Fashion is always looking for something different – even if different only means a revival of a rose-tinted past. The 1950s teddy boys looked back to Edwardian dandyism. Current fashions, we are told, look back to the 1970s and 1980s as much as they look forward.
There is fashion, too, in architecture. Often this fashion is characterised by a complete rejection of the last phase of design – but looks back to the time before. It was not always thus, of course. Until the Renaissance, builders built in the current style; they would have seen it as very odd to have tried to copy the styles of the past. The very few exceptions to this – for example at Westminster Abbey where the nave was completed in a style that matched (but did not slavishly copy) earlier work – were undertaken for very specific reasons.
But then came ‘architects’ – a breed hitherto unknown. Within a century they had taken over from the skilled master masons and were dictating the styles. Some of the results of this transition were awkward; look, for example at Fountains Hall, where the Renaissance style of classical columns comes head to head with late Gothic in an engaging but ungainly hotchpotch of a building.
The classical styles reigned in Britain very roughly from 1650 to 1770. Its different manifestations – Baroque, rococo, Palladian, neo-classical, even Etruscan – were all interpretations of the architecture of the Greeks and Romans. Ripon’s Town Hall is a typical (if late) example. And even if there were no columns or pediments, there was classical proportion in the buildings, in the relationship of window to wall, for example. Any of Ripon’s many Georgian buildings will give you the idea.
And then came the 19th century. To us, it seems to have been a time when, architecturally, anything went. Classical design still continues, though it often became heavy, not to say coarse, in its details. There was a revival of the Elizabethan style, led by the decision of the parliamentary authorities after the 1834 fire that destroyed the Houses of Parliament, that the replacement had to be in ‘Elizabethan or Gothic’ architectural styles. The decision was taken by a committee headed by Earl de Grey, uncle of the First Marquess of Ripon.
Much of the detail of the Westminster building was deigned by Augustus Pugin, whose passion was Gothic. He hated classical and Renaissance styles (‘new and degenerate’) and believed that Gothic was the only Christian style. Pugin’s ideas were expressed with determination, not to say fanaticism, and were taken up by others, among them Gilbert Scott, who restored Ripon Cathedral between 1865 and 1875.
Originally a dull architect of workhouses, Scott read Pugin’s works ‘and I suddenly found myself like a person awakened from a long feverish dream’; he thereafter devoted himself to Gothic architecture. The example of Scott and his contemporary architects meant that much more attention was given to medieval buildings. ‘Restoration’ was the order of the day – restoration that too often led to over-enthusiastic change in ancient structures.
The fashion for restoration inevitably had its critics, not least among them William Morris, who founded the Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings in 1877. The Society to some extent halted the mania for restoration, which anyway was beginning to slow. Into the 20th century, architects were striving for new styles – and looking askance at the Georgian buildings. Even into the 1960s good Georgian houses – always designated as ‘boxes’ – were being demolished. And by then, of course, the Victorians had become the objects of derision, too.
Some architectural historians tried to get a little perspective on the matter. Nikolaus Pevsner was among them. In the late 1950s he began to lecture on Victorian architecture – to some derision. At one lecture he had to stop to tell the audience that his talk wasn’t meant to be funny; they couldn’t believe that anyone would want to take such a subject seriously.
So what of today? We are undoubtedly just as prejudiced as the people of the 19th and 20th centuries in our views on architecture – we just don’t recognise it as prejudice. There are some critics who are willing to praise new architecture, but for the majority of the population new architecture is incomprehensible. There are even fewer who would look favourably on much of the architecture put up in Britain between, say, 1950 and 1980 – like, say, the NatWest bank building in the Market Square.
Yet fashion will change again. There may already be thrusting young architectural historians preparing theses on the architecture of the 1980s in Britain. Like the audience at that talk by Pevsner, we may laugh at the idea, but it will come to be accepted as a serious academic subject just as much as Georgian and Victorian architecture is today.
And for the rest of us? We will no doubt continue to react to buildings in a way that is conditioned by fashion. But just occasionally, it may be salutatory to stop and consider the past and future of architecture in Ripon and beyond, so that we have some way of judging when changes and developments come along. Above all, let’s not have too narrow a view, either of what Ripon should look like, or, indeed, what its future should be.
• David Winpenny will be talking to Ripon Civic Society about Gilbert Scot’s restoration of Ripon Cathedral at its next meeting, on Thursday 3 February, staring at 7.30. The meeting is in Allhallowgate Methodist Church Hall; non-members pay £2.00. There will be an exhibition about the restoration in the Cathedral from 14 February to 6 March.
