There have been two contrasting television series recently that dealt with architecture. One was ‘Climbing Great Buildings’. This saw Dr Jonathan Foyle, who spoke at a talk organised by Ripon Civic Society earlier this year, donning mountaineering gear to examine at close hand some of the country’s iconic buildings. It involved not just climbing up the sides of such buildings as Durham and Lincoln Cathedrals, Burghley House and the St Pancras Hotel, but also swinging on ropes into vast interiors or, memorably, descending from the dome to the floor of St Paul’s Cathedral.
When he wasn’t concentrating too hard on his climbing techniques and on his fear of the height above or the void below, Dr Foyle analysed some of the building techniques that had gone into the construction of the buildings, explained some of the technical terms architects use and said a little about why the buildings had been constructed.
There has been correspondence, notably in ‘Radio Times’ about what the climbing added to the architectural history. It did, however, provide some interesting points of view, and was certainly one way of getting the viewer interested in a subject that finds it hard to compete with ‘The X Factor’ or ‘Strictly Come Dancing’.
The other programme in many ways could not have been more different. It could easily have been overlooked, as it was tucked away in the recesses of BBC4’s schedules, but it was well worth tracking down. ‘Churches: How to read them’ was presented by author Dr Richard Taylor, who has spent his life looking at our churches from all angles – and not just architectural ones.
Dr Taylor believes that we have lost the key to understanding exactly what motivated our ancestors to build and furnish churches in the way they did, and how they used them. This may sound dull – shades both of the cataloguing style of the Pevsner ‘Buildings’ of England’ guides and of those earnest early 20th century guidebooks that told you how many poppyheads and cresset stones a church had, but never told you what they actually were.
This is not the way of Dr Taylor. Without recourse to cataloguing or antiquarianism (or to ropes and carabiners) he spoke in his series with enthusiasm and clarity about the beliefs of our ancestors, of the ways in which organised religion changed, and about the way that churches changed, too. His series took us from the Anglo-Saxon church to the modern day, showing how throughout the ages buildings have been adapted to worship and how what remains today can tell us of the past.
This is not the first time, of course, that such an approach has been tried, not just with churches but with other architecture-related subjects, too. Pevsner himself attempted something along these lines in his 1976 book ‘A History of Building Types’, where he traced the development of different types of building (town halls, theatres, hospitals and prisons among them) to show how different uses demanded different solutions.
Two years after Pevsner’s book came Mark Girouard’s important study ‘Life in the English Country House’. From it we learned just how our country houses were lived in, from medieval times to the Second World War. It is a story of shifting values, attempts to hang on to feudal ways, and the assertion of the middle classes and the loss of subservience. But it is also the story of why rooms were used for certain purposes, and why they were decorated in particular ways.
To take a single example, the dado rail, much loved by interior decorators a few years ago, has its origins in the chair rail along the walls of country houses in the 18th century. It was to protect the walls from the backs of the chairs, which would be ranged along the sides of the room when not in use. If you wanted to take tea, or sit and chat, servants would bring the chairs to wherever you needed them, returning them to the wall after you had left. It was only in Victorian times that furniture was arranged in the rooms permanently.
There is a new book that takes the story to a more domestic level – Bill Bryson’s ‘At Home’. Subtitled ‘A Short History of Private Life’, the book is in typically-amusing Bryson style and looks at what smaller houses are like and why we use the rooms as we do.
All these are different ways of looking at buildings and their use. And they are techniques that can be applied to the cityscape, too. We can look at Ripon from the Foyle viewpoint (though perhaps not physically climbing all over it!) to obtain the big picture. We can use Dr Taylor’s technique so that we really understand what lies behind the street plan, the look of the buildings and the uses to which our buildings are put. And we can use the Girouard and Bryson methods to examine how people over the generations have used and changed the houses, shops, public buildings, offices and all the other structures of our city.
When we do so, we will learn a great deal about Ripon and what we need to care for. It’s a process that has begun, and will continue – there is never an end to learning!
