These are exciting times for planning. You may wish to read that sentence again.
These are exciting times for planning. Does it seem an odd idea, that planning can be exciting? You might think of planning as on the same scale of excitement as watching paint dry or BBC Parliament. After all, for most people, planning is not an exciting subject. We regard it as we regard electricity; we ignore it if it works, and complain vociferously if it stops working.
Yet at the moment planning is an exciting, if rather scary, subject. Why? Because the planning laws have just changed. Perhaps you didn’t notice, but you can be sure the developers did. And local authorities, which have to deal with the new laws, will have noticed, too – though how far they are geared up to the changes remains to be seen.
This is the biggest reform to the planning system for 50 years. The system was certainly overdue for change; over the years it had grown even more complex, with sub-policies to the sub-policies forming an almost-impenetrable jungle, through which it was almost impossible for the non-professional to hack a route – and which gave plenty of scope for arguments between the professional planners, local authorities and local people. Planning law ran to more than 1200 pages of legal nicety – and, of course, every word was at some point argued over and challenged.
Now we have a shiny new document – the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF). Its title is unlikely to set the heart racing, and the contents are unlikely to win the Man Booker Prize, but it is nevertheless an important document. And, instead of the 1200 or so pages it replaces, this one is just 65 pages from cover to cover – and only 45 pages of policy – the rest is a glossary of terms and a list of 44 ‘Documents replaced by this Framework’.
Note that this is a ‘Framework’ not a set of definitive rules. As the first paragraph says, ‘The National Planning Policy Framework sets out the Government’s planning policies for England and how these are expected to be applied. It sets out the Government’s requirements for the planning system only to the extent that it is relevant, proportionate and necessary to do so. It provides a framework within which local people and their accountable councils can produce their own distinctive local and neighbourhood plans, which reflect the needs and priorities of their communities.’
So this seems to be all about giving local people a real say in the planning of their local area. But in the run-up to the publication of the NPPF you may have heard a lot of disquiet expressed by many conservation bodies, perhaps most vociferously by the National Trust, but also by civic societies, many acting through their umbrella body Civic Voice.
Much of that disquiet stemmed from the impression given during the consultation that the NPPF was leaning too much in the direction of developers, who would be able to gobble up large tracts of virgin countryside without any restraining hand. There was also the indication that planning law was stifling much-needed economic growth. That was never true, except perhaps in very limited and specific circumstances. Even under the old planning rules 80 per cent of planning applications were granted permission, and 30 per cent of the ones that went to appeal were allowed, too.
At the heart of the new NPPF is ‘sustainable development’. In the earlier drafts of the new policy this was a rather woolly term. Thanks to effective lobbying, the government has sharpened up the definition. If a local authority has a Local Development Plan in place, a development proposal that fits with the plan should be allowed ‘without delay’; if there is no agreed Local Development Plan, planning permission should be given unless ‘any adverse impacts of doing so would significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefits, when assessed against the policies in this Framework taken as a whole; or specific policies in this Framework indicate development should be restricted’ – so the answer is ‘yes’ unless the NPPF says ‘no’. It may well be that there is wide scope for interpretation here.
One of the main thrusts of the NPPF is that decisions should be locally-made. As the responsible Minister, Greg Clark MP, says in his ‘Ministerial Foreword’, ‘This should be a collective enterprise. Yet, in recent years, planning has tended to exclude, rather than to include, people and communities. In part, this has been a result of targets being imposed, and decisions taken, by bodies remote from them. Dismantling the unaccountable regional apparatus and introducing neighbourhood planning addresses this.’
So what might the new NPPF mean for Ripon or for the villages and countryside around? First, it could make it more straightforward for development to take place in the city or in a village – but it also means that the people who live there should have more say in the decision as to where development might be. This is the purpose of the Neighbourhood Plan; Ripon has been given £10,000 by the Department of Communities and Local Government to develop its own ‘City Plan’ to ensure that local people have a say in local development; once agreed, the city plan will have the force of any planning law.
Among other useful policies are the need to ‘recognise town centres as the heart of their communities and pursue policies to support their viability and vitality’ and that ‘Planning policies and decisions should encourage the effective use of land by re-using land that has been previously developed (brownfield land).
There is much to be commended in the NPPF as it has now been implemented; much more than might have been expected from earlier drafts, thanks to the insistence of amenity bodies nationally and locally. But the proof of the planning will be in the building. These are certainly exciting times – but we must wait to see what the impact of the new NPPF really is.
