‘Things are seldom what they seem,
Skim milk masquerades as cream;
High-lows pass as patent leathers;
Jackdaws strut in peacock’s feathers.’
As Little Buttercup hints to Captain Corcoran in Gilbert and Sullivan’s HMS Pinafore’, it’s easy to be deceived by appearances (and in case you were wondering, high-lows were low-heeled military boots, the last things to be made of expensive patent leather).
When it comes to buildings, architects of the past, and particularly since the Renaissance, have spent a great deal of ingenuity in making structures look like something they are not. So architects like Serlio and Alberti, Michelangelo and Bernini, dressed churches and private houses to look like the structures of ancient Rome rather than as buildings of their own day.
And it’s to Andrea Palladio, the most influential of Italian Renaissance architects, that we owe the transfer of the style of the Roman temple, with its columned front and triangular pediment above, to so many country houses, town halls and garden buildings. Palladio used these elements with subtlety and without making ‘correctness’ a passion; many of his followers, less gifted with genius, made from his work a set of rules that had to be obeyed – with the consequence that sometimes their buildings became sterile exercises in mechanics rather than things of beauty.
In and around Ripon we have plenty of examples of how Palladian rules have been applied. The Town Hall, designed by James Wyatt at the end of the 18th century, is a prime example – polite, correct in Palladian terms, even handsome, but not exciting. Earlier in that century we have the more imposing façade of what is now Queen Mary’s School at Baldersby Park, designed by one of the arch-prophets of the Palladian Style, Colen Campbell in 1720; it has attached columns similar to those on the Town Hall, but a much more stately presence.
Campbell was probably the architect of the Banqueting House at Studley Royal, too, while another architect, Roger Morris, seems to have designed the nearby Temple of Piety, looking exactly like a small Roman temple but really just a summer house. Both Campbell and Morris worked at Studley Royal House, destroyed by fire in 1946, and designed the eminently-Palladian stables that now form the house on the estate. Their clients were, of course, the Aislabie family, and William Aislabie was to take this cult of making buildings resemble something they were not a whole stage further at Hackfall near Grewelthorpe.
Guests of the Aislabies who visited Hackfall were driven to Mowbray Point and to what appeared to be a small cottage in a field – a cottage with pointed gothic windows, but otherwise unremarkable. Passing through the cottage, the doors at the far side were flung open to reveal the magnificent prospect of the gorge of the River Ure and the immeasurable countryside beyond. This was what the 18th-century theorists of landscape would have called a ‘sublime’ moment – a coup de theatre that sent the pulse racing. But for architectural historians the greatest interest is not in the view but in the structure of the ‘cottage’; for the side that faces the view is not timidly Gothic but a magnificent Byzantine-style ruin, carefully constructed to make it seem to be a fragment of an ancient basilica that has otherwise been destroyed in a cataclysmic disaster.
This is the greatest set-piece of Hackfall, but the other buildings there are instructive, too. The Rustic Temple is made of stones so huge it seems to be almost Mayan, but otherwise Gothic prevails, particularly in Mowbray Castle, a battlemented folly high up on the edge of the gorge, opposite Mowbray Point. It was designed to give the impression that the Aislabies could trace their ancestry back into the mists of time.
Gothic was, of course, the best way to make an instant link with the Middle Ages and the Romantic past of British history, so it is not surprising that Gothic follies became the rage. Not too far from Ripon, for example, are the examples of Yorke’s Folly above Pateley Bridge, with its Gothic-detailed columns, and, much more recent, the entrance building to Akebar Caravan Park near Constable Burton, with its Gothic windows and ‘ruined’ roofline. And some of the structures at The Forbidden Corner in Coverdale continue to use Gothic to arouse particular associations – Gothic Horror – in the minds of visitors.
Gothic, of course, had its greatest revival in the 19th century, and, certainly for the Church of England, it became the only proper style in which to build churches. Logically, this was as odd as building houses that look like Roman temples, but so well did it become the established norm that today we hardly give it a thought – and even complain if a church looks too ‘modern’.
In the Middle Ages, of course, Gothic was modern. So when Archbishop Walter de Grey began to remodel the west front of his great church in Ripon, he used the most up-to-date Gothic, and built the two great tiers of thin lancet windows and the two flanking towers. But even here ‘things are seldom what they seem’. The impression conveyed is of a huge structure, but in fact the church behind was only as wide as the space lit by the windows. The towers projected beyond the width of the building, to give it a more imposing approach. It was a trick learned from, perhaps, Lincoln Cathedral, which has the same deceptively-wide west front.
Are all these uses of architectural sleight-of-hand meant to deceive? Only up to a point. They rely as much on associations as on deception. Or they are perhaps used to be fashionable – just as 18th and 19th-century householders in Ripon put ‘polite’ new facades on medieval buildings, which still retain their ancient timbers behind brick or stucco fronts. And do we still practice to deceive? Certainly – and too much, perhaps; new houses still ape Georgian predecessors rather than strike out in a 21st-century style. So we may well be just as guilty as was the past of ‘strutting in peacock’s feathers’.
