were influenced by the Italians, especially by Palladio, who, in 18th-century Britain, became the one to copy. And in the 19th century, all these styles came together in an eclectic free-for-all. There were, of course, some who tried to break away – we have only to recall Paxton’s Crystal Palace (whatever Morris thought about its contents) or the great railway sheds like St Pancras – but these tended to be the work of engineers.

And through the 20th century we have found that there has been a restless search for a new style – Art Nouveau, Art Deco, Jazz-Modern, Fascist. At one stage it seemed the engineers were going to triumph, freeing design from the constraints of load-bearing walls. Skyscrapers, triumphs of steel and glass, soared into the sky.

But for a time we lost our way, perhaps. Brutalism arrived in the 1960s, and we joyously built in shuttered concrete. Then we reacted against that, and found the rectangular box again, this time covered in mirror glass or showing all its innards on its exterior. There are some great 20th-century buildings – ones that we might all recognise as being exemplars of their time (though that’s not necessarily the same thing, of course). But for the most part we have had to put up with mediocrity rather than genius.

And what of today? Have we reached a consensus about what constitutes modern design? Of course not. What we think of as good design today will quite probably be ridiculed in the future – and we may also find that what we dismiss today is the masterpiece of tomorrow.

So where does that leave us? Should we not try to have a view of what constitutes good design? Must we throw in the towel and make life easier for ourselves by saying ‘anything goes’? Well, no. Even though we may lack an all-pervading aesthetic for 21st-century design, and even though there is never going to be a total consensus on what we should be aiming for, we need to have some idea of our own tastes. It may be that most of us can recognise bad design, or design that leaves something to be desired. It’s always easy to tell when something is just plain bad. Or even if it’s not bad in itself, it may be bad in its context.

In our large cities it is possible for experimentation and for mistakes. But city buildings are often transitory – buildings of the 21st century may replace 1960s buildings that were themselves replacements of 30s buildings, which replaced Victorian structures.

Perhaps we should be more aware of design in smaller settlements – like Ripon – where the scale of buildings may be less but their impact may be greater. In such places we cannot always rely on rapid turnover – what’s built today will be there for at least two or three generations. That often makes our local authority planners very timid in approving anything that smacks of innovation – they want the same again, please – inoffensive pastiche houses, self-effacing commercial buildings that disappear into the background. But is this what we should be aiming for?

The role of Civic Societies, like Ripon’s, is to encourage protest against the mediocre. We need to champion good modern design and not allow authorities to get away with their own pet projects when they lack any sort of design quality. We may not always get it right, but we should not cease to keep our planners up to the mark as far as we can.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.