WEBB SHOWS THE WAY FOR THE SQUARE

The architect Philip Webb was a close friend of William Morris. Morris – designer, artist, poet, weaver, political activist – was, of course, one of the most interesting men of the 19th century; and Webb, not so much a public figure, was one of the most interesting architects.

The Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings (SPAB) was founded by Morris and Webb in 1877. We need to be careful of misinterpreting the name of the Society; ‘protection’ sounds very defensive, as if any plans to do anything with an ancient building has to be opposed, and that all ancient buildings are precious. But from its earliest days SPAB has encouraged good new buildings and sensitive reuse of old ones.

Webb was always keen to encourage young architects in the principles and methods of practical conservation. Note that word ‘practical’ – this is conservation not for its own sake but for a useful purpose. And Webb was a very practical designer – his houses (and they are comparatively few) were always based on the needs of his clients rather than on a grandiose idea to which practicality was subordinate.

One of his earliest works was for his friend Morris. The Red House at Bexleyheath – now in suburban southeast London but when it was completed in 1860 far into the countryside – was Webb’s first major building, and it was in what was then the modern style. There had been some earlier buildings that probably influenced Webb, like the cottages by William Butterfield at Baldersby and Baldersby St James, dating from the 1850s, but it was The Red House that really got noticed.

Webb was a sensitive repairer of old buildings – ‘sustaining it without injury to its historical interest’ as he put it. Where repair was needed it was done with as little fuss as possible and with great honesty, so that what had been done was not hidden but obvious to anyone who looked. Stonework was not replaced; nothing was rebuilt to look tidier. That these ideas are now at the forefront of building conservation work (though not always followed) is in large part thanks to Webb, Morris and the SPAB.

For all these reasons it is appropriate that there is a well-established Phillip Webb Award run by SPAB. The Award is for students studying to become architects at UK Schools of Architecture and its purpose is ‘to encourage new design in the context of historic buildings and to develop an appreciation of old buildings . . . through an understanding of the architectural and historical values of old buildings and the purpose, philosophy and techniques of conservation.’

And if that sounds as if the Award is pushing them in the way of approaching historic buildings with timidity in case they inadvertently compromise them, the brief they are given for the Award makes it clear what is wanted: the Student . . is to choose an individual building or group of buildings of historic interest in the UK which are subject to decay or neglect. Students are required to produce a scheme which will sympathetically re-vitalise the building or buildings and their setting for existing or appropriate new uses. The scheme should include a significant element of new design.’

That last sentence might make you sit up. The Award does not ask that a building should be restored to its former state. It does not demand unobtrusive repair. It demands ‘a significant area of new design’. And the other important word is, of course, ‘revitalise’. Buildings need a purpose, and the Philip Webb Award deliberately demands that the students come up with imaginative and viable uses for the buildings.

Each year SPAB’s magazine ‘Cornerstone’ reports on the winners. The variety of buildings they illustrate, and the use to which they are put, is amazing. Some you might expect – disused docks turned into an industrial heritage complex, for example, or a church into a dance studio. Others are less predictable – in 2011 awards went to a scheme to convert Sheffield’s disused Crown Court into a community archive, and for a fire-damaged Georgian house in London to become a centre for recovering drug addicts. There was even a plan for the 1970s Thamesmead estate in east London, transforming acres of concrete dinginess into an exciting 21st-century community. What they all have in common is an exciting vision of using enlightened intervention into old structures to give a new lease of life.

It will not have escaped your notice that Ripon has some buildings that would merit a similar intervention. Good work has recently been done on two of what the Civic Society has termed the ‘Three Disgraces’ at the corner of Water Skellgate and Low Skellgate, but the rear of the former Public Rooms still needs work, and the former Turk’s Head pub needs a new role. There is the forlorn structure between Sainsbury’s store and Kirkgate, which may have been a maltings; a use for that is disparately needed. And, of course, the Ure Bank Top maltings, one of Ripon’s biggest buildings, is a problem that cries out for an imaginative solution.

All these could be offered to students to use as case studies for the Philip Webb Award, and Ripon might find that not only have we found a solution to a series of problems, but also, if there is the will to carry out at least one of them, that we can be at the forefront of architectural design rather than lagging behind as the city so often does.
And then, of course there is the Market Square. How about encouraging students to design a new, multi-purpose, architecturally innovative and inspiring, market hall for us on the northern half . . . ?

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.