SOLVING THE HOUSING NUMBERS IN THE BACK-LANDS

‘Crisis’ is a good newspaper headline word. ‘Slammed’ is another. And, more often than not, when they are allied to the word ‘Council’, we know that there is the scent of failure in the air. So when in last week’s Ripon Gazette we read ‘Council slammed over possible planning crisis’ we know that there is something up.

The ‘planning crisis’ is the decision by a government planning inspector to call Harrogate Borough Council’s plans for housing in its area ‘inadequate’ and to suggest a rethink. The inspector says that the area needs almost 1100 new dwellings (or ‘homes’, to use the looser term preferred these days) each year. By suggesting that the council’s plans will not deliver anything like that number, and that it needs to think again, the planning process has been thrown open once more. This has led to fears that developers will use the inevitable hiatus to leap in and demand planning permission for new houses in areas that local people consider unsuitable – and with the council having little power to stop them under the recently-revised national planning laws.

Does this constitute a ‘crisis’? And should the council be ‘slammed’? That will depend on your point of view; but there is certainly a dilemma created by this turn of events. It is to try to help with such dilemmas that the Ripon Neighbourhood Plan (the ‘City Plan’) is being formulated; the spat (another good headline word) between council and inspector will certainly have an effect on the City Plan’s formulation.

Yet need it be so much of a crisis? To most politicians (and possibly to most government inspectors and to readers of newspapers) new homes means new buildings. And whether these are on so-called ‘brownfield sites’ that have been used for some type of structure before, or on greenfield sites – previously undeveloped land (though not necessarily the ‘attractive open countryside’ that objectors always claim) – the effect is the same: the builders move in and new houses, sometimes of dubious architectural worth, are thrown up as cheaply as possible and sold as expensively as possible. It need not always be so, of course; the Ripon Civic Society Annual Awards, mentioned in this column last week, have regularly sought out good examples of new building, including new houses, and rewarded them appropriately.

But there are other ways of providing for the housing needs of the local area, by thinking laterally or, even more appropriately, ‘outside the box’. It’s not always necessary to construct new ‘little boxes’ to meet the number of new dwellings needed. There is plenty of spare room in the Harrogate area where people could live – in the ‘backlands’ behind the shopping streets and in the unused upper levels of shops.

Some years ago Ripon was a leader in the idea of ‘Living over the Shop’ – a campaign to open up dusty and disused upper floors, whose only function, often, is to house unwanted stock and out-dated display materials, for use as flats. In addition to this, any assiduous explorer of the city of Ripon will soon notice that behind the shops, pubs and restaurants there are plenty of empty or little-used buildings, some of them in an unhappy condition. With some thought and money these could be turned from eyesores into dwellings – and even into real homes.

As part of the search for nominations for the Civic Society’s Awards this year members of the Awards committee recently visited a scheme that has done just that, near the top of Kirkgate. Regular visitors to the city centre will know that this part of the city has for long caused concern as various owners neglected their premises and the impression given to residents and visitors was of a scruffy and unkempt part of the city.

The shops on the north side of Kirkgate, just below the Skipton Building Society, had been boarded up for some time. Behind them, accessed through one of Ripon’s many alleyways – this one, Lowley’s Court, had, like too many of them, been sealed off by a solid doorway – is a range of buildings that have been long disused. Now, though, all this has been transformed.

The look of this building is deceptive. It is one of the many Ripon buildings that have a ‘polite’ brick Georgian façade (this one colour-washed in red to achieve uniformity). This front hides a much earlier building, possibly from the 16th century, with ancient timbers forming its basic framework. Inside, it still retains some Georgian balustrading on the staircase and early-19th-century fireplaces. The range of buildings behind was always more modest, but is still handsome.

In the restoration and development work two flats have been created on the two floors above the shops, each with a spacious sitting room with views along Kirkgate, as well as bedrooms and well-fitted kitchens and bathrooms. The work has been done sympathetically, keeping much of the old character of the building while providing for today’s living style. Behind, a three-bedroom cottage has been created, again keeping much of the style of the original. Access is through the alley, which has been paved and which leads to a small courtyard with (much needed these days) adequate bin storage for the properties.

All this is well done – but should not be something out of the ordinary. Buildings’ owners should be encouraged by the council to look at the possibilities their properties offer for creating new housing. There needs, too, to be a national rethink about how such developments are both promoted and taxed – it is ludicrous that, generally, restorations attract VAT but new-builds don’t.

Keep your eyes open as you go around and see just where such restorations could take place to provide new houses and flats; you may be surprised how many you spot. And you may also feel that it’s possible to provide a good proportion of those 1100 houses in the area without the recourse to building afresh.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.