As Ripon Civic Society hands outs its annual Awards this evening, the 19th-century’s most-famous art and architecture critic John Ruskin comes to mind.
Very few people read Ruskin today. Yet in his day he was much more famous than, say, Brian Sewell or even, a few decades back, as Kenneth Clarke of ‘Civilisation’ fame. For Mr Sewell and Lord Clarke it was television that really brought them into the limelight. For John Ruskin the only mass media were the newspapers and his books.
His experience with the papers was not a happy one; he was most famously in the press was when he was sued in the High Court for his criticism of a painting by Whistler called ‘Nocturne in Black and Gold; The Falling Rocket’. Ruskin hated it for what he considered its slapdash style; he wrote that ‘I have seen, and heard, much of Cockney impudence before now; but never expected to hear a coxcomb ask two hundred guineas for flinging a pot of paint in the public’s face.’
The trial entertained the public; and Ruskin lost. The jury sided with Whistler, but only just; it awarded him damages of a farthing, and he had to pay his own costs, which bankrupted him.
Ruskin’s books had a better reception. Two of his publications stood out to his contemporaries; the multi-volume ‘Modern Painters’ in which he championed Turner, among others, and ‘The Seven Lamps of Architecture’. The ‘Seven Lamps’ looked at architecture from different standpoints, each illuminated by its own ‘lamp’. The Lamps were ‘Sacrifice’ – that whatever was created should glorify God; ‘Truth’ – that buildings should not be sham but use natural materials and display their construction honestly; ‘Power’ – that buildings should show the power of the human mind on their design; ‘Life’ – buildings should be made by hand, not machine; Beauty – ornamentation should be copied from nature; Memory – buildings should respect the culture from which they have developed; and Obedience – that architecture should not strive for originality, but follow the best English styles of the past. Much of this seems today to be very worthy, very Victorian – and very impractical.
How does all this fit with the Civic Society’s Awards, the winners of which will be revealed at the Spa Hotel this evening? Although the Society might not be able to subscribe wholeheartedly to all of Ruskin’s seven theories, it can certainly endorse some of his philosophical thinking by looking at the practical results of architecture, and environmental improvement and craftsmanship in Ripon and the surrounding area today.
So what are Ripon Civic Society’s ‘Lamps’ for its 2012 Awards? First, perhaps, comes Economic Well-being. When the Society considered its Awards last year, it was noticeable how little new building and refurbishment of existing buildings was going on. There were some excellent and worthy winners, of course, but the pool was considerably smaller than in the days when the economy wasn’t ailing. This year there seems to have been more to choose from – a hopeful indicator, along with the decreasing number of empty shops in the city, that things are at last moving.
Next, Design. When the economy was strong, buildings were erected quickly and, it appeared, either with no thought of design or, too often, aping the style of the past. Only a few architects, recognised by our Awards, took pains to provide good design. Now that we have fewer developments there seems to be a greater awareness of decent design – long may that continue.
On the other hand, we have what we might call the ‘Lamp’ of Historic Awareness’. Refurbishing an old building, or adding a new part to an historic structure needs an awareness of the past – this is what Ruskin’s ‘Lamp of Memory’ was about, too. But this doesn’t mean that an historic building requires a timid approach. Boldness can pay dividends, too. Last year the Society awarded the exemplary conversion of Dishforth’s former church into a village hall – a scheme that showed exactly how it should be done. There are excellent schemes involving old buildings in the shortlist for this year’s Awards, too.
The Society’s next lamp must be ‘Craftsmanship’ – a combination perhaps of Ruskin’s lamps of ‘Life’ and ‘Truth’. Ruskin would appreciate the fact that the Society’s Craftsmanship Award still recognises the skill and care with which craftsmen undertake work in the city and the surrounding area. The fifth ‘Lamp’ is ‘Imagination’ – thinking outside the normal pattern and coming up with clever and inspiring solutions to problems of, say reuse of buildings or of regenerating the economy. Again, the Awards have always recognised that imagination is a great asset to the area.
Two more lamps; first, ‘Social and Civic Awareness’ – the recognition that development and change must not be solely driven by profit or by economics but by the well-being of the citizens. Many projects recognised by the Awards over the years have come under this heading; the Society has given its John Whitehead Award to, for example, Ripon in Bloom and to Ripon Museum Trust in recognition of their work.
The final lamp is that of ‘Environment and Sustainability’. This is a lamp that has flickered somewhat in a recession; environmental considerations seem to take a back seat when economics rear their heads. On the other hand, schemes to promote cheaper energy from the sun, the wind, ground heat or flowing water, have increased. The Society hopes to see more, small-scale, schemes in the coming years.
So there are Ripon Civic Society’s Seven Lamps – find out next week how the Awards this evening reflect their glow.
