WHO HOLDS THE ASSETS?

Local authorities are selling their property faster than you can say ‘public asset’. Anything that can be ‘rationalised’ (that is, flogged off) is certainly being considered the length and breadth of the United Kingdom as councils try to claw back some of the money that they have lost in the recent public spending cuts.

Of course, no one would deny that making the most of what they own is a sensible way forward, especially if the money they raise will help to meet shortfalls in social services or in education. But there is a difference between doing the most with what you have and alienating some of the most valuable things you own merely for short-term gain.

The old cliché of ‘selling the family silver’ is often trotted out in such circumstances. Like most clichés, it has at its heart an important truth; few of us these days may have any decent amount of silver in our families, but getting rid something valuable unless you are in dire straits has always been seen as not quite the ‘done thing’.

And what has this to do with what the Civic Society particularly concerns itself, the built environment of the city of Ripon and the surrounding area? As the skirmish over the Spa Baths three years ago shows, Harrogate Borough Council does not consider even the most iconic Ripon buildings to be sacrosanct.

Understandably, there was an outcry against the proposal to sell off the Baths. The argument was not against the proposal that Ripon should have a new pool; it was against the way that the Council presented the selling of the Spa Baths as the only possible way in which a new pool could be funded. Many people believe strongly that the building is an integral part of the fabric of the city, built as it was by the city fathers in 1904 to celebrate in a substantial way the tercentenary of the charter given to Ripon by King James I.

Now, we are told, Harrogate is looking at all the buildings it owns with a view to ‘rationalising’ its holdings of bricks and mortar. This is not necessarily a bad thing; there will undoubtedly be some buildings that the Council owns that could be better used, or which could be wisely disposed of into other hands without losing anything of great importance to the community.

There are, though, some structures – like Ripon Town Hall, for example – that it would be wrong to dispose of to the highest bidder. Ironically, of course, the Ripon Town Hall has only been in Harrogate Borough Council’s possession since the early 1970s, when it took over the local government in the district. Before that it was owned by Ripon City Council, which had been presented with it in 1896 by the Marquess of Ripon, whose family had built it and had owned it for most of the 19th century. As one of the emblems of Ripon, the Town Hall would seem to be a supreme case of retention – though if the examples of Skipton and Oldham, for example, are anything to go by, even town halls are vulnerable.

And then there is the Hugh Ripley Hall, the future of which is in doubt; its closure would save Harrogate about £8,000 a year. Should this be protected from sale, too? Or could it be one of the buildings that might be handed over to community ownership?

Here Quirk might come to the rescue. Barry Quirk, Lewisham Council’s Chief Executive Officer, produced a report for the Government in 2007 on how public property assets, like the Hugh Ripley Hall, could be transferred to community groups and charities. The ‘Quirk Review’, as it is known, showed that such transfers could have real community benefits, and that public bodies already have the power – the ‘General Disposal Consent 2003’ – to let community groups buy assets at less than the full market value as long as the use they make of the building is for public and community benefit and that the value of the asset is less than £2 million.

Having such a power does not, of course, mean that a local authority has to use it – though it will have to show that it has made some effort to find a community use before selling on the open market (which is not what happened with the Spa Baths). And, of course, taking on any sort of building means great responsibility.

Any community group that is given the task of taking on such and asset from its local authority needs to think long and hard about the financial implications, even if they receive the building for a token sum. There are sources of support that may help, including the Architectural Heritage Fund and the National Lottery – but even with such help it is a daunting task.

Ripon is not yet at the stage of taking assets from the Council – but we should be prepared for the possibility, and for the inevitable battles, not just for ownership but for long-term funding, that may be ahead.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.