David Winpenny has seen the lights about lights
Here’s a question that might flummox even the most dedicated of pub quiz fans. For what invention is the Nottingham engineer John Peake Knight famous, and why did it take more than 40 years for his invention to be widely introduced?
If you already know the answer, you may be a traffic engineer – or very well read. For the rest, here’s the answer. John Peake Knight was a railwayman. Born in 1825, he was of the railway generation, coming to maturity along with the railway system. He left school at 12 to work on the railways, and by the age of 25 he was Superintendent of the South Eastern Railway.
His invention came when he was 37. As an expert on railway signalling, it occurred to him that a similar system could work for the very heavy traffic on the nation’s roads. He proposed to the Metropolitan Police a system that used semaphore arms by day and coloured lights illuminated by gas at night. It took three years, but eventually a set was installed just outside the Houses of Parliament, at the junction of Great George Street and Bridge Street on 10 December 1868. The lights required a policeman to operate them.
The system lasted all of 23 days. On 2 January 1869 a gas leak caused them to explode, causing fatal injuries to the duty policeman. Knight’s experiment was over. It was another 43 years before another policeman, in Salt Lake City, Utah, came up with the idea again, using red and green lights. There were traffic lights in Cleveland, Ohio by 1914, and by 1917 interconnected sets, run by a central switch, were installed back in Salt Lake City.
The idea reached England in 1927, when automated lights were erected in Princess Square in Wolverhampton – the event is now marked with a Wolverhampton Civic Society plaque. They were at first known as ‘Robots’ – pronounced ‘roh-bohs’ – and were considered very modern.
Since then, traffic lights have proliferated. In the last 10 years the number in London has increased by a third. In Ripon, too, new sets have appeared in quite a few locations, and the rate of increase may well match that of the capital.
But new thinking is suggesting that this may not be a good thing. Traffic lights may have had their time. Regulating the flow of traffic and the passage of vehicles is, of course, necessary – but are traffic lights the best way?
There is actually little evidence in favour of them. Traffic managers like lights because lights manage traffic for them. Yet often motorists dislike them. They delay journeys, cause tailbacks and increase pollution. Anyone who has been stuck at the lights at the end of Low Skellgate will know the feeling.
Yet, you may argue, traffic lights, whatever their disadvantages, make the roads safer. But do they? Evidence suggests the opposite. In the town of Drachten in northern Holland all the traffic lights have been removed. The result has been that the number of accidents to motorists, cyclists and pedestrians has dropped dramatically. Similar changes have been made in Sweden and Denmark, where removing traffic lights has virtually eliminated fatal accidents at junctions. And experience has shown that roundabouts are a much better way of making junctions safer – the traffic moves, but does so more slowly.
In September last year a four-week experiment was begun in Portishead, outside Bristol. Traffic lights at one of the town’s busiest junctions were switched off. The doom-sayers were out in force, predicting mayhem and carnage. But what actually happened?
Traffic flowed freely. Motorists who had previously only looked at the lights now looked at each other, and at cyclists and pedestrians. They were much more aware of safety and much more considerate, knowing that they shared road-space. The flow of traffic improved remarkably, and traffic queues and the consequent pollution became a thing of the past. When the junction was controlled by £600,000-worth of traffic lights it allowed 1700 vehicles an hour through. Without the lights, numbers were more than 2,000, but with no congestion. As a result the lights have never been switched back on. In the following eight months there were just two minor shunts and no injuries to motorists or pedestrians.
It was not absolutely straightforward, of course. There are still concerns from people who are blind or partially sighted, or otherwise disabled. But these can be overcome by sensitive planning of road spaces and, as commentators have said, driver education. The same Portishead people who said it would never work now say that using the junction is ‘an absolute pleasure’ and that they ‘can’t believe the difference.’
Even in London, some traffic lights are to be removed, and others switched off at all times except for rush hours. And what can happen in London and Portishead, as well as in other places, could happen in Ripon. There may be plausible arguments for some of the sets of traffic lights – around the Clock Tower at the end of Palace Road, perhaps – but others could be re-examined. Maybe that way we could return polite driving and consideration to our streets, cut down accidents and reduce pollution. Let’s at least give a green light to considering the matter carefully!
• For more information about the Portishead changes see http://www.boreme.com/boreme/funny-2010/portishead-no-traffic-lights-experiment-p1.php
