RIPON’S ‘WHAT IF?’s

There is a novel – perhaps not much read – by Kingsley Amis that deals with one of the ‘What if?’s of history.

It’s called ‘The Alteration’ and starts in 1976 (the year of its publication) with the funeral in St Paul’s Cathedral of ‘His most Devout Majesty, King Stephen II of England and her empire’. The crowned heads of Europe and beyond (‘the kings of Portugal, of Naples, of Sweden, of Lithuania’ as well as ‘the Crown Prince of Muscovy and the Dauphin; the brother of the Emperor of Almaigne . . .and the New Englander Ambassador’) assembled in the cathedral sit beneath with a vast ceiling painted by Turner showing the Holy Victory; there is a west window by Gainsborough showing the birth of St Helena, frescoes of St Augustine by William Blake and an ‘Ecce Homo’ by David Hockney. The music they hear sung in the service is Mozart’s Second Requiem.

All this because, of course, Amis is having fun with the idea that Henry VIII never broke from the Roman Catholic Church to establish the Church of England. England remained a devoutly catholic country, and artists and musicians used their genius gloriously to enhance the Church.

And what if we play ‘What if?’ in Ripon? What twists and turns of history have we zig-zagged through, and what decisions have been made that might have gone differently for the city and its prospects?

The first ‘What if?’ What if Eadhead, who was Bishop of Ripon from 681 to 686, had established the see of Ripon permanently? When he died, Wilfrid put the Ripon diocese into that of York – where it remained until 1836. But what if, for those 1,117 years, Ripon had remained the seat of a bishop? That would make Ripon one of the ten oldest sees in England. And with so long a history of bishops of Ripon, we may have seen a greater development of what is now the Cathedral – it may have had monastic buildings, like many cathedrals, which today would provide extra space for the church authorities and added attractions for visitors; we have only to look at the recent developments at Durham Cathedral to see the possibilities.

And then, what if, as Amis suggested, there was no break with Rome, and Henry VIII had left the monasteries alone? Would the influence of Fountains Abbey, so near, have had a greater influence on the development of Ripon? It’s undoubtedly true that Fountains exerted influence until it was dissolved in 1539, and that there was always some tension between town and monkish gown. How might this have developed in the 17th, 18th and 19th centuries? Or would social change have swept away places like Fountains Abbey in any case?

Or what if Ripon had become England’s third university town, the northern equivalent of Oxford and Cambridge? This was put forward in the late 16th century and was supported by Queen Elizabeth’s adviser Lord Burghley and by the Archbishop of York, Edwin Sandys. But Elizabeth was not convinced, so it is another ‘almost’ for Ripon. It would certainly have changed the city; we have only to think of Cambridge and Oxford today to get some inkling of how Ripon might have developed. Colleges along the banks of the Skell and the Ure (though punting seems unlikely); college chapels and halls; houses of intellectuals on the north side of the city, as in Oxford; Ripon as a centre of academic excellence and with a vibrant influx of young people.

Another question; what if William Aislabie had made a success as Chancellor of the Exchequer, made money for the nation out of the South Sea Bubble and not had to retire in disgrace to Studley Royal? We might not then have had his great garden, to which his son William added the Fountains Abbey ruins. And without it, the visitors who come to the Fountains estate (and who sometimes even come into Ripon) would go elsewhere.

In 1915 Ripon became home to a vast army camp, one of the places from which men were sent direct to the front. Wilfrid Owen was one of them, of course. But what if, instead of the camp having largely been abandoned when it was no longer in operational use, it had developed as a rival to Catterick. How would Ripon have fared as a permanent, huge garrison town? It would certainly have developed differently – but would it have been for the better or for the worse?

And coming closer to our own day, two other radical changes; Ripon lost its railway station and its rail link in the late 1960s. Then in 2001 the Ripon campus of what was by then the University College of Ripon and York St John shut and was sold. What if these events had not taken place? Certainly, it seems in retrospect a foolish and short-sighted decision to close the railway; just think how valuable it would be to us today. And the closure of the college did take some of the heart of out of the city; not only did we lose the input of the young students, but we also lost many of the staff whose skills and enthusiasm fed into the life of the city.

So, a few examples of what Robert Frost called ‘the road not taken’. Of course, we can do nothing about the past; but we can be careful for the future. We always need to bear in mind that what we decide today will have the greatest impact on the future. Decisions must be made, of course – but with careful consideration, not as a knee-jerk reaction to what is currently conceived as a problem. Which way will Ripon go? Time will tell, but we are responsible for its direction.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.