Those of you of mature years (shall we say?) may recall the original broadcast of the television series ‘Civilisation’ in 1969. Or you may have seen it for the first time in 2005, when it was shown again on BBC4. The series is nothing less than a survey of Western art, architecture and philosophy since the Dark Ages. You might argue that this is a limited view of what constitutes ‘civilisation’; it ignores Japan and China, Africa and the whole of the Americas, for example.
Nevertheless, it was a ground-breaking programme, and attracted a very large audience; it certainly increased the sale of colour television sets so that viewers could see the art in its full glory. And, despite its comparatively narrow field, ‘Civilisation’ was given space – there were 13 programmes, each 50 minutes long – nearly 11 hours of television on what many would have considered a very specialist subject. Would that the television bosses had the courage to allow such expansiveness these days!
It was enormously successful and achieved many awards both for the programme itself and for its presenter, the then Sir Kenneth Clark. It is said that it led to his becoming a life peer, Lord Clark of Saltwood (though many said he was ‘Lord Clark of Civilisation’). Clark himself said that he always felt rather a fraud, not being really an intellectual or a proper art historian, merely one who could pick up facts and retell them in a reasonably accessible manner.
Despite his somewhat patrician tones, and his ability to walk into shot and partially obscure the subject of his talk, Clark was certainly the right man for the job. His background had prepared him for such a role. From the first volume, ‘Another Part of the Wood’, of his entertaining two-volume autobiography, we learn of his privileged upbringing – his father inherited wealth from the family thread manufacturing firm in Paisley and spent an idle life, with plenty of yachting and buying and selling country houses; he was also a keen gambler, and on several occasions broke the bank at Monte Carlo.
Young Kenneth spent much of his childhood at Sudbourne Hall near Orford in Suffolk, and in the Scottish Highlands. At Sudbourne one of his chief pleasures was rehanging the pictures in the rooms – something that set him up for his future career as Keeper of Fine Arts at Oxford’s Ashmolean Museum, Keeper of the King’s Pictures and Director of the National Gallery. By the time he went to school at the age of seven – and more so at Winchester – he was already an unusual boy with a love of art history. After Oxford, where he studied, of course, the History of Art, he went to work for Bernard Berenson, great guru and authenticator of artworks. He got his Ashmolean job at the age of 30, and in quick order attained the highest ranks in his profession.
Never slow to offer an opinion and always urbane, charming and clear in his talks, it was no wonder that he became, through his writings and his lectures, the voice of art in the country. He did television work before the war, but in the 1950s became the man for art – that he was also Chairman of the Independent Television Authority helped, too.
‘Civilisation’ brought him before many more people, and he attained an eminence that no art historian can hope for today. His only equal, perhaps, was one of his heroes, John Ruskin. In the mid-19th century Ruskin’s word on art had almost the status of holy writ. His pronouncements on art influenced how 19th century Britain viewed its art. He championed Turner in his book ‘Modern Painters’ and Gothic architecture in ‘The Stones of Venice’. He fought a famous libel case with the painter Whistler; Ruskin accused Whistler of ‘Cockney impudence’ in his one of his paintings, calling him a ‘coxcomb’ for asking ‘two hundred guineas for flinging a pot of paint in the public’s face’. Ruskin lost his case – and Whistler was awarded damages of a farthing.
Kenneth Clark’s admiration for Ruskin lasted throughout his life; Clark’s first book ‘The Gothic Revival’, which came out in 1928 has a chapter on Ruskin, and he later claimed that his best book was his compilation from Ruskin’s extensive writings in ‘Ruskin Today’, published in 1964.
And where are the successors to Ruskin and Clark today? Who are the arbiters of taste, the popularisers of art, the pundits whose opinion we accept as sound and correct? Perhaps we are too close to them to recognise them for what they are. In art, we have Brian Sewell, Waldemar Januszczak and Andrew Graham-Dixon, all, in their different ways television figures. And we have Sister Wendy, too. None of them, though, has achieved the Clark status, maybe because television is no longer the same dominant force it was when we had only three or four channels. In architecture – well, who? No one since Betjeman and Pevsner, perhaps.
Does this matter? Should we look for people to lead us in how we ought to look? Given that too many people are blind to what constitutes good art and architecture, and do not notice what is around them, it can only be a good thing for us to have someone who can metaphorically take us by the hand and lead us through art, pointing out the landmarks and increasing our appreciation.
It doesn’t have to be a television performer, of course; it may be a good teacher, a speaker at an event who opens our eyes to a particular subject – or even a newspaper column! Perhaps we should not look for another dominant figure like Clark or Ruskin, but accept guidance from wherever it can come. As long as we are open to such guidance, Lord Clark ‘of Civilisation’ would have been satisfied.
