What makes a good street?
In the old part of the city of Lincoln there is a street called Strait. It climbs the hill from the plain below towards the cathedral set on its ridge. As it ascends, it has a slight curve – so why is it called Strait?
The answer lies in both the meaning and the spelling of the word. Strait is a word from Middle English, derived in turn from Old French and before that from Latin. The Latin word strictus means ‘drawn tight’ (as in restricted) and the French means ‘tight or narrow’. We still use strait as a narrow piece of water – both in the singular and the plural. So the Lincoln street is a narrow one, rather than a straight one.
As a street name it’s also found in the Acts of the Apostles, where after St Paul’s blinding flash of light on the road to Damascus he is visited by Ananias, who is told by God to ‘Arise and go into the street which is called Straight and inquire in the house of Judas for one called Saul’. So the name of the Lincoln street may have been an ecclesiastical joke from the cathedral clergy who used the route to go up and down the hill.
Strait’s lack of straightness is one of its most attractive features. It is one of the aspects of any streetscape that adds interest and excitement. It’s the excitement of not knowing what is around the corner, of gradual revelation, that is so often important on a street. The poet Alexander Pope wrote about gardening that the designer ‘gains all points, who pleasingly confounds, Surprises, varies, and conceals the Bounds’. Not revealing the whole picture immediately can give a street much more variety.
What else contributes to a good street? Lincoln’s Strait is on a hill – and that’s another excellent characteristic for any street. Not too steep a hill, perhaps – though the steep Golden Hill in Shaftesbury in Dorset has achieved fame because of its picturesque qualities that appealed to the makers of Hovis in their advertisements. And if you can combine your hill with a curve, you have the makings of a great street – look, for example, at Micklegate (which means great street!) in York, which has both.
And one of the finest streets in Europe is not too far away. Newcastle’s Grey Street curves and rises from near the River Tyne to the Grey Monument. Unlike many streets, like Strait or Golden Hill, which have developed their line naturally and their buildings piecemeal, Grey Street was a deliberate piece of town planning. It was constructed between 1834 and 1839, as almost immediately was recognised as remarkable; a writer in 1838 wrote that ‘the proportion and correspondence of every part in the whole . . . are calculated to impress the beholder with indelible surprise.’
The 18th-century Squares, Circuses and Crescents of Bath, or the straight boulevards that Baron Haussmann laid out in 19th-century Paris can be magnificent and imposing, but they are perhaps not as immediately satisfying as Grey Street, even though the buildings have a similar magnificence.
A third aspect of a good street comes through variety. Grey Street’s buildings are varied in design, but are all largely of the same date. But a street that has a variety of different ages along it is perhaps even more attractive. Think of some of the streets in Richmond around the Market Place, for example, or of the delightful Fishpool Street in St Albans, that in a relatively short stretch has medieval, Tudor, Georgian, Victorian and 20th-century buidings, all working together to form an attractive street that begins on a hill, which curves at least twice, and which displays, too, a variety of materials – another indicator of a good street.
Of course, what is a good street architecturally may not be good commercially, or residentially – though an attractive street often means visitors, who can spend money in shops. And if you have such a street in a place, it can certainly pay dividends to look after and promote it.
Which brings us, as always, back to Ripon. We have several streets that might tick the boxes – curve, slope, variety – but one stands out; Kirkgate.
From the Market Square it curves downhill, bending a little more having passed Duck Hill into the strait (though not straight) and level section. You need to get quite a long way along the street before you reach the surprise of the Cathedral’s magnificent west front appearing – the street conceals its highlight very well. The effect must have been even better when the entrance to the area in front of the Minster, as it then was, was protected by a gateway.
Kirkgate is one of Ripon’s showplace streets. And what do we make of it? Not a great deal. Empty and derelict shops, parked cars where they should not be, vehicles cutting through illegally but with impunity. A lack of care in some places, certainly an unkempt air.
When the street was repaved some years ago, the street should have been closed to traffic. It should happen now, with a physical barrier of some kind that can be operated by those who have legitimate reason to use the street. It should otherwise become a pedestrianised route from the Square to the Cathedral.
And as for the top end, on the hill, the immediate need is to reroute the 36 bus, which should not be allowed into this important medieval street.
These things can be done, given the will and the courage. If they are, we may be able to reclaim Kirkgate as Ripon’s most attractive street – it may not be quite Grey Street, or Golden Hill, or even Fishpool Street, but it could certainly be a pleasure to walk along – is that too much to ask?
