When Griff Rhys Jones, the President of Civic Voice, spoke to the group’s Annual General Meeting in Coventry in mid-October, he made a plea for the protection of the urban environment.
In some ways it was hardly a surprise that he did so. Civic Voice is the national umbrella charity for the civic societies and civic trusts – the civic movement – throughout England. Ripon Civic Society is a member of Civic Voice. As Civic Voice’s website says, ‘We make places more attractive, enjoyable and distinctive. We promote civic pride.’ And, of course, ‘civic’ means related to a city or urban area. So you would expect Civic Voice’s President to speak up for the urban environment.
On the other hand, the word ‘protection’ may have brought some of you up short. In what way does the urban environment need protecting? Griff Rhys Jones pointed to the long and successful history of the Campaign to Protect Rural England (CPRE) in fostering awareness of the threats to the countryside and the need to protect it. We may find some significance in the fact that CPRE was founded (in 1926) as the Council for the Preservation of Rural England; since then ‘preservation’ has become a much more loaded word, implying a backward-looking campaign that wants the clock turned back. Now it is a ‘Campaign to Protect’ – a name with a more dynamic and forward-looking sound. If CPRE has success in looking after our countryside, Civic Voice and its member societies, says Griff, should look to doing the same for our cities, towns and villages.
But why do we need to protect the urban environment? And what does attempting to do so imply?
It’s relatively straightforward to campaign to save individual buildings. The listings system for buildings is based on the idea that individual buildings have an intrinsic value and that the more important of them should be protected. That is straightforward enough. Occasionally the list contains structures that are not intrinsically important but are listed because of what’s called their ‘group value’.
The listing system is well understood and can work well – better for Grade I and Grade II* buildings than for those listed Grade II. But in an urban setting buildings do not stand alone or with a few chosen companions that can be easily added to a list. More often it is the totality of the buildings in a street or around a square, by a river or in an alleyway, which make up the importance of the urban fabric. Within that totality, there may be few buildings that individually merit listing, but the whole group needs protection from inappropriate development.
This was recognised in the Civic Amenities Act of 1969, which allowed local authorities to set up Conservation Areas to give limited protection to whole areas of cities, towns and villages. Further changes to the legislation were made in 1990. Now there is a way of controlling development within a designated conservation area, and in dealing with planning applications local authorities must take note if a building where work is proposed is in a conservation area.
Inevitably, how well this is done varies between local authorities; some are exemplary in their dealing with such applications; others give the impression that conservation area protection can be safely ignored. Few of them take the powers that are available to prevent, for example, inappropriate replacement window frames being used in conservation area buildings.
Civic societies have a powerful role to play in keeping local authorities to both the spirit and the letter of the law on listed buildings and conservation areas. But there is a much wider role, a role that Griff Rhys Jones suggested in his speech. If all civic societies do is object, then their role is very limited. Instead, they should be at the forefront of debate about the future of our towns and cities. They should be providing a vision for the future of the communities in which they work and doing all they can to see that the vision is realized. That is what Ripon Civic Society is doing through its involvement with the Greater Ripon Improvement Partnership (GRIP) and in the formulation of the Neighborhood Plan for Ripon – as well as through these weekly Ripon Gazette columns!
Any vision, unless it be completely anodyne, will be controversial. Ideas will be put forward that may be completely against any previous thinking; they should act as a stimulus to creative thought, not as a spring that shuts like a trap to close down any further discussion. ‘It’s never been done like that’ is not an argument. As Oliver Cromwell colourfully put it when confronted with closed minds, ‘I beseech you, in the bowels of Christ, think it possible that you may be mistaken.’
The distinction between preservation and protection is an important one, in the context of Ripon as well as of the wider urban environment. Civic Societies should not be the enemies of progress – and especially not of good modern design. Progress, not pastiche, could be a useful slogan. Protect what is worth protecting, but don’t hang on to that which is not. Is it wrong for a shop to become an office or even a house? With shopping patterns changing so rapidly, we may need, even in Ripon, to grasp that particular nettle. Shops – and pubs – will inevitably shut, and a Canute-like attitude to this tide will not help. Rather, we should be ready for the future with our vision and optimism, being sure what we want to achieve and how we will achieve it. Only then will we really be protecting our urban environment.
