Public spaces are important. That is probably a truism; life would be dull indeed – and probably impossible – without places where we could shop, meet friends or just pass through when we are going from one part of town to another. And what about places to gather as a community? Think of the crowds that gather around the London Eye or in Glasgow’s George Square on New Year’s Eve. Or of the great rallies in London that end with the marchers congregating in Trafalgar Square to hear speeches from the great and good – or from demagogues and rabble-rousers.
These are set pieces, when gatherings are pre-planned and happen at specific times. But there are other uses of such public spaces, too. Wander though any British town or city in decent weather and you’ll see people enjoying the open spaces. They may be standing and chatting, or sitting on conveniently-placed seats to watch the world go by. Children play and young people chat, or skateboard, or rollerblade . . . If there are enterprising restaurants and cafes there will be open-air seating where the clientele – and not just the smokers, either – can enjoy the sunshine.
There are places in Yorkshire that have enthusiastically embraced the idea of properly-considered public space – or are in the process of doing so. Inner Sheffield’s spaces, like the Peace Gardens and Devonshire Green have been made much user-friendly, with grass, seats and fountains, and traffic has been diverted away. In Leopold Square the city has revitalized a tired area by creating a new public square, free from traffic and lined with a variety of restaurants and cafés. All this results in a more pleasant, clean and relaxed environment. Meanwhile, there are ideas in York to revitalize the already-pedestrianised city with an imaginative ‘great street’ linked to parks and open spaces stretching right through the city centre from the university, via the Minster to the railway station.
But what makes public spaces attractive or useable? This subject has been studied in some depth, not least by Jan Gehl, who is the Professor of Urban Design at the Royal Danish Academy of Fine Arts’ School of Architecture in Copenhagen. His two important books, ‘Life between buildings’ and ‘Public Spaces & Public Life Studies’ stress that it is the spaces in between buildings that make any town or city landscape come alive. As Gehl points out, his work is not straightforward planning or simple architecture. Instead, he says, he studies ‘the borderland between sociology, psychology, architecture, and planning.’
His way of working, first carried out in Copenhagen, is initially to study how the existing spaces work, and how people use them. This is by far the most important step because it provides a really clear understanding of the place with which he is working. Using the data gathered, he then makes recommendations as to how improvements can be made to the public spaces to bring about change and improvement. Because the initial work has been thoroughly carried out, the recommendations go with the grain of the place and with the needs and desires of the population; they are not imposed from outside.
It is, of course, not always plain sailing, nor indeed a fast process to implement change. Councils and planners are sometimes not as open to new ideas as one might wish, and new ideas need careful explanation – and, Gehl says, education – to appreciate the value of their public spaces, to understand the quality of public life that is taking place between their buildings and to agree on the steps that should be taken to improve the spaces.
Yet such transformations can happen, given the political will and the backing of local people. Gehl and his team began their work in the centre of Copenhagen. His work has transformed the city centre, once the preserve of cars and lorries, into a pedestrian- and cycle-friendly zone, where, as in Sheffield, it’s a pleasure to walk or sit. He’s also advised on the centers of other cities, including Stockholm, Oslo, Riga, Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne and London.
He’s had influence in Yorkshire, too; in Castleford he worked with Wakefield Metropolitan District Council and with local people in the project to make a lacklustre town centre a more vibrant and user-friendly space. The Channel 4 television series ‘Kevin McCloud and the Big Town Plan’ gave a flavour of the work – though it perhaps gave a false impression that such transformations can be instant. Gehl, though, believes that it may be better to take time over projects and to transform incrementally rather than suddenly; his work at Copenhagen has taken 40 years already.
Taking stock of our public spaces and looking not just at their visual aspects but at how they are used is a vital first step. In Ripon we have some idea of how our spaces are used, but we probably need more. What do people really use our open areas for? What would they like to see in areas such as the Market Square, Old Market Place, the cathedral area, the broad space at the junction of Low, High and Water Skellgate, and even spaces like the area between Sainsbury’s store and Kirkgate? And how do uses change between summer and winter, between dry and wet days, between people of different ages?
There is certainly a case for commissioning such a review; then we should really have something on which to base plans for the future of the city.
• Were you puzzled or excited by last week’s column that detailed research into Ripon’s Hippodrome undertaken in the archive of Spiro da Afyllo papers in the Archivio di Pollafior in Sardinia by the Jesuit priest and eminent Roman historian Fr D’Apis Loyola and his colleague Prof Lily Adosa? Or did you immediately realise that the Sardinian town is an anagram of April Fool and the names of the priest, the professor and the Greek collector are all formed from April Fool’s Day? Of course you did!
