‘The rich man in his castle
The poor man at his gate
God made them high and lowly
And ordered their estate.’
In these more egalitarian days we no longer sing this verse from that favourite school hymn of the past, ‘All things bright and beautiful’. But when Mrs C F Alexander of Derry wrote the words in 1848, this was accepted as the order of things; the poor lived outside the castle gates, and looked up to the rich man who inhabited that noble pile – and God had ordained that it should be so.
But why was it accepted that the rich man should live in a castle at all? After all, by the 19th century, few rich people would actually live in a fortified building; most would inhabit grand houses rather than castles, probably calling their home a Hall or, more modestly, a Grange, perhaps.
But the idea that a castle was the appropriate place for a rich man had persisted from the earliest times, when feuding barons fortified themselves behind strong walls, or the monarch ordered castles to be built to protect the country from external enemies. In Britain we can look back to the fortified hilltops of the Iron Age, and to the forts of the Romans; York’s Multangular Tower and Richborough Roman Fort in Kent are both good surviving examples of the size of these structures.
But we really start with castles – as opposed to forts – in Britain with the Norman invasion of 1066. All schoolchildren used to learn about the motte-and-bailey castles – originally of wood, but soon replaced with stone – that the Normans erected to subdue the English. The huge square keeps of the Normans – a prime example is that at Richmond – were a very visible sign of the power of the new overlords.
Castles soon developed in sophistication; the main keep was supplemented by heavily-defended curtain walls; sometimes (especially in English castles) there was a combined keep and gateway – as at Dunstanburgh Castle in Northumberland. Then came concentric rings of walls, so that even if the enemy penetrated the outer walls they would be trapped and at the mercy of the defenders. Sometimes the entry progression through the sets of walls was particularly tortuous, so that invaders were disorientated and never knew from where the next arrow or spear – or vat of pitch – would descend upon them.
We know the name of at least one of the masterminds behind British castles. He was James of St George (originally from Savoy) who worked for King Edward I on castles to subdue the Welsh, including Rhuddlan, Conwy and Caernarfon, as well as his planning masterwork at Harlech.
Later castles displayed variations on the earlier; plans were increasingly polygonal, so that arrows could be shot obliquely along the walls at besiegers. But eventually, as times became more peaceful, castles started to be built as much for comfort as for defence. The giveaway on many of these are the large, outward-facing windows, which would have been too vulnerable in earlier times. The gates become welcoming places rather than showing a suspicious military face to anyone approaching.
By Renaissance times it was possible to have a castle that was hardly defensive at all, or to adapt an old castle so that it fitted with new ideas of comfort. The Norman Kenilworth Castle in Warwickshire was refashioned in the 1570s by the Earl of Leicester to receive Queen Elizabeth in lavish style. The country was, generally, at peace, and it was only on the shores of our island that defences were needed, in the latest style – no more huge castles but smaller ones, like Pendennis and St Mawes in Cornwall, or Deal in Kent, which were essentially gun platforms. Sometimes buildings were hardly noticeable – it was great geometric defences like those that survive at Berwick-upon-Tweed that were important.
But after 1603, when James VI of Scotland became James I of England, too, even such defences became unnecessary, and it was possible to look back on the old castles with a romantic eye. One of the first to do so was Sir John Vanbrugh. Admittedly Castle Howard pays tribute to the past only in its name, but Vanbrugh’s own house in Greenwich, which he named Vanbrugh Castle, has turrets and towers in best castle style. And by 1764, when Horace Walpole’s Gothick novel ‘The Castle of Otranto’ was published, castle styles were fashionable again. Indeed, even in the 1740s the Duke of Argyll was busy building himself a country house in the form of a castle at his seat of Inveraray, to designs by Roger Morris; it was given its conical towers a century or so later.
In the 1820s it was fashionable to add a tower to your Gothicised house – Swinton Castle is a good local example – but by the middle of the 19th century there were attempts to build medieval-style castles that nevertheless were comfortable country houses. The red-sandstone Peckforton Castle in Cheshire looks formidable from the outside, but its interior is spacious and comfortable – it is now, like Swinton Castle, an hotel.
William Burges was commissioned by the Marquess of Bute to extend his castle at Cardiff and to restore (almost from the ground) the nearby Castell Coch; both are in Burges’s elaborate and colourful style. Other medieval castles were reinstated too, including Bamburgh, work done for Sir William Armstrong.
What is considered to be the last castle in Britain was built for Sir Julius Drewe, owner of the Home and Colonial Stores, at Drewsteignton in Devon. Designed by Sir Edwin Lutyens, it is Castle Drogo; impressive though it looks, it is now costing the National Trust millions to repair, after less than a century of use. So the rich man in his castle these days needs to be even richer than ever, while the poor man at his gates is these days helping, with his visitor admission fees, to keep the castle in good repair.
