You may recollect that very ancient television sketch – from The Frost Report of 1966, to be precise – with John Cleese as the tall toff in a bowler hat, Ronnie Barker in a trilby as the rotund Middle Class man, and the diminutive Ronnie Corbett, in cloth cap and muffler, as the representative of the Working Man. If you do remember it (or have seen one of its multitudinous repeats), you will recall Corbett’s most famous line: ‘I know my place’.
Whether we still need to know our place socially can be debated endlessly; but really to know our place – the place where we live – is certainly of vital importance. It has always been the aim of the Civic Societies movement to ensure that we have a sense of place, that we care for our environment and encourage good new development. Perhaps it is no coincidence that the movement gained its greatest impetus in the 1960s, when Cleese, Barker and Corbett were lampooning the class structure.
Last month a report on place appeared; it’s called ‘Our Future in Place’, and is otherwise known as ‘The Farrell Review of Architecture and the Built Environment’. It was written at the request of the Minister for Creative Industries, Ed Vaizey by a team led by the distinguished modern architect Sir Terry Farrell CBE (architect of the MI6 building on the Thames in London, which has featured in the Bond films ‘The World is Not Enough’ and ‘Skyfall’, and of The Deep in Hull). The impetus for the Review was to provide information as the Department of Culture, Media and Sport formulates its plans for promoting high standards of design.
The Farrell Review takes the word PLACE as its starting point and uses it as an acronym for Planning, Landscape, Architecture, Conservation and Engineering, all of which are vital, the team argues, in prompting a sense of place and in educating the planners and the politicians of the future so that we can improve the quality of urban design. As a supplementary, the committee suggests that PLACE can also stand for Politics, Life, Advocacy, Community and the Environment – all matters close to the heart of any civic society, and, indeed, to every community in the country.
There is a call for ‘a new level of connectedness between government departments, institutions, agencies professions and the public’ and for ‘a new level of public engagement through education and outreach in every village, town and city’ – again, music to the ears of the civic movement. To help achieve this Nirvana the Farrell Review offers 60 recommendations about how professional education, school and community education should be developed.
Farrell believes that architecture and the built environment should be an integral part of many school subjects, with professionals in these areas engaging with schools to increase and promote knowledge of their local area – again something civic societies have long sought to do. But such education does not stop at the school gates; Farrell suggests that event town and city should have an ‘urban room’ or a ‘Place Space’ (as happens in every Chinese and Japanese community) which should include a model of the settlement and which can act as an exhibition and learning space, where the community can get together to discuss both the past and the future of the place.
There are recommendations about the better integration of professional training for the many professionals that come together to influence a community, including, though not exclusively, the planning, landscape, architecture, conservation and engineering professions that form PLACE.
As importantly, the Review underlines the importance of changing the current planning regime from a largely reactive one, where planning decisions are made as a result of pressures, to one where there are agreed principles and plans against which applications are tested. As the Review notes, where such plans are in place ‘it is very often down to strong leadership and the right skills within local authorities’ – which again brings it back to education, not just for council officers but for the elected members, too. The Neighbourhood Plans that a number of local authorities (including Ripon) are currently formulating is a first step in fighting this reactive way of doing things, but much more needs to be done.
Farrell recommends that every public body needs an independent ‘PLACE Review Panel’ to keep authorities on their toes. And, the Review notes, ‘Places will only become great if there is civic leadership, whether it’s from politicians, community groups or built environment specialists’. It recommends that ‘each local authority could nominate a built environment professional from the private sector and an elected member to champion local design quality. ‘Civic Champions’ actively engaging with neighbourhood forums could help shape neighbourhood plans and improve design quality’ – an extension of the short-lived vogue for local authority ‘Heritage Champions’ that flamed briefly a few years ago then sputtered out.
Considering listed buildings, the Farrell Review says that the listing process, by which buildings are given protection, ‘should be made less academic and more open, transparent and democratic . . . we should all have a say in what is listed.’ And it points out the important lesson that ‘now there is widespread recognition that preserving the old is no longer at odds with designing the new.’
In his personal conclusion to the Review, Sir Terry Farrell argues that the built environment is as important as other aspects of our lives: ‘In the last few decades our food and our health have been transformed and we now expect and demand so much more, such higher standards. Our built environment, our buildings and our places are just as critical to our happiness and wellbeing. What is facing us is how to raise this part of our culture to similar levels.’ It’s a message Civic Societies have been pushing for years – perhaps at last we have the impetus to make it reality.
