RIPON COMPARED

‘Odyous of olde been comparisonis, And of comparisonis engendyrd is haterede’ as John Lydgate wrote about 1440 or, as we might put it, ‘Comparisons are odious’.

It’s an old idea, then – yet despite its age, it is one of those sayings that really have no effect. Much of life depends on comparisons – from insurance websites to school league tables, from Which? Magazine to Trip Advisor, we rely on seeing how one thing compares with another.

So when the Greater Ripon Improvement Partnership (GRIP) offered a student from the York Management School at the University of York the chance to undertake a study related to Ripon, the agreed title was ‘A Comparative Case Study of the Success of Four Yorkshire Market Towns with Ripon as a Focal Point’ – the study is a dissertation that forms part of the student’s submission for an MA in Management.

For the comparison, GRIP and the student agreed that the report would see how Ripon compares with three towns that appeared to be broadly similar to Ripon, yet were often perceived as being more economically successful. They are Skipton, Northallerton and Beverley.

After a brief survey of the history of market towns, as centres where a rural population could bring its produce to sell, the report examines how they gradually changed into places of general commerce in the 19th century, only to be undermined in the 20th century by the advent of supermarkets and out-of-town shopping complexes.

Looking at ‘Strategies for Change’, the report underlines that decline is not inevitable, and that there are policies and schemes that can help, including the Localism Act of 2011 and bodies like Action for Market Towns and the appointment of Town Teams. But the meat of the report is in the comparisons of the four places. How does Ripon compare?

Looking first at populations, Beverley, with 18,398 people, has almost 2000 more than Ripon; Skipton has 14,530 and Northallerton 10,330. Skipton has four market days, Beverley and Northallerton both have two; Ripon has just one. Ripon has two colleges/sixth form centres within 4 miles – better than Northallerton which has one, but worse that Skipton’s four and Beverley’s six. Ripon is also further from its nearest university. And, of course, Northallerton and Beverley have central council offices, with much professional employment, and Skipton has the headquarters of a major building society.

Within the immediate area, Ripon and Northallerton can claim nine supermarkets; Beverley has six, Skipton currently has four. All except Skipton have a high proportion of multiple chain stores and, as a consequence, fewer independents. Ripon is the only one of the four that is judged to have a ‘high’ volume of charity shops.

When it comes to services and entertainment the picture is brighter; all four places have the services (hospital, doctors and dentists, police and fire stations and a Town Hall) that you might expect – though the study does not quantify them or assess their effectiveness. All four also have a range of entertainment facilities – Ripon and Beverley have no cinema (though that’s about to change for Ripon); Skipton and Northallerton have no racecourse.

Significantly, Ripon is the only place without a railway connection. It also has the lowest ratio of parking spaces per head of population. Skipton is the only one with a Park and Ride Bus – and, probably as a consequence, the highest parking charges. Ripon has the lowest number of hotels or inns in a central location (four as opposed to Skipton’s eight) with, again possibly as a result of supply and demand, the highest cost per night.

The average age of Ripon’s population is 38.86 – the youngest (though not by much) of the four places, and the lowest percentage of those over 45. Ripon residents are assessed as being the second most affluent after Beverley, though this does not take factors like mortgages, living costs or tax rates. Ripon people seem to rely more on their own transport rather than public transport than do the residents of the other towns. The report looks at other factors, including house prices (Ripon’s are the highest) and average crime rate (Ripon is second after Beverley; all are quite low)

How do residents view their own towns? How far are they satisfied? Do they consider their towns successful? Here the report makes salutary reading for Ripon. Assessed on a scale of one to five (five being best), the success rate perceived for Ripon is at level 3; the other three towns are rated higher, at 4. A quarter of responses rated Ripon at only 2. The figure includes visitors as well as residents. Among residents only there were lots of 2s and 3s, with no top marks of 5, which were found in the other towns. So the perception of Ripon’s success is lower than we might wish.

So what’s the outcome of all this? The report makes long-term and short-term recommendations. The latter include promoting Ripon better as a ‘quality destination’, looking at the possibility of an extra market day and extending trading hours. It also suggests working more closely with local schools, tidying shop fronts and making better use of empty retail units and connecting better with the outside world by using social media.

Longer-term goals should include railway reinstatement and better transport links with Ripon’s hinterland villages, looking at additional parking and a Park and Ride scheme, more accommodation for visitors and better signposting.

Attentive readers of this column will realise that little of this is new – they are recommendations that have been made for Ripon before. But to see the city coming second (or fourth) best to other Yorkshire market towns is salutary. The report is of great value in mirroring the reality for Ripon. What we now need is the determination to act on its recommendations.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.