The late Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother, not usually known for her philosophical insights, once said, ‘If you find anything or anybody a bore, the fault is in yourself.’ Her remark came to mind when the architectural critic Jonathan Meades was quoted on a radio programme as writing in his latest book ‘Museum without Walls’ that ‘everything is fantastical if you stare at it for long enough… there is no such thing as a boring place’.
So is there such a thing as boring architecture? Are there really boring places? Taking a literal view the answer is ‘Yes!’ – but not because of any intrinsically uninteresting facets of a place. There is a place where all architecture is boring, because the town itself is Boring – Boring in the state of Oregon. And even Boring found something interesting to do; it recently twinned with the village of Dull in Perthshire.
Also boring is the work of one particular American architect. His work includes quite a number of apartment blocks in New York, and something that has a secure place in US history and in New York’s tourist trade – the US Immigration Station building on Ellis Island, where the ‘huddled masses yearning to breathe free’ came ashore for the first time in their new homeland. Working with his partner Edward Tilcon, the architect was William Alciphron Boring.
But neither of these is what Meades was meaning. His contention is that if you look hard, if you open your eyes properly ad take in the details of a place, if you are really receptive to a place and take the trouble to spend time there and take it all in, any place – every place – will prove to have something of interest.
One of the ways to prove this is to travel by public transport. At some point on any journey you will find yourself waiting for the next bus or train. Your wait may be only a few minutes; in remote places it might be several days or even weeks. There is always the temptation to look on this as wasted time, time that you need to fill by reading, listening to music or sleeping. Yet if you treat it as an opportunity to absorb the place where you are temporarily stranded, it will begin to yield its riches.
How do you do this? What steps should you take to begin to absorb a place’s character, even if, on the surface, it lacks anything approaching interest, let alone charm? One way, regularly advocated in this column, is to look up. Don’t look at the boring shop fronts, the railway advertising or the bus timetable. These are ephemeral. But above them you can look at the architecture that provides the background to them.
What sort of a building is it? Perhaps it’s a Victorian or an Edwardian structure; if it is, you will find plenty to delight the eye – carvings and texts, perhaps, or bricks of different colours. There may be evidence of earlier uses – old ‘ghost’ signs, perhaps, once painted on the walls and now almost vanished after a century of neglect. You may spot ornamental ridge tiles of a wide variety of designs, or some elaborate ironwork. Perhaps there are small balconies or evidence of stained glass. There may be plants growing on rooftops – buddleias are a common sight – and of course there are bound to be birds, if only the ubiquitous pigeons.
And if you’re not so fortunate to be somewhere the Victorians built in their ornate way – perhaps in a bus station in the concrete jungle of a city – you might try looking for evidence of how the concrete buildings were actually made. Were they constructed of pre-fabricated blocks that are hung on a frame? Or of poured concrete that still retains the impression of wood grain from the shuttering into which it was poured? If there is brickwork, how are the bricks laid – in the conventional modern way, just with the long, stretcher, side showing? Or has the bricklayer adopted an older bond – the alternate long and short bricks of English bond, or the alternating courses of long and short of Flemish bond?
If you’re in a place for longer than few minutes, of course, there is much more scope. Walk around (still looking up!) to see what you can spot. Resist the temptation wander through the shops – streetscape is more interesting and costs nothing to see. You may find a local museum (always good if you’re abroad, to get a flavour of a place) or a park. Or just think about what makes the local architecture distinctive – there will usually be something, whether it’s the building materials (Is it a stone area? What type of stone? Or is it brick? – look at the colour variations in the bricks. Or is wood the main material? How is it used? Are the roofs slate or tile?).
You can try this at home, too. Go to a part of Ripon, or of your local town or village, that you’ve always thought uninteresting, and really look. You will find things you’ve not noticed before – small, barely-altered cottages, perhaps, or buildings that have changed their function over the years. You may even find something fascinating about the intricacies of an industrial landscape.
There are, of course, whole series of books that work with this idea. The famous ‘Observer’s Books’ introduced many subjects to both children and adults, and got them really to look at things. And there are still the I-Spy books, which aim to capture the interest of children in looking at what’s around them. We can still learn to look and take an interest. There really is no such thing as a boring place; and, as the Queen Mother suggested, if you find it boring, the fault may lie with you . . .
