It’s summer (even if occasionally the weather would rather we forget the fact), and for many people it’s a time for visiting gardens. If you’re one of them, you might visit because you’re a plantsman or plantswoman, knowing plant names and admiring the skill (or criticising the lack of skill) with which the gardeners present the displays. Or you may just relish the contrasts of scent and colour, shape and form that gives a particular garden its unique ambience
If you’re interested in architecture, though, you may pay some attention to the structure of the garden – the bones of the layout on which the plants form the substance. In all but the simplest cottage garden (and sometimes even there) thought needs to be given to how the garden areas relate to any buildings, and to each other.
Of course, the fashion for different garden designs changes as often as fashion in plants. The difference between an Elizabethan knot-garden and a Capability Brown landscape is immense, but both come from the same impulse, to make nature attractive to the eye. It cannot be done without some artifice, some element of design that enables the garden to ‘work’. The Elizabethans often surrounded their gardens with walls or raised walkways. Capability Brown’s landscapes, with their apparently seamless integration of a great house into a pastoral setting, relied on something else – a revolution in garden design called the ha-ha.
The ditch and wall of a typical ha-ha separate a great house from its surrounding parkland without using fences or obvious walls, and give the appearance of vast, uninterrupted landscapes without the inconveniences of sheep, cattle and deer wandering across the lawns and peering in through the drawing-room windows. This is a typical 18th-century conceit, allowing the gentry to claim ownership of apparently-unlimited great estates.
The ha-ha began in a small way in the French gardens of the 17th century. Some were just a few yards long, across the end of an allee of hedges or trees to make the vista appear to continue into the countryside. Also known as a saut de loup, such a ha-ha was a modest affair, but its value was soon recognised and larger ones, enclosing whole gardens, were constructed.
According to Horace Walpole’s ‘History of the Modern Taste in Gardening’, the Royal Gardener Charles Bridgeman was responsible for bringing the ha-ha to Britain. An earlier claimant, however, seems to be the Frenchman Guillaume Beaumont who in about 1695 surrounded the garden at Levens Hall in Cumbria, now famous for its topiary garden, with a great ditch to separate it from the parkland.
But why was such a ditch called a ha-ha? Another Frenchman, Dezallier D’Argenville, writing in 1709, gave the explanation in his ‘Theory and Practice of Gardening’. ‘At present we frequently make Through-views, call’d Ah, Ah, which are Openings in the Walls, without Grills, to the very level of the Walls, with a large and deep Ditch at the Foot of them, lined on both Sides to sustain the Earth, and prevent the getting over, which surprises the Eye upon coming near it, and makes one cry Ah! Ah! from whence it takes its name.’
As a device to separate the garden from the park, the ha-ha was seized upon and became enormously fashionable. Opening up the landscape as viewed from the house or its immediate garden became the rule which, as Jane Austen wrote in Mansfield Park, ‘affected country residences by the thousand. It was indeed a period when every house of any pretensions had its walls swept away and a ha-ha substituted’.
Most of the better-known 18th-century gardens had ha-has. The earliest, such as that at Levens Hall, form great bastions resembling Tudor fortifications. At Castle Howard, Vanbrugh’s Temple of the Four Winds is built at a corner of the ha-ha. At nearby Duncombe Park, the retaining walls are built in huge curving sweeps, with superb rusticated masonry, while at Bramham Park they come to sharp points. The ha-ha at Stowe in Buckinghamshire, provided by Bridgeman, encloses the famous garden in a loose diamond pattern. Beyond it long rides and paths cutting through the woods were laid out; the style can still be seen at Cirencester Park, while at Badminton in Gloucestershire the park was laid out with great avenues of trees that were continued across the countryside by the Duke’s neighbours.
Horace Walpole considered the ha-ha the greatest invention of gardening, allowing garden, park and countryside to seem as one. And the man he credits with the greatest appreciation of the ha-ha’s value was the architect and landscape gardener William Kent, who, he said, ‘leaped the fence and saw all Nature was a garden’. Kent also worked at Stowe, and was succeeded by Capability Brown. For Kent, Brown and their myriad provincial imitators, the ha-ha was the essential element of their work.
How much did it cost to keep up with horticultural fashion? Was it for the sake of economy as well as fashion that stout walls were abandoned? Boswell noted in 1783 that Dr Johnson reckoned a mile of park wall in England cost £1,000. But ha-has were not much cheaper; twelve years later a ha-ha at Moseley Hall in Warwickshire, 24-feet wide at the top and with turfed sides, cost 7s ld a yard, or very nearly £700 a mile—and this, apparently, without the brick or stone retaining wall.
If you have an historic ha-ha you’re very likely to find that it’s officially a listed building, and that you have responsibility to keep it up. And the responsibility can’t be ignored; there have been High Court cases in which local authorities have won the right to enforce the reinstatement of ha-has that had been neglected or filled in.
So next time you’re on a garden visit, look out for the ha-ha – it’s there to divide the garden from the park, keep the animals in their place – and to surprise you into exclamation!
