It’s easy to be cynical about planning and the planners whose job it is to carry it out.
In 1939 the German dramatist Bertolt Brecht, who had left his country as the Nazis took over, wrote that ‘The finest plans are always ruined by the littleness of those who ought to carry them out.’ We might forgive Brecht for having a jaundiced viewpoint, but his is an attitude that we can easily see mirrored today in many places. The planning process is not, for most people, an absorbing subject, nor are planners accorded celebrity status.
Yet planning is important – and, it follows, so are planners. Before World War II planning was in a more rudimentary state, and there were dire warnings about what the country would be like if unfettered development was allowed to continue – miles of ribbon development along main roads, advertising hoardings wherever the advertisers wanted them, densely-packed areas of slums in places where no houses should be built. Some of the warnings were from what today we would call the ‘Nimbys’ – the ‘Not in my back yard’ brigade.
One such proto-Nimby was the novelist E M Forster, whose essay in the book ‘Britain and the Beast’, which came out in 1937, was entitled ‘Havoc’. Forster wrote that ‘Only last summer the lane where I live [near Abinger in Surrey] was subtly ruined. It had been for centuries a hollow “smugglers’ ” lane between high sandy banks, and it serves my house, another private house, and a farm – nothing more; beyond the farm it turns into a cart track. Everything was peaceful, and then the local authority awoke. Crash went the picks, down went the gravel and the tar, up and down went the steam roller, the level of the lane was raised and hardened, and all its mystery sterilised.’
Yet whatever objections Forster had, and many still have today, about what they see as the heavy-handedness of authority, we should be grateful that since the War planners have had some say in how our country has developed.
Planning is not an exact science. It is governed by rules and regulations – it has to be so, or there would never be any consistency in decisions – but much of it is interpretation and, that word which this column keeps coming back to – vision. Now, we may (and we do!) complain that there is a lack of vision among our planners; we often think that their rules and regulations act as blinkers rather than as telescopes with which to see the Promised Land. And there may be some truth in this. Yet in many instances it is these very rules that have meant we are not overrun with inappropriate development.
Today, we live in interesting times for planning, both nationally and locally. The government has set about what it sees as a simplification of the planning process, reducing thousands of pages of planning regulations into a simple 52-page document. How wonderful, we may think – here at last is a government that really is cutting through the red tape. Let’s put out the flags (for which we may no longer need planning permission) and celebrate.
But before you break out the bunting, just wait! There is widespread disquiet about some of the ways in which the new policy is expressed. The National Trust, in particular, has been very vociferous in attacking the new proposals, especially the idea that, unless other restraints exist, such as land being designated as a National Park, a site of Special Scientific Interest, an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty or Green Belt (and sometime not even then), the default position in any planning application will be ‘yes’. This, they say, will open the floodgates to unrestrained development; the government disagrees.
Closer to home, Harrogate Borough Council (HBC) has just begun consultation in Ripon on its Sites and Policies Development Plan Document (DPD) – hardly a title to set the pulse racing. Yet it is important, for the DPD looks at plans for growth in the city, and especially at sites where new houses can be built. Within the next week or so all the properties in Ripon should receive through their letterbox an explanatory newspaper that sets out the reasons for the consultation, sets out the parameters under which their suggestions have been put forward, and, most importantly, six sites in Ripon where new houses could be built.
It is important that everyone makes their views on the sites known, as the Civic Society certainly will. As well as reading the newspaper, you can visit an exhibition in Ripon Town Hall on Saturday 24 September from 10.00am to 3.00pm and on Thursday 6 October from 2.00pm to 7.30pm, at which the planners will be present to discuss your ideas.
And there’s one more aspect of planning to be considered. Under the new Localism Bill that will soon receive Royal Assent to become an Act, neighbourhoods are encouraged to come up with Neighbourhood Plans that set out their own policies for development sites. Such Plans cannot be dog-in-the-manger’ refusals to accept any development, but they can influence policy higher up the decision chain.
Ripon has a chance to develop its own Neighbourhood Plan – and perhaps even to get some central funding to do so. An application for funds needs to go through Ripon City Council (because Parish Councils are considered the responsible authority for Neighbourhood Plans) and be submitted to central government by HBC. Through the Greater Ripon Improvement Partnership (GRIP) the Civic Society has urged the City Council and HBC to pursue this line as quickly as possible, as the deadline for funding application is approaching. It needs a consensus that we want to be masters of our own planning destiny as far as possible – surely something of which even Brecht and Forster would have approved.
