HOW CAN BUILDINGS HELP WITH REGENERATION?

Among ugly phrases, ‘Heritage-led Regeneration’ must rank quite high. This column has commented before on the word ‘Heritage’ as having an imprecise meaning and being used to cover whatever the user wants it to cover – as flexible as the definition of middle age. And ‘Regeneration’ is also a word of oddly-amorphous definition. Dr Who regenerates into a completely different form, but regenerated plants would be expected to look like their original.

Still, ‘Heritage-led Regeneration’ is the phrase that has currency among professionals who look at how restoring and reusing buildings can help to improve an area. There are lots of people working in this field – not just locally, like civic societies, local building preservation trusts, but nationally and even internationally. There are conferences and site visits, learned papers and articles in the popular press, all of which point to the value of bringing unloved buildings back to useful life.

Eight years ago a House of Commons Select Committee published a report called ‘The Role of Historic Buildings in Urban Regeneration’. It strongly supported the idea; it said, ‘Historic buildings provide a foundation for the regeneration of many of our towns and cities. Regenerating these buildings can reinforce a sense of community, make an important contribution to the local economy and act as a catalyst for improvements to the wider area. They should not be retained as artefacts, relics of a bygone age. New uses should be allowed for the buildings and sensitive adaptions facilitated, when the reuse of an historic building is no longer relevant or viable.’

Civic societies around the country would say ‘Amen’ to that view; they have never been in the business of preserving just for the sake of preservation, but have been keen both to see new and imaginative uses of buildings, and adaptations to them so that they can play a full role in their communities. And if all this sounds like wishful thinking designed to give a comfortable glow of virtue, it is backed up by some strong and robust research.

Regeneration, it has been found, has an impact in several ways, in addition to the more obvious ones like providing jobs or housing. These impacts include the restoration of social pride in an area that may have felt itself neglected or overlooked. Bringing a building ‘back to life’ can provide a focus for community effort and cohesion, and get people working together for the good of the place in which they live – making not just the place look better but making them feel more valued and confident, too.

Then there is the impact on crime. Television crime programmes are very often filmed in grimy, derelict areas and in decaying buildings. Partly this is because such places are easily accessible and cheap to hire, and give a gritty ‘reality’ to a programme. But such settings do emphasise the link between grime and crime – that more crime is likely in a place that is run-down than in one that is well-kept. And the research largely bears this out. Certainly, crime can fall in an area in which regeneration has taken place – at the very least because casual vandalism falls.

And what of health? Can regeneration help there? It seems so. One obvious example is by bringing green space back into public use, which has obvious health benefits. But the research goes further. People who are involved in heritage regeneration projects can find their mental health improved, too, by gaining in confidence and having a new focus for their lives; volunteering can be good for you!

Education, too, benefits. Restored buildings often offer facilities for education, and indeed the process of restoration can provide educational interest to groups of all ages. Then there are opportunities for some people to be physically involved in a restoration and in doing so to learn new skills – perhaps traditional techniques that might be in danger of being lost. If properly managed, a project could offer deprived or excluded sections of the community an opportunity to learn and to find that work – and education – can be valuable to them.

How much of this is of relevance to Ripon? Do we need such regeneration projects? And what has happened in the past?

It’s easy to be lulled into thinking that much of Ripon is fine, and needs no regeneration of its buildings; this is to look at the superficial face. In a recent walk around Ripon a Harrogate Borough Councillor (not one representing one of the Ripon wards) expressed surprise at just how much dereliction there was even in and around the city centre. Look behind the buildings on the Square, behind those in Kirkgate, Westgate, Low and High Skellgate . . . you’ll soon spot the problems. Very few of these problem areas are insoluble – but they do need vision, money and determination. It can be done – look at the development of west of the Square around what is now Booth’s store – this was for many years a problem area.

It’s easy to come up with facile solutions – like selling off the Spa Baths for housing – but that doesn’t necessarily help regeneration. Better to take the bull by the horns, as the Ripon Museum Trust did with the Workhouse, and find a community way to a solution. Not every building could – or should –become a museum. But virtually every derelict area could be brought back to like, to the benefit of us all.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.