Television is always looking for something new. ‘Britain’s Got Talent’, ‘The X Factor’, ‘Popstar to Opera Star’, Big Brother – not to mention the extraordinary array of what in past centuries would have been called ‘freaks’ that passes for entertainment on some channels – are all searching for that ‘hook’ that will keep the viewers watching.
And of course, it’s not just the ‘popular’ end of entertainment that does this. Last weekend, for example, saw the final of the ‘BBC Cardiff Singer of the World’ competition, when great young singers competed for a title that opens doors for them in opera houses around the globe.
It’s not just television that craves novelty. Advertising is based on the idea that we can all be encouraged to try something new, exciting, different, revolutionary or scientifically-proved, something that offers luxury, convenience, easy living or comfort, something that makes you stand out from the crowd, or fit in because everyone else has one . . . Fashion, cars, sports, holidays – anything and everything is looking for ‘the latest’.
Has it always been so? Have we always been so keen for the new that we sometimes ignore the past? It’s a huge question, which delves into the psychology of human nature – and one that can’t be given a simple yes or no answer. Today we feel instinctively that things progress, that we move forward. However old you are, you will inevitably look back and consider how things have changed in your own lifetime. Perhaps you consider that, say, your grandfather was born before the Wright brothers flew, and lived to see men on the moon. Or remember when the pocket calculator was a marvel, yet accept that we have huge amounts of computing power at our fingertips.
Was it the same in the past? Did the people of Ripon look back at the time when Celtic monks occupied their monastery, and think to themselves how much life had progressed now that Wilfrid and his Rome-following monks had taken over? Was Archbishop Roger’s new church of the 1170s seen as an improvement on its predecessor? When James I gave the city a new charter and the last Wakeman was transformed at a stroke into the first Mayor, was there rejoicing throughout the city? And when the obelisk went up in the Market Square in 1702, what did people really think?
John Aubrey, the 17th-century writer of the entertaining ‘Brief Lives’ had an interesting perspective. He believed that 1649, as well as making a revolutionary change as Charles I was beheaded, was also the year in which English people started to look at the world as progressing rather than being static. Until, then, he wrote, ‘twas held a strange presumption for a Man to attempt an Innovation in Learnings; and not to be good manners, to be knowing more than his neighbours and Forefathers. ‘Twas held a Sin to Make a Scrutinie into the Waies of Nature.’ Aubrey quotes his friend Harvey as a man who suffered from this prejudice before things changed. ‘In those times, to have had an inventive and enquiring Witt was accounted Affectation, which censure the famous Dr William Harvey could not escape for his admirable Discovery of the Circulation for the Blood’.
Aubrey’s point was that until the 17th century change was viewed with suspicion. Of course things changed – not just obvious things like fashion and style, music and art, but agriculture and governance – and, of course, religion. Aubrey lived through the Civil War, as much a religious as a political conflict. But he also noted other things – that cherries were introduced into England by King Henry VIII, who had tasted them in Flanders; that hops arrived in Henry’s reign, too, changing English ale into the sort of beer we would recognise today. He quotes a rhyme that said ‘Greek, Heresie, Turkey-cocks and Beer, Came to England all in yeare.’
So how much have we really changed? Are we open to new ideas, or do we constantly look back and say ‘It’s always been like this’ or ‘It was good enough for my grandfather’ or even ‘It’s too difficult to change’ and insist on leaving things as they are?
Ripon needs to change in all sorts of ways. It needs to alter its mind-set, to recognise that it cannot today rely solely on its position as market town serving a narrow hinterland, but needs to embrace tourism as an economic driver; it needs to acknowledge that there are still problems with traffic and parking that cannot be changed by mere tinkering but need a radical solution; perhaps it needs to embrace ideas of becoming a larger city that can better sustain itself and provide more facilities for its citizens of all ages.
Is Ripon still stuck in a pre-1649 attitude, where it is still considered to be ‘a strange presumption for a Man to attempt an Innovation’? Or, seeking the best for the city, can we embrace innovation, not for its own sake as television does, but because it is vital to our future?
