The Swiss artist Paul Klee famously said that ‘a drawing is simply a line going for a walk’. That, of course, leaves a great deal unsaid. Who controls the direction of the line, its thickness, its colour, its destination?
But line is the essence of art – and no more so than in English art and architecture. In 1955 the Reith lectures on the BBC Home service were given by Dr Nikolaus Pevsner, who took as his subject ‘The Englishness of English Art’. The titles of two of the lectures mentioned lines – ‘Hogarth and the Line of Beauty’ and ‘Blake and the Flaming Line’. But even before he reached these two artists, he was talking about how the line, rather than the three-dimensional form, were the essence of English Art.
This can seem quite logical when you look, for example, at Anglo-Saxon art – the sinuous, intertwining lines of the Lindisfarne Gospels or the treasures of Sutton Hoo, for example. But how does it translate into architecture? Isn’t architecture essentially about form and structure, not line?
If we look at Ripon’s sole-surviving Saxon architecture, it becomes clear that line is as important as form. St Wilfrid’s crypt beneath the cathedral’s floor is just an arrangement of simple lines and curves that delineate the space and provide niches and passages in and through that space. And when we leave the crypt and look at the next phase of architecture, the Norman, the same is true. The cathedral’s north and south transepts have lines and curves in abundance – and some of the curves here form pointed arches, marking the transition to Gothic architecture.
The west front of the cathedral is usually considered its finest feature, with its row of tall, thin Gothic windows called lancets. Yet at the opposite end of the building is something even more English – the great east window. This is in what’s come to be known as the Decorated style – and Pevsner says in his lecture that it is ‘utterly English – there are no continental parallels. And this Englishness demonstrated itself by the delight in the use of simple lines of tracery that break up the huge span of the window.
And Pevsner also suggests that another facet of the Decorated style is utterly English, too. That’s what’s called the ‘nodding ogee’ – a double-curve arch that leans forward from the surface. A good example of this is seen just next to the cathedral’s east window, in the sedilia. These early 14th-century canopied seats for the priests have these double curves at the top, and they seem so overladen with exuberant decoration that they are starting to lean forward – another example of the English delight in playing with line.
And to finish with Gothic architecture and line, there is the cathedral nave to consider. The unfinished rebuilding of the arches beneath the tower displays a liking for line in the clusters of columns that ascend to great heights. And the windows of the nave aisles are examples of another wholly-English style, called the Perpendicular.
After the playfulness of the Decorated style, the Perpendicular, with its great emphasis on straight vertical lines, seems austere. As Pevsner says, it is ‘reasonable, regular, matter of fact, angular, repetitious’ – though, he adds, it does give ‘spaciousness and clarity’. This, too, relies on line as much as form for its effect.
How does the English love of line show itself in later periods? The Elizabethans were fond of line – think of some of the Elizabethan plaster ceilings decorated with pretty plaster ribs or with strands of vines – or of the flat, linear decoration called strapwork that decorates buildings like Fountains Hall.
For a time the English love of line is hidden by a love of classically-inspired architecture, though even then the Englishness shone through – look at the ceiling of the council chamber in the Town Hall if you want to see a classical architect taking a line for a walk.
The 19th-century Gothic revival knew all about the value of line – the line of the spire of Holy Trinity church in Ripon or the Gothic of some of Ripon’s grander terraces. But even before that, the English expressed linearity with lines of humbler terraces, all with a continuous roofline and an emphatic horizontality.
Into the 20th century, and by the 1960s more architecture was all line – lines mostly defining boxy (and sometimes brutalist) buildings. Think of the original buildings of what is now Outwood Academy or the 60s science block across the road at the Grammar School.
And in this century, architects have again discovered line. Ripon can’t offer any outstanding examples, but if we think of the iconic buildings in other parts of the country, there are plenty. The Gherkin in London is a triumph of line; so is The Sage Gateshead. And simplicity of line is something that will continue to be a particularly English trait.
The late 19th-century artist Aubrey Beardsley followed in the steps of Hogarth and of Blake in using line as the trademark of his art. Some critics thought he was too extreme – one parody says of ‘Mr Aubrey Beardsley’s idea of the Archbishop of Canterbury [that] He has drawn him sitting in a wheelbarrow in the gardens of Lambeth Palace . . . it is very clever. There are only three lines in the entire picture, two for the wheelbarrow and one for the Archbishop.’ That might be taking the line to its extreme – but it would have been profoundly English.
