WHICH WAY SHOULD WE FACE?

In ‘The Pilgrim’s Progress’, Christian meets Mr By-Ends, ‘as very a knave . . . as dwelleth in all these
Parts’. By-Ends’ friends include ‘Mr. Smooth-man, Mr. Facing-both-ways, Mr. Any-thing; and the parson of our parish, Mr. Two-tongues’. They are all fair-weather friends, content to go with the flow.

By-Ends confides to Christian and his companion Hopeful that although he seems well-bred, his family has humble beginnings: ‘To tell you the truth, I am become a gentleman of good quality; yet my great-grandfather was but a waterman, looking one way and rowing another’.

Is there something of Mr By-End’s great-grandfather about Ripon at the moment? Is the city looking one way and rowing – or perhaps being rowed – another?

Much of the current gaze of Harrogate Borough Council is focussed to the south. Leeds is the great centre to which all communities are drawn – the Saturn that captures other settlements like satellites. It is not surprising that Harrogate is drawn in as one of the further-circling spheres. If you are a councillor sitting in Harrogate, many of whose electorate commute from Harrogate to work in Leeds, you will inevitably feel that the future of the town lies in hitching your destiny to the greater force nearby.

But Harrogate Borough does not consist merely of Harrogate. The town is towards the south of the area served by the Borough Council. What about the communities further north? How much do they feel affected by the gravitational pull that Leeds is exerting, and to which Harrogate seems irresistibly attracted?

Any answer to that will depend on many considerations, and it is hard to give a definite answer. Anyone who was born towards the former West Riding conurbation, or who has lived there, or who works there, may perhaps agree that looking towards its financial and industrial pull is the only way forward. Others may recall that until 1974 Ripon was part of the old West Riding itself – a county run not from Leeds but from even further away, in Wakefield. At that time, though, the city was not so dominated by Harrogate and had, perhaps, rather more autonomy. And there is the possibility, of course, that in a planned Church of England reorganisation, what is currently the Ripon diocese will become part of a new larger one run, again, from Wakefield.

It has been suggested, for example at a recent meeting of the Greater Ripon Improvement Partnership (GRIP), that, for Ripon, this southward-looking may not be the best solution to ensuring that the city is prosperous and at its best. Should we, instead, be looking northward as Harrogate tries to row us southward?

What would this mean – and what would we gain? There are already many links with the area to the north of us – both in history and today. Even before St Wilfrid arrived to shake up the city, the diocese and the country (not to mention the church!), Ripon had links with the north. Cuthbert, one of the greatest of the northern saints, was the guest-master in the Celtic monastery in Ripon before his fellow monks were turfed out to give the place to Wilfrid and his ideas inspired by the Roman Church. Wilfrid built a magnificent church at Ripon – as he also did in Hexham, where, as here, his crypt survives.

In succeeding centuries Ripon seems to have been as much in the orbit of Durham and Newcastle as of anything to the south – at a time when Leeds was little more than a twinkle in the eye of authority. Even after the Industrial Revolution, and the arrival of the railways, Riponians were just as likely to travel north as south – or to travel north to go south; the railway link to the main line at Thirsk made an easier journey that that to Leeds.

And today, many Riponians will travel north for work (the A19 makes Teesside easily commutable by car), for shopping or for leisure. And a look at Ripon’s coach park on most days will reveal at least one coach stopping off here that is coming from or on its way back to Teesside or Tyneside.

Of course, Ripon must work with Harrogate; we are part of that local government dispensation, and until it changes, we need to use it to our advantage as best we can. But perhaps the city should also be developing closer ties with our northern neighbours, so that we can use the best of both for the betterment of Ripon. We shouldn’t just be rowed in one direction without at least looking over our shoulder to see if there’s a glimpse of the Celestial City the other way, too!

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.