What makes a good tour guide? And what pitfalls should a tour guide avoid?
Most of us some time in our lives have had guided tours, perhaps of a country house or a church, a museum or a castle, a nature reserve or a park. And we have all, no doubt, experienced the good as well as the bad of guides. We always remember the good – and we probably remember the bad just as much, but for the wrong reasons. Yet if guides would only observe a few points of guidance, they could all approach at least a decent level of competence. So here are some pointers for you if you ever have to guide yourself.
First, you need a good voice – loud enough but not overbearing (not Brian Blessed, please!) and well-modulated, with enough variety to be interesting. This may not be something you are born with, but it can be developed. And even if you are giving your talk through a microphone, a loud, clear voice and a well-regulated speed (not too fast) are essential.
It should go without saying that you need a good knowledge of your subject. It does not instil confidence in your audience to say that you don’t know much but you’ll do your best, or that you’re a bit rusty because you haven’t guided for a few years. If this is meant to be disarming, it doesn’t work; it leaves your audience feeling short-changed. So you need much of the knowledge at your fingertips – though for the more out-of the way questions (“who designed that stained glass?”; Do those twisted columns have Masonic significance?”) a quick reference to your notes (which you have remembered to bring) is allowable.
A major crime for guides – and something too often encountered when being guided around a building – is for them to stand with their back to a group to point to features. Always face your group – not all of them will have 20:20 hearing, and if your voice is directed away they’ll cease to hear and lose interest.
Then, of course, you need to keep to time – arrive well before the hour at which the members of your group are due to assemble; they may well be there very early – and keep a careful eye on the clock as you do your tour. It is a sin to overrun!
Gauge the level of your audience’s’ knowledge. This may be easier said than done, because it’s not always possible to distinguish an Emeritus Professor from an intelligent layman! But do not assume that your audience either knows nothing, and patronise them with the most mundane facts that they already know, or treat them to complicated technical descriptions and references that go over their heads. American museums sometimes use university post-graduate students to go their guiding; the best can be good, but some give the impression both that they are practising for their forthcoming glittering academic career and that the people they are addressing have no knowledge at all.
And then there are the humourists. A light touch and the odd amusing remark go down well; heavy-handed attempts to be funny do not. And, especially, don’t leave your audience unsettled by odd questions ; “Do any of you cook?” was a recently-heard question; where was it leading – to a request for a demonstration? To a warning not to? The group was immensely puzzled.
Some tour guides appear to be slightly manic. They feel it is their mission to enthuse you with their own philosophy of life, and use the objects they are describing to show how right they are. Another US guide was guilty of this; he had chosen about five museum objects (from several million) to stop in front of and spout a slightly whacky view of what they mean and how we should take their message to heart. He was very full of himself.
On the other hand, do not be dour and downbeat. People are here because they want to know about the place around which you are guiding them. It’s likely to be their first, and possibly their only visit. So that fact that you have given the tour 735 times before means nothing – they are fresh, and so should you be. We’ve all come across guides who go into auto-pilot on a tour, rattling out the script as if it was a selection from the telephone directory. Be interested and lively, and interact with your audience.
If you find yourself on a coach having to talk en route to somewhere, only do so if there is something of interest to say, or some background to the destination that it’s convenient to fill in before you arrive. Do not comment (as guides have been known to do) on the antics of drivers ahead, about the inadequacies of the local council or the fact that your mother was born three fields away. These things are rarely of interest.
And, if you are guiding at a stately home, for example, do not assume that all your audience is fascinated by the ramification of a family tree. A brief outline may be helpful; attempting to shine light on the most distant branches just leaves the group confused. And, unless your group consists of architectural historians, do not become too technical; regular and attentive readers of this column will of course know about such things, but the general public will not.
A good guide will follow these rules and also add that indefinable element of rapport with the audience. He or she is the sharp end of a venue’s contact with the public, and they, for good or ill, will colour the visitor’s perception. If you do guide, these are some of the ways to get it right – and if you’re not, use them to judge next time you’re on a guided tour!
