CONSTRUCTION OR ORNAMENT?

‘The structure of her attire was always elaborate, and yet never over laboured. She was rich in apparel, but not bedizened with finery; her ornaments were costly, rare, and such as could not fail to attract notice, but they did not look as though worn with that purpose. She well knew the great architectural secret of decorating her constructions, and never condescended to construct a decoration. But when we have said that Mrs Stanhope knew how to dress, and used her knowledge daily, we have said all.’

The lady who knew how to dress well was Mrs Vesey Stanhope, mother of the scandalous Signora Vesey Neroni, femme fatale of Anthony Trollope’s ‘Barchester Towers’. Mrs Stanhope is perhaps deliberately contrasted with the Bishop’s wife, Mrs Proudie, whose dress, ruined by the castor of the lame Signora’s mobile couch, seems to have been over-elaborate; ‘Gathers were heard to go, stitches to crack, plaits to fly open, flounces were seen to fall, and breadths to expose themselves; a long ruin of rent lace disfigured the carpet, and still clung to the vile wheel on which the sofa moved.’

This column does not usually contain information on ladies’ fashion; but Mrs Stanhope and Mrs Proudie suggest two different ways of looking at buildings – and perhaps hint of the movements in architectural fashion. Mrs Proudie was a woman who believed that elaboration made the best impression; Mrs Stanhope that form was more important, and that any decoration had to follow the form itself.

‘Barchester Towers’ came out in 1857. Trollope’s comment that Mrs Stanhope ‘knew the great architectural secret of decorating her constructions, and never condescended to construct a decoration’ was very up to date. The previous year a great and important book had been published by Owen Jones, an architect and decorator. It was ‘The Grammar of Ornament’, and it was an expanded version of a series of lectures that he had given to the Society of Arts and at the Government School of Design.

In ‘The Grammar of Ornament’, Jones lays down some ’general principles in the arrangement of form and colour, in architecture and the decorative arts.’ His first ‘Proposition’ is that ‘The Decorative Arts arise from, and should properly be attendant upon, Architecture.’ Proposition three states that ‘As architecture, so all works of the Decorative Arts, should possess fitness, proportion, harmony, the result of all which is repose.’

Trollope, though, had taken particular note of his fifth Proposition – ‘Construction should be decorated. Decoration should never be purposely constructed.’ Mrs Stanhope is firmly in the Owen Jones camp; Mrs Proudie is not.

Of course, Jones was not the first to advocate the subordination of decoration to construction. Architectural history has swayed to and fro in its love of decoration. Greek buildings were very carefully constructed on mathematical principle, and are today considered very ‘pure’; where there is ornament, it usually emphasises the construction. Even the Parthenon Frieze – the Elgin Marbles – emphasised the form of the building. We must remember, of course, that Greek buildings were coloured, and the frieze was one of its most colourful parts.

The Romans tended to more elaborate forms, and often they added ornament for the sake of it, rather than to ‘decorate the construction’ – think, for example, of the Arch of Constantine near the Coliseum, which is a mass (or even a mess) of sculpture and fussy detail.

Rushing through the centuries, we come to the Normans. Their constructions were basically simple and solid – and decoration was limited to simple capitals to columns, and incised patterns on the column’s cylinders – most notably at Durham, but in many other places, too. Here again we must always remember that churches were painted, with the painting usually emphasising the form.

The simplicity of what we know as ‘Early English’ – the style of Ripon Cathedral’s west front – with is tall lancet windows with shadow-giving mouldings, gave way to something more elaborate, the Decorated style. The Cathedral’s East window is one of the earliest manifestation of the style, called Geometric. Later it blossomed into all types of curves and double curves, only to be replaced by the more austere Perpendicular style, shown in the Cathedral’s nave.

This see-sawing continued; Elizabethan and Jacobean buildings tended to become more and more elaborate and emblematic. There was a brief flowering of classical style with Inigo Jones before the Civil War. At the Restoration French ideas and Baroque styles came in, mixing classical forms with quirky playfulness.

This in turn was swept away by the Palladian style of rules and diktat, especially from Yorkshire landowner Lord Burlington; his influence is still seen in buildings like Ripon Town Hall. Burlington laid down the rules, but it needed architectural sensitivity to create a decent building; as Alexander Pope wrote in his Ode to Burlington: ‘So shall, My lord, your just and noble rules/Fill half the land with imitating fools’.

Many people consider that Victorian architects were all ‘imitating fools’, who brought forward both Gothic and Classical forms without an idea of their own. Yet there were still voices warning against decoration for the sake of it. The Gothic architect Pugin wrote that architectural ornament should be limited to ‘enrichment of the essential construction of the building’. William Butterfield, whose multi-coloured brickwork, like that at Baldersby St James Church, shocked his contemporaries, also believed that his patterns were being used to emphasise structure.

And so the fashions continued – neo-Renaissance, like Barclays Bank on Ripon Market Square; neo-Palladian, like the nearby Skipton Building Society. Moderne (or Art Deco), like the former Palladium cinema. Brutalist – mostly absent from Ripon, though the Natwest Bank tries hard. Then a return to decoration, first with columns around the doors of ordinary houses, followed by a move even to sub-gothic with pretend gothic arches over rectangular windows.

And where are we today? With Mrs Stanhope or with Mrs Proudie? Where on the pendulum of taste for decoration will future architectural historians place us? Perhaps it’s too early to tell. But if we get too elaborate, we can be sure that the castor of fate (as ‘I’m Sorry I Haven’t a Clue’ might put it), will be ready to ruin the over-blown dress of decoration.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.