In 1947 W H Auden published a long poem called ‘The Age of Anxiety’; it inspired Leonard Bernstein to write a symphony with the same title. For Auden, the post-war world was his ‘Age of Anxiety’ – but architecture shows that past ages were equally beset with worries and fears.
What we might call the ‘Architecture of Anxiety’ has a very long history; our most primitive ancestors probably took the trouble to ensure that their shelters, however temporary, would be defended as well as possible from wild beasts, or possibly from other humans.
In prehistoric times tribes would gather together to construct defensive earthworks on the tops of hills to ensure that they had both a distant view of any approaching enemy and a good, defensible position from which to fight them. These are evidence of an unsure and probably unstable age, when it paid to take great care of how you protected yourself.
Such fortifications are hardly architecture, perhaps. Something that could certainly be classified so, however, are the brochs of Scotland. Constructed from the 1st Century BC, brochs were tall, circular defensive towers that could be up to 50 feet high. Inside, they had double walls with staircases between to allow the inhabitants to access a series of wooden floors and to keep a sharp lookout from the roof. The largest surviving of the brochs is on the island of Mousa in Shetland; it has just one entrance, leading to a long, low passage that could be barred in case of attack.
When the Romans arrived in Britain, they came, it appeared, with all the certainty of conquerors. They marched across the land, building their playing-card-shaped forts and laying down their straight roads, masters, it seemed, of all they surveyed. But even the Romans didn’t have it all their own way; when Boudicca, Queen of Iceni, revolted in AD60 (or possibly 61) she destroyed the Roman settlements later called Colchester, St Albans and London, leading to perhaps 80,000 deaths before her final defeat.
Thereafter, though the Romans founded these cities and added new ones, including York and Lincoln, there was always, it seems, a lingering anxiety about security. All their cities and many towns were given secure walls, either of wooden-palisaded earthworks or of stone; parts of the Roman York wall survive beneath the medieval walls.
The greatest of the Roman walls was, of course, that built by Hadrian. Begun in AD122, its construction was as much a result of anxiety as of power. Despite forays into Scotland, by the 2nd century the emperor had cut his losses and decided to demarcate a set boundary with the wall. Even if, as modern thinking suggests, the wall was a means of regulating passage to and fro from the border of empire rather than a defensive bulwark, there can be little doubt that it represented a need to ensure the border’s security from possible hostile forces to the north.
It can be argued that the series of strong castles that Edward I built in north Wales after his invasion in 1282 were also both a show of power (equivalent to a parade of missiles in Moscow or Pyongyang today) and an admission that there were still enemies whom it was wise to protect against.
Scots, too, were a source of anxiety, and the north of England was particularly vulnerable. There were incursions throughout the Middle Ages; in the early 14th century Ripon Minster’s east end apparently received extra protection, with a battlemented projection between the buttresses below the east window; it was removed when Edward Blore restored the building in the early part of the 19th century.
Medieval kings may have considered the Welsh and the Scots as ‘foreign’ nations, but for Henry VIII and for Elizabeth I the threats were chiefly from across the Channel. Henry responded to threats of invasion from France and Spain by ordering the construction of forts on vulnerable coasts. Between 1539 and 1547 as series of distinctive multi-lobed forts appeared, the earliest at Walmer and Deal in Kent. And from 1560 Elizabeth ordered the construction of new, up-to-date ramparts at Berwick-upon-Tweed, where the perceived threat was from both the Scots and their allies the French.
The French were again the enemy when the Napoleonic Wars threatened the country. Anxiety about invasion resulted in the strengthening or building of forts along the coast (Paull Fort near Hull and Landguard Fort in Felixstowe are good examples) and the construction of Martello Towers along the coast from Orkney to Cornwall.
Twentieth-century anxiety about foreign invasion resulted in extra coastal defences, from pillboxes and road barriers to anti-tank blocks and artillery emplacements, many of which can still be seen. And, post-war, the Cold War threat of nuclear weapons saw bunkers being built, including monitoring stations like that at Acomb in York.
Are we free of such anxieties today? Do we no longer express such fears in our buildings? Of course we do. Anyone who lives in a gated community is acknowledging some form of anxiety about the uncertainty of modern life and the possibly-hostile forces around us.
Local authorities purchase benches for the streets that allow people to sit for short periods but are designed to be so uncomfortable as to prevent homeless people from sleeping on them. They also put bolts or even spikes on ledges when someone might conceivably want to lie down.
And then there is the multiplicity of health and safety rules that result in the barriers and handrails, warning signs and CCTV that are all around us; these could even be thought to increase our anxiety by suggesting dangers we had not considered before and which common sense would have led most of us to beware anyway.
Perhaps Auden was premature in believing that the ‘Age of Anxiety’ was the late 1940s; maybe we are still living in it, and architecture is helping to sustain our anxiety.
