BRIGHTNING UP BOARDING UP

If you wonder what good rioting has ever done, it’s as well to bear in mind the old proverb that ‘It’s an ill wind that blows no-one any good.’

Of course, to riot – or perhaps more accurately in recent cases, to smash, burn and steal – is reprehensible, and creates untold problems for its victims. Property that has been attacked is doubly vulnerable, not just from the initial attack but from subsequent opportunists who come to steal, not televisions, mobile phones or trainers, but the fixtures and fittings, sometimes even the fabric of the building itself.

And so something comes out of the rioting – a good living for people who offer a service of boarding up buildings to make them safe from further attack or from deterioration. There are plenty of such companies, so there must be a decent living to be made. Some of them will undoubtedly see that anyone whose house needs such immediate protection is unlikely to quibble over the bill, and take advantage to hike their prices. Others may just have a reasonable, standard fee. Sometimes the property owner will not be able to shop around, especially if the damage occurs when they are away and the boarding up is organised by the police or the local authority.

When emergency boarding up is needed, it is perhaps understandable that the look of what is put in place is secondary to its security. When a window has been smashed, a temporary barrier of plywood or chipboard may be acceptable – if it is in place for a short time only, especially in retail premises.

But what about buildings that are boarded up not as the result of civic disturbance or of accident but of lack of tenants or an inability to sell – or just because the owner wants to mothball it for a period? Should we accept that the same standard of boarding is good enough?

There is no doubt that a boarded up property does nothing for the look of a place – especially in historic or picturesque locations. It is, of course, wise for owners who know that their buildings are to be empty for some time to protect them from both casual damage (stone-throwers aiming at tempting windows) and from more serious problems: as well as miscreants who would remove fittings, copper piping and slates, these may include illegal drinkers or drug-takers, squatters and arsonists. But protection should not mean disfigurement.

The Royal Town Planning Institute (RTPI) has looked at how premises can best be protected from such problems, and have made recommendations that refer specifically to ‘Heritage’ properties – including ones in Conservation Areas, like most of the centre of Ripon. They say that any preventative measures should avoid having impact on heritage fabric – this means, at the very least, don’t nail security boards straight into 18th-century woodwork or drill holes in a scheduled ancient monument. They say that ‘boarding must be done sympathetically’ – which leaves much room for manoeuvre for the people doing the work. Who is to decide what is sympathetic in an area? The RTPI says that it should be done ‘in consultation with the planning authority or other agency’.

Wise words – but two questions arise; how many owners will actually do so, and will the planning authority have a policy that tells them how the boarding up should be done, anyway? Certainly Harrogate Borough Council currently has no guidelines available for consultation, and they usually only get involved with the matter if they serve a notice under Section 215 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1990 for repairs or to improve the condition of a building. That is a rare occurrence – the latest figures on the council’s website relate to the years 1997 to 2003, during which such a notice was served just six times.

So what should be done? First, we should look at what is good practice for buildings that are boarded up. It is generally agreed that unfinished wood is not sufficient in a sensitive area. It looks temporary and quickly becomes discoloured and shabby. Then there is metal – as exemplified by the boarding up of The Station Inn on Ripon’s North Road, which recently closed. In some ways this looks worse, presenting a grim visage to the world, as if aggressively challenging vandals to take it on.

What, then? One very simple solution would be to insist on a simple colour that boarding could be painted. Some of Ripon’s boarded buildings, like the former library and the adjoining former labour exchange, and some of the higher windows at Coltsgate Hill Chapel, have the boarding painted grey. This looks much more effective and acceptable than unpainted wood.

Harrogate Borough Council could, perhaps, draw up a simple guideline that would specify how the boarding was to be finished in conservation areas; grey or a subtle blue might be appropriate. If these guidelines were enforced the look of boarded buildings would immediately be enhanced.

In particularly sensitive areas (like those blots on Ripon’s townscape at the junction of Water Skellgate and Low Skellgate) it would perhaps be better to have boarding that at least gives some indication of the form of the windows that are – or should be – behind, perhaps with glazing bars painted on them in a simple trompe l’oeille effect. That might cost a little more, but would be very much worth the extra.

Of course, as the RTPI points out, ‘The best way to protect a building is to keep it occupied.’ The Fire Protection Association says that more than a third of heritage and listed buildings damaged by fire are empty, unused or derelict. If a building must be empty and boarded up, while a vigorous search is, one hopes, being carried on for a suitable use, then at least the boarding should be done with sensitivity. There is scope for local authorities to make a positive mark here, by encouraging a more enlightened look at boarding up.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.