Floodlighting buildings is a subtle art. Underplay it, and people wonder what the point was of spending money merely to add a very slight glow to a perhaps-undistinguished structure; overplay it, and you can end up with a garish and over-lit fantasy that speaks of the fairground rather than of architecture.
Let’s start with first principles; why should we floodlight a building? You may think it’s a question that’s only been asked since electric light became available, but the desire to light the outsides of buildings to show them off has been with us for much longer.
Fireworks were one way – the Chinese, of course, had a head start, but certainly by the 18th century European cities used fireworks to outline and illuminate buildings on particularly joyous occasions. Sometimes the fireworks had their own elaborate structures, most famously in St James’ Park in London on Monday 15 May 1749, when Britain had a mammoth display to celebrate the Treaty of Aix-la-Chapelle marking the end of the War of the Austrian Succession. An artillery of squibs and rockets was launched from an elaborate structure 114 feet high, to the sound of Handel’s ‘Music for the Royal Fireworks’. It was a great spectacle – the more so as the wooden structure caught fire and burned down.
Another way of illuminating buildings was the use of transparencies – coloured pictures, often of royalty or national and local heroes, which were placed high in buildings. These were also used in the 18th century and illuminated with candles, but gained new momentum with the advent of gas lighting. The first building to be illuminated outside with gas light was the Soho Works in Birmingham of manufactures Bolton and Watt in 1802. Gas-lit transparencies were soon in vogue – though they, too, often resulted in conflagration.
Throughout the 19th century gas engineers found ways of using gas to illuminate the facades of buildings, which was always a hazardous procedure; gas was a notoriously unstable fuel, prone to popping and flaring. So when electric light was introduced it was greeted as a much safer way of illuminating – and engineers could build on a tradition of lighting the outsides of buildings.
Early electrical floodlighting would seem to us rather underpowered, but it was regarded as a marvel in its day. It was soon taken up not just by building owners but by sports clubs; the first football ground to be lit with floodlighting was Sheffield’s Bramhall Lane as early as 1878.
Electric lamps gradually improved, and were joined by neon lighting in 1910, when Georges Claude publicly displayed the first neon lamp; he took out a patent for it in 1915, and neon lighting was used widely throughout the 20th century, not least in set pieces like Piccadilly Circus in London and Time Square in New York.
Floodlighting gradually became commonplace on important buildings. A particular impetus was given when the International Illumination Commission met in London in September 1931 and many of the capital’s buildings were floodlit for the first time, including the Houses of Parliament, Westminster Abbey and Horse Guards. Illumination totalling 70 million candlepower produced a dazzling effect – and there were traffic jams through the city as hundreds of thousands of people went to see the brightly-lit buildings!
So today we can expect important buildings to be floodlit. Such lighting can enhance them by emphasising their structure and important details. Yet at other times, floodlighting is not quite so desirable. Buildings are designed to be lit naturally by daylight, which generally is overhead illumination; floodlighting more often than not is from below, throwing light, if the designers are not careful, in a way unintended by the architect.
So we return to the initial question – why should we floodlight a building? As English Heritage’s guide ‘External lighting for historic buildings’ says, they ‘are often amazing feats of architecture and engineering. Many have been enhanced and brought to light at night-time with striking and subtle external lighting schemes.’ The recent upgrading of the floodlighting on Ripon Cathedral falls into that category. But, warns English Heritage, ‘Just because such a building or structure happens to be listed does not mean this is a good reason to proceed with external lighting.’
Technicalities of lighting are one thing; taste is another. In considering floodlighting both need to be considered. Just because it is possible to use coloured lights on a building, should you? The BBC lighting engineers seem to have a hatred of the natural colour of buildings; watch any concert from the Royal Albert Hall or a service from a cathedral and they will have rigged up lights – usually blue and pink or, occasionally, purple, to light walls and arches, making noble buildings into a branch of light entertainment. And although the coloured lighting at Fountains Abbey regularly draws crowds, is that necessarily a reason for it to continue indefinitely? It may be attractive to people, but it lacks subtlety.
Of course, even if you don’t use coloured light, the tone of the lighting is important. Do you use sodium light to give an orange glow, or something more approaching a daylight tone? And when you place the lights, do you go for overall illumination or do you pick out the best features with spotlighting? Will your floodlighting make a building safer, or have you created dazzling glare or deep shadows in which vandalism becomes easier? Above all, does your lighting really enhance your building, or might it have been better to have left it well alone?
Perhaps not many of us have responsibility for deciding such questions, but we should all be aware of how lighting is used on our buildings – it can subtly affect our perception of a city in more ways than we might think.
