Last week’s column looked at the winners in Ripon Civic Society’s Awards – but managed only a brief mention of the other shortlisted projects, all of which were given certificates for being Highly Commended or Commended. So this week we’ll look at them – projects that were very worthy of their place in the final judging.
In the ‘Best New Building’ category, in which the Award went to The Orchards residential mental health care facility on Princess Close, there was one other shortlisted candidate. This was Cathedral Court, the new housing on semi-derelict land on Water Skellgate. The developer, Meridien Homes, has designed and built a small community of attractive, small-scale houses that are well-detailed and proportioned. They have much improved the look of Water Skellgate, which until recently had been looking tired and somewhat run-down. The Civic Society gave the scheme a commendation.
There were several candidates for the category of ‘Best Restored Building’. The winner, as noted in last week’s column, was Highfield Coach House, which also went on to win the Sustainability Award and the Helen Whitehead Salver for the Best Project. But another restored coach house also caught the attention of the Society’s judges, this one on Blossomgate. This small building had been decaying for many years before its possibilities were spotted and it was developed into an office for Vinden Estates.
The restoration respects the integrity of the building, with minimum intervention, and makes excellent use of the interior space, with a small gallery. This restoration was pointed out by many people, and the Society was delighted to give it a Highly Commended certificate.
St John’s Church, Bondgate was also Highly Commended. This small Victorian church has been transformed by an imaginative restoration and re-ordering. The pews have been removed, the dark woodwork painted in light colours, and underfloor heating and adaptable lighting has been installed. The result is an attractive and flexible space for church and community use, that still respects the sacred use of the building.
Something completely different was the recipient of a commended certificate for restoration; this was the work by the National Trust on two adjacent ice houses in the deer park at Studley Royal. Built in the days before refrigerators to store blocks of naturally-formed ice that could be used in the great house, the ice houses had been derelict for many years and were in a dangerous state. The restoration has seen sensitive repairs to the brickwork – the domed brick roofs and the deep pits below them – and the replacement of the clay and turf cappings.
There was also commendation for the repair and restoration of the early Victorian house at 82/83 North Street; this is a building that is not seen to its best advantage because of later structures – now a shop and restaurant – built in its front garden. Nevertheless, its owners have taken the trouble to restore its windows in an appropriate way, both on the front and rear elevations, and to re-slate the roof, as well as to repaint the whole façade. It is a good example of the care that ought to be taken on all such listed buildings.
In the ‘Best Environmental Improvement’ category, won by the imaginative planting scheme at the Orchards, there was a commendation for the mural artwork in the ginnel beside Lockwoods Restaurant in North Street. This is an attractive and colourful multi-panel artwork, designed by local school pupils on the theme of Ripon’s links with Lewis Carroll’s Alice. It particularly brightens up the view from the restaurant’s side windows.
The ‘Best Shop Front’ category, won by two shops in Masham, also saw ‘Treasure and Relish’ – the café and bookshop in High Skellgate – being awarded a ‘Highly Commended’ certificate for the care with which this traditional Ripon shopfront has been restored and subtly repainted. And the new entrance at the rear of the Yorkshire Trading store, which gives access to the store from the bus station and improves the look of that area of the city centre, was also commended.
Ripon Civic Society believes that it is important to encourage and sustain good craftsmanship. The Craftsmanship Shield for the winners of this category was given for the new gargoyles at Ripon Cathedral, but the Society was pleased to be able to highly commend two other examples of good craftsmanship.
One was the restoration and reconstruction of the Victorian tiling in the sanctuary of St John’s Church, Bondgate; this had been badly damaged by later changes, so few of the original tiles could be rescued; yet the completed work looks as perfect as it would have been when the church first opened. The other project was the Crown Hotel sign that once stood on the outside of what is now Sainsbury’s store, but which fell and broke into many pieces two years ago. The difficult restoration was carried out by Ripon Museum Trust volunteer Fred Lee, and was paid for by Sainsbury’s, which has now allowed it to be placed inside the building.
The final category, Sustainability, was won by Highfield Coach House, but the Society was pleased to be able to give the National Trust a second certificate, Highly Commended, for its installation of a ground source heating system for the Visitor Centre at Fountains Abbey. Like many such projects, it is hidden away – in this case it consists of 6,000 metres of fluid-filled tubing below the Visitor Centre car park. The fluid absorbs heat from the ground; a heat exchanger raises the temperature and provides enough heat for the building, with more to sell to make extra funds for work on the estate.
All the projects recognised by the Civic Society’s Awards are worthy of their recognition, so why not go and see them? You may find pointers for the future in the care and attention that all have taken in their preparation and completion.
