The comic writer Frank Muir used to say that the French phrase faute de mieux was to be translated as ‘It was Frank’s fault.’
In fact, of course, it means, ‘for lack of anything better’. Muir’s quip came to mind last week, when the Civic Society was mentioned, once directly and once by implication, in the pages of this newspaper. Both mentions were critical; both were from current or former councillors.
In a letter, John Richmond wrote with some glee about the Planning Committee of Harrogate Borough Council rejecting the professional advice of their officers and giving planning permission for a new care home beside the bypass roundabout nearest to Morrison’s store and McDonalds. He seemed to be complaining that Ripon Civic Society had not attended the planning meeting at which the matter was to be determined, and that ‘for reasons best known to themselves [they] seem to oppose virtually everything that suggests Ripon moves forward.’
Mr Richmond is, of course, entitled to any opinion he wishes to hold; but it would behove him to look at reality before he makes his comments public. He is probably not aware of the immense amount of care that Ripon Civic Society devotes to planning matters, and how many planning applications the Society comments on in the course of a year.
In the majority of these cases the Society offers its support, or suggests improvements that might make the application better. The Society does help to move Ripon forward; Mr Richmond has only to look at the Society’s support for the west of the Market Square Booths development and for the current proposals to transform the former Abbots building on North Street into a cinema and restaurant. Is this ‘opposing virtually everything?’
And what of the care home proposal that Mr Richmond is so pleased about? Here’s where Frank Muir came to mind. There seems to be a mind-set among some people that ‘anything is better than nothing’ – that if there is any sort of eyesore problem in the city, it is fine to slap anything new on the site because it is bound to look better than its present state.
But this can only ever be a ‘sticking plaster’ way forward – a solution that covers up rather than improves. There has already been too much of this in Ripon – one has only to look at The Arcade, which was greeted as a great improvement to the old bus station site (though that could hardly be construed as a accolade, given the dire state it was in) but really is a low-grade disappointment.
The Civic Society objected to the both the siting and design of the care home. The site, where the former Wheatsheaf pub still clings precariously to life on the edge of a former quarry, poses all sorts of problems. The new building will have to be constructed mostly ion landfill, which can hardly be ideal. It is situated on one of the busiest roundabouts in the city, next to a supermarket which is likely to expand. Not, you might think, the ideal location in which to house elderly people.
Of more importance, though, was how the building was placed on the site, and its bulk. It is to be built virtually right up to the pavement, forming an huge visual intrusion as you come from the A61 into the city. It is the wrong building, on the wrong scale, in the wrong place.
Ah, but it’s replacing an eyesore, so it must be good. Is this an argument that really stacks up? Should the Civic Society follow this logic? The answer to this must be a resounding No. The Society will support – always has supported – good development. But equally it has opposed what is bad – and this building, as the council’s own professional staff pointed out, is, frankly, bad.
On the front page of last week’s Gazette Cllr Williams attempted to put the blame for the long-term lack of investment in the Spa Baths on to the groups who opposed Harrogate Council’s ill-thought-out plans to sell off the Baths for private housing to pay for a new pool. Ripon Civic Society was one of those groups, so it would be good to get the facts straight on the Society’s behalf.
For too many years the Spa Baths were not looked after properly. Money should have been regularly invested in maintenance – as for all buildings. Instead the Baths were largely ignored unless something critical happened. So when there was a possibility of a new pool for Ripon, the knee-jerk reaction was to sell off the site and alienate this important public asset, a symbol of civic pride that celebrated the 300th anniversary of the city’s 1604 charter. It is little wonder that people objected; it was to be foisted on the city without consultation and, it seemed, as quickly as possible before anyone noticed.
The Civic Society supported the idea of a new pool – and still does. But, as with the Care Home, it will never acquiesce in something that it believes is wrong for the city, nor subscribe to the faute de mieux attitude. The Society wants the best for Ripon, and if that means opposing second-best solutions it will continue to do so, however much criticism is levelled at it.
