This is the age of the logo.
Everywhere we look, products and services have their own distinctive emblem by which we are supposed to recognise them and by which we are encouraged to remain loyal. Some logos are universal – Coca-Cola’s curly lettering (a very long-established recognition symbol), the Adidas stripes, the Nike ‘swoosh’ – and appear on every possible surface, lest we forget them. Others are more local in nature, but within their own realm are well-recognised – like Ripon’s horn, perhaps.
This urge to be recognised goes back to ancient times. Seals from 5000 years ago have emblems associated with particular dynasties; since at least 600BC rulers have put images of their faces on the coinage. Our word ‘logo’ is a contraction of ‘logotype’, actually meaning a symbol that stands for a word (logos is Greek for word) so it is ironical, perhaps, that we now see logos as almost exclusively graphic, even if, like Coca-Cola or Facebook, the logo incorporates the name.
In the early Middle Ages military men had a particular problem. If you look at the Bayeux Tapestry, it is almost impossible to distinguish one side from the other – all have similar armour and helmets, and their shields have conventional patterns. If it is true that King Harold was killed by an arrow in the eye, it was probably because he raised his helmet to let his followers recognise him.
So what developed was what today we might call a system of personal logos – or what are more conventionally known as coats of arms. Each knight (and we’re only talking about the upper echelons of medieval society here) adopted a specific emblem to paint on his shield, so that he would be recognised in battle. So the English kings had the three gold lions on a red background that still appear in the royal coat of arms, while the French kings had gold fleurs-de-lys on a blue ground.
This was fine, as long as everyone chose a different design. Sometimes, though, knights chose the same design; at the siege of Caerlaverock Castle in Dumfriesshire in 1300 Sir Brian Fitzalan and Sir Hugh Pointz had identical shields, and, though they were on the same side, fought each other to settle the matter. To stop this unseemly squabbling, a new court – the Court of Chivalry – was set up to make decisions among English families.
The Court’s most famous case involved Sir Richard Scrope, who came from Masham, Sir Robert Grosvenor from Cheshire and a Cornish squire called Carminow. All three claimed the same coat of arms – a blue shield with a diagonal gold stripe. Squire Carminow was soon disposed of, but there was a long legal battle between Scrope and Grosvenor, finally decided in favour of the Yorkshireman. The Scropes, still Yorkshire landowners, continue to bear the coat of arms; the defeated Grosvenors chose another design – and eventually became Dukes of Westminster.
Having a coat of arms became one of the marks of being a gentleman, and your family could use your shield, too (slightly altered to show where in the family they ranked). Servants and retainers might have a badge that related to the coat of arms, too. Heraldry – so called because it was regulated by the heralds – became a simple way to show ownership. So it was not surprising that institutions as well as people wanted their own coats of arms. Universities and colleges, learned bodies and eventually local government adopted their own coats of arms.
By the time that this happened, there were specific regulations in place, and for a coat of arms to be official it had to be issued by the College of Arms, a body formally incorporated by King Richard III in 1484 under the control of the Earl Marshal, the Duke of Norfolk. In return for a fee the applicant received an official document that set out in best heraldic language the coat of arms they were entitled to use.
Yet sometimes this essential legal step was overlooked, perhaps from ignorance, perhaps from parsimony. The Court of Chivalry continued to try cases of illegal use of coats of arms – often when commercial firms used corporate coats of arms – until 1732. Thereafter it went to sleep; people in England and Wales could use any coat of arms without legal redress (in Scotland the rules have always been much tougher). The Court woke briefly in 1954 when the City of Manchester sued Manchester Palace of Varieties for using the Manchester cost of arms on its curtain and (more importantly) on its seal. The Palace lost and paid costs of £300.
One corporate body that omitted to go through the correct channels to regularise its coat or arms appears to have been the city council in Ripon. There is certainly a recognised coat of arms of the city, which incorporates the horn and the letters of the city’s name (often as ‘RIPPON’). But the council has no official and exclusive right to it.
This is the state of affairs that the Mayor is determined to regularise. His ‘Coat of Arms Appeal’ is raising funds to ask the College of Arms to give Ripon an official coat of arms for the first time. When it does so the council will be able to challenge unlicensed use of the shield and will be able to use it properly in its official documentation. For the first time, too, Ripon could have the ‘extras’ that go with it – a crest to sit on top of the shield and which could form a badge, a motto (which may well be the text inscribed on the town hall) and even figures at each side, called ‘supporters’ – deciding on them will provide interesting scope for the imagination.
This is an important matter – a matter especially of civic pride; which is why Ripon Civic Society has already supported the Appeal. Please consider doing the same.
