Imagine, just for a moment, that an awful thing has happened – that Ripon Cathedral has caught fire. We would assume that, with its new fire safety system and the proximity of the fire station, to which alarms would go automatically, such a fire would be limited in its effect and the cathedral would be relatively undamaged.
When York Minster had its fire in 1984, the effects were largely limited to its south transept, though that was devastating enough. In the 19th century the Minster had had both its choir and its nave burnt out in separate fires, too. Other English cathedrals, too, have had serious fires, notably Peterborough in 2001.
All these events are terrible – but of all the cathedrals that have suffered from fire, Coventry Cathedral stands out. Most cathedral fires start by accident (or in the case of York Minster’s fire of 1829 as the result of arson) but Coventry was different. On the night of 14 November 1940 the city of Coventry was deliberately targeted by the Luftwaffe, and incendiary bombs fell on the Cathedral. The resulting conflagration destroyed virtually all the medieval building, leaving only its outer walls and, miraculously, its tower and soaring spire.
Even before the war ended the cathedral authorities asked Sir Giles Gilbert Scott for a design for a new cathedral. Forty years earlier Scott, then just 21, had the chance to build another cathedral by winning the competition to design a new Anglican cathedral for Liverpool. Because of his youth he was forced to work with the elderly but highly-respected architect G F Bodley, until Bodley died in 1907. Scott’s Liverpool Cathedral was completed only in 1978, 18 years after his death.
The Coventry authorities were unwilling to spend decades building a new cathedral. And they were also in a dilemma about style – should their new cathedral be traditional – ie Gothic – in style, or should it reflect modernism? Scott tried both ways – but eventually retired from the fray, leaving open the challenge of others. There was to be a competition at Coventry, too.
Architectural competitions have not always had a good press. Giles Gilbert Scott’s grandfather Sir George Gilbert Scott (who restored Ripon Cathedral in the 1860s) came third in a competition to build a new Foreign Office in Whitehall, but manoeuvred his way into the job, only to find his Gothic design rejected by Lord Palmerston. He was eventually obliged to design it as a Renaissance office block instead. Much more recently there was the competition for a new opera house in Cardiff; here there were two competitions, both won by the architect Zaha Hadid – but, because of a lack of enthusiasm by Cardiff Council, among other considerations, her exciting design was never built.
Fortunately, for the new Coventry Cathedral there were better precedents, notably the competition for Guildford Cathedral, won in 1932 by Edward Maufe and built almost exactly to his winning design. That was in a mild, modernish Gothic style. At first the Coventry authorities thought they needed Gothic, too. In the first draft of the competition rules suggested that needed a traditional design. After protest from the Royal Institute of British Architects the words ‘in the English Gothic tradition’ were changed to ‘the architect being left free to make his choice of style’; obviously women were not thought likely to enter – or perhaps even capable of entering – the competition.
There were 219 entries; they were in all manner of styles, from the most traditional gothic to the futuristic – especially notable was that from Peter and Alison Smithson; they designed a square glass box with a parabolic roof looking like a delta-wing bomber. But the winner was the Scots architect Basil Spence. His design was condemned by many at the time as a ‘concrete monstrosity’, even though it was built mostly of red sandstone. Its characteristic features – the zig-zag walls, the glass screen engraved with angels, the huge tapestry designed by Graham Sutherland, the statue of St Michael and the Devil by Epstein – are well known and much loved today, though reviled by many during the cathedral’s construction in the 1950s.
The new Coventry Cathedral was consecrated exactly 50 years ago today – on 25 May 1962. Five days later another great work of art, Benjamin Britten’s War Requiem, commissioned to mark the cathedral’s opening, was given its first performance; the soloists included the baritone Dietrich Fischer-Dieskau, who died last Friday.
So, is Coventry Cathedral traditional or modern? In its plan it is largely traditional – a rectangular box with the altar at the far end, with aisles and a vaulted roof. In detail it is partly traditional; it has stone mullioned windows, for example. And it is partly inspired by 1950s architecture; the tapering concrete columns are like something from the 1951 Festival of Britain, for which Spence designed – or like the legs of a 50s coffee table. It was Spence’s genius that he managed to combine these elements into something that is, on the whole, a great building.
And what if we were to face the same dilemma today – if Ripon Cathedral burned so badly that it needed a new start? What would happen? There would certainly be a clamour for exact reproduction of what had been lost; there would, equally, be a strong sense that its replacement should show today’s style. Resolving these opposing views would require great skill and judgement.
Coventry shows that it is possible, by taking a long view, to have a building that works for now and, as a cathedral must, for centuries if not eternity. Would we have the same courage that the Coventry authorities had? – a courage that, incidentally, was consistently opposed by Coventry City Council, which gave no money to the new cathedral. Would we give in and build pastiche? Or perhaps there would be no willingness at all to rebuild.
Fortunately, it’s a decision we don’t have to make – let’s hope that we never do.
