The quotation from Goethe that ‘architecture is frozen music’ has been noted in this column before. We looked at how the articulation of buildings – the underlying structure of a building and the light and shade that it offers – compares with how a musician articulates a piece of music.
But there is more to the metaphor than that – though how far Goethe took his comparison, and whether it was a carefully-considered remark or just a clever comparison, is not clear. Still, it’s a useful starting point for a few thoughts about how the buildings of Ripon stand up against some musical parallels.
That underlying structure of architecture and buildings is, of course, a vital starting point. Every piece of music needs a form – whether it’s a simple playground song or Mahler’s long and complex Eighth Symphony. And so, of course, does a building — a mud hut as much as a palace.
If we start our look at Ripon’s buildings with our oldest-surviving example, the crypt of the cathedral, we already see form and structure. The main chamber is rectangular and is entered by and decorated with round-headed arches. The approach passages are carefully constructed. And when we consider that this was only a small part of a greater structure that lay above it, it’s possible to see that formality was already something that builders (who were not yet distinguished by the name of ‘architect’) were fully aware of.
It may be instructive to compare such a building with the parallel development of Gregorian chant, formalised by Gregory I who was Pope from 590 to 604, not very long before St Wilfrid built the Ripon church. The monks of Ripon would have sung the offices of the church to Gregorian chant, which, like the architecture of the time, is underpinned with sets of rules to enable it to be used in all sorts of situations and to many texts.
Over the centuries Gregorian chant gradually became more elaborate, and in time it developed into plainsong in more than one part. This elaboration also has architectural parallels in Ripon — again in the Cathedral. Look at the Cathedral’s west front with its tall, narrow windows, called lancets. This design has something of the elegance of perfect monastic chant, simple but moving.
By the time we get to the east front of the cathedral, though, we find that this simplicity has burst out into geometrical shapes that intertwine with each other, just as plainsong evolved from parallel strands of melody into complex, interweaving counterpoint And the elaboration of music and architecture continued; if you look inside the Cathedral at the sedilia – seats for the priests near the high altar – you see that they are carved in the most elaborate way (much of this is reconstruction, but is likely to be similar to what was there in the Middle Ages). This can be seen as a parallel to the most florid medieval church music.
There is another side to music, of course – the music of the common people. You can find parallels to this, too, in the comic faces carved in many places in the cathedral, and in the spirited carvings in the tip-up seats, the misericords -where you’ll even find representations of bagpipes, a quintessential^ peasant instrument.
As the Middle Ages transformed into the time of the Tudors and Stuarts, music and architecture continued to develop along similar paths. You could say, perhaps, that the exuberant front of Fountains Hall is a representation in stone of an Elizabethan madrigal, with its formal structure enlivened with curlicues and classical allusions. And the Wakeman’s House is its middle-class (and middle-brow) companion, a decent and simple wooden structure, originally intended to be plastered, that you could, perhaps liken to simple Elizabethan lute music.
The 17th century takes first architecture and then music into the baroque period. There is something of the Baroque spirit in the design of Newby Hall (possibly attributed, in part at least, to Sir Christopher Wren) that equates with the music of, say Purcell. Halfway through the 18th century comes the more measured and stately music of the classical period, and the orderly and well-proportioned Georgian houses, like those in Park Street and Westgate, for example – as well as the Town Hall – that bring Haydn and Mozart to mind.
Into the 19th century, things change again. We get Gothic Revival buildings, like the early Holy Trinity Church and, later, St Wilfrid’s Church. And buildings become more elaborate again — some, like the terraces near the Clock Tower have a definite Wagnerian streak. Can we see the Edwardian grandeur and complexity of Elgar in the facade of the Spa Baths? Or, rushing forward into the 20th century, the experiments with new and sometimes disturbing forms of classical music in buildings like the NatWest bank or the shops on the corner of Moss’s Arcade and Queen Street? Or do they reflect instead the rise of the pop culture?
Of course, the spirit of the day always finds outlets in a number of different artistic disciplines — you could find links with movements in painting or in literature in much the same way. You may like to consider such matters next time you look at Ripon’s buildings.
