‘A critic is a man who knows the way but can’t drive the car,’ wrote Kenneth Tynan in 1966; he was a man who knew what he was talking about – he was a theatre critic.
It’s always been easy to regard critics as a slightly (or more than slightly) inferior class of people; as long ago as 1625 Sir Henry Wotton write that ‘Critics are like brushers of noblemens’ clothes’ – in other words, like the lower servants. And Disraeli was equally forthright; ‘You know who the critics are? The men who have failed in literature and art.’
Yet, given all this condemnation, we still have critics in all fields of human endeavour – more now than ever before, given the explosion in social media. It is now so easy to ‘leave feedback’, to ‘give us your views’, to add that (safely anonymous) critique on a website that can damn an enterprise just as crushingly as a Roman Emperor’s downturned thumb.
Critical writing on architecture, too, is easy to condemn. Architects themselves often view any writing about their work as, as one blogging architect put it, ‘always a bit of a contradiction, and ultimately pointless. Architecture expresses itself as architecture . . . and certainly not words on paper.’ In an absolute sense that must be true, just as a symphony or an opera, a ballet or a painting expresses itself in its own form.
Yet as long as there has been architecture there have been critics of it and writers about it (well, almost as long – no criticism of prehistoric huts has yet emerged from the mists of time). There are seventh-century descriptions (perhaps not critical examinations) of St Wilfrid’s churches at Ripon and at Hexham by both Bede and Wilfrid’s biographer Eddius. When Canterbury Cathedral burned down In 1174, an eyewitness, the monk Gervase, wrote of its magnificence and the desire of people to preserve as much of the ruined fabric as possible.
Francis Bacon, in his essay ‘Of Building’ of 1597, writes about his perfect large building: ‘I say you cannot have a perfect palace except you have two several [sic] sides; a side for the banquet . . . and a side for the household; the one for feasts and triumphs, and the other for dwelling.’ Again, this is hardly criticism, more prescription. More scathing was the criticism by Roger Pratt, (the first English architect to be knighted) of Christopher Wren’s designs for the new St Paul’s Cathedral; they were, he said, not stately enough’ and that ‘Architecture here has not received those advantages which it has in other parts, it continuing almost still as rude here as it was at the very first’ – a plea for looking to the Italian architectural designs of men like Bernini, Fontana and Borromini.
A generation later, Colen Campbell, in ‘Vitruvius Britannicus’ of 1714, took the opposite view: ‘How affected and licentious are the works of Bernini and Fontana? How wildly extravagant are the Designs of Borromini, who has endeavoured to debauch Mankind with his odd and chimerical Beauties, where the Parts are without Proportion, Solids without their true Bearing, Heaps of Materials without Strength, excessive Ornaments without Grace, and the Whole without Symmetry?’
Like nearly all architectural writing, this was hardly unbiased. Campbell had his own agenda, that of promoting the more austere Palladian style. So successful were he and the Earl of Burlington, who employed Campbell to remodel Burlington House in London’s Piccadilly, that Palladianism was to hold sway for many decades.
By the 19th century, architectural criticism had become a recognised, though not always welcome, profession. Helping it on its way was Horace Walpole, who was always ready with a critical line, and was keen to push his own ideas about Gothic architecture, which he considered, offered ‘a whimsical air of novelty’. When the Cambridge Camden Society was founded in 1839 to ‘promote the study of Gothic Architecture, and of Ecclesiastical Antiques’, they did not stint in their criticism of new buildings; neither did Pugin, whose ‘Contrasts’ attempted to show how the buildings of his own day were vastly inferior to those of the Middle Ages.
Then there was Ruskin, who was one of the most severe and influential architectural critics of the Victoria era. Nikolaus Pevsner described Ruskin as ‘a superb though maddening writer and a confused thinker, though one with frequent flashes of genius’.
Ruskin’s writing is often what we today would term ‘over-elaborate’: sentences like ‘The goodly building is the most glorious, when it is sculptured into the likeness of the leaves of Paradise’ sounds glorious, but is not exactly helpful to architects trying to form their style. Nevertheless, Ruskin’s essay ‘On the Nature of Gothic’, from which this quotation is taken, was described by William Morris as ‘one of the very few necessary and inevitable utterances of the century’.
As we moved into the 20th century the number of architectural writers increased dramatically. These days we remember John Betjeman, who had a style that, while it could be trenchant, was always readable; Pevsner, who was always thorough but sometimes indigestible; and, perhaps, Ian Nairn, recently the subject of a BBC4 documentary, perhaps one of the most opinionated – even emotional – and readable of all.
Today we are as likely to see architectural critics (sometimes masquerading as architectural historians) on the television as to read their words. The telegraphing Dan Cruickshank is often on our screens; Waldemar Januszczak is grittier and more forthright; Jonathan Glancey perhaps more cerebral. All can write and speak entertainingly on architecture for a wide audience.
Good architectural writers and critics can illuminate our understanding of our built heritage and guide our ideas about the future. But perhaps the last word should go to a website commentator, who, when answering the question posed by the Architects’ Journal ‘What are the hallmarks of a brilliantly-written building study?’ replied succinctly: ‘Pictures.’
