BODLEY – ARCHITECT OF GRACE AND REFINEMENT

‘Unquestionably the most influential architect at work in the Anglican Church during the last third of the nineteenth century’ says the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography of George Frederick Bodley, the next in this summer series on the life and works of Yorkshire-born architects. That influence continued well into the 20th century, and spread beyond the confines of the Church of England.

Bodley was born in March 1827 at 4 Albion Street in Hull, the sixth son of a doctor. He seems to have become interested in architecture by reading ‘Principles of Gothic Architecture’ by Matthew Bloxham, which was published in 1829, and was encouraged to take it up as a career by Sir George Gilbert Scott, whose brother was married to Bodley’s sister. From the age of 18 he was taken into Scott’s office in Spring Gardens, off Trafalgar Square, as a pupil.

He stayed for five years, learning the details of his chosen profession, but also, along with fellow pupils George Edmund Street and William White, chafing against what they saw as Scott’s narrow insistence on using only the architectural style of late-13th-century England. When, on leaving Scott, he set up his own practice, Bodley developed his style by developing Gothic into a modern style; That may seem odd to us today, especially as he looked at forms of early Gothic to inspire him; but his elegant, pared-down style was to have a significant impact on later architects; its influence can be seen in Edward Maufe’s Guildford Cathedral (consecrated in 1961, though designed in 1933) and Basil Spence’s Coventry Cathedral (designed in 1950 and consecrated in 1962), as well as in more modern churches.

Bodley was fortunate in the timing of his career, for many of his churches were built for clergy who had been influenced by the Oxford Movement’s restatement of the catholicity of Anglicanism, and who were interested in expressing it in ritual. They needed churches in which that ritual could be decently and reverently expressed. Two of Bodley’s earliest churches were for a ritualist vicar in the Cotswolds. The church at Selsley in Gloucestershire is his first major work; it is an impressive, tall church with a strong tower. For the stained glass Bodley gave the commission to the firm newly-founded by William Morris and his friends.

Other early churches designed by Bodley include St Michael’s in Brighton (‘a boyish effort, even antagonistic’, wrote Bodley later; the church he built was soon dwarfed by a large addition designed in an even more antagonistic style by William Burges) and All Saints in Cambridge, which is much more like the work of his teacher Scott than many of his other churches, though full of un-Scott-like painted decoration, much of it designed by Bodley himself.

The best of his early churches are at Tue Brook in Liverpool and at St Martin’s in Scarborough; both are built in a refined version of Gothic that soon became Bodley’s trademark. St Martin’s in particular (a job he got because its founder, Mary Craven, was a next-door neighbour of the Bodleys in Hull) is a showpiece of Pre-Raphaelite art; as well as the Morris firm’s stained glass there is a pulpit decorated with paintings by Rossetti, paintings by Spencer Stanhope and more painted decoration. There is a story that Bodley did some of the painting himself and narrowly escaped serious injury when working high up by the light of a gas light, which suddenly flared up, causing him to lose his balance and almost to fall.

In the mid-1870s Bodley designed two of his greatest works, in very contrasting styles – the churches of St Augustine, Pendlebury, a church in the poor suburbs of Manchester, and Holy Angels at Hoar Cross in Staffordshire, in the grounds of a country house. The brick-built Pendlebury church is a single space, with no division of nave and chancel, and has weighty though elegant internal buttresses supporting the high roof. Here the detail is sparse; it is the line of the Gothic style that is important, and which was to influence later architects. Hoar Cross is the opposite – of stone, with a traditional layout, and full of carved decoration and fittings designed by Bodley. By now he had moved from Morris’s glass, which he saw as too assertive, to Burlison and Grylls, a company Bodley and his some-time partner Thomas Garner set up. Burlison and Grylls glass is light and silvery, so it doesn’t compete with the architecture.

In the long list of Bodley’s work two estate churches stand out; one is at Eccleston in Cheshire, for the Duke of Grosvenor, which has a sturdy tower and flying buttresses. The other is at Clumber Park in the Dukeries, commissioned by the Duke of Newcastle, where the spire is surrounded by a corona of masonry, exactly like the medieval church at Patrington, which Bodley must have known from his Hull childhood.

Towards the end of his life Bodley, who had been architect to York Minster since 1882, entered the competition to design a new cathedral at Truro; he lost to John Loughborough Pearson. He was very disappointed, but there were two consolation prizes; one was the new cathedral in Washington DC, which was partially built to his design. The other was his appointment in 1904 as co-architect – with the 21-year-old Giles Gilbert Scott, grandson of his old master – of the new Liverpool Anglican Cathedral. The young Scott had won the competition to design it. The Lady Chapel at Liverpool bears much of Bodley’s stamp.

Bodley was not a good businessman – he used his cheque book for architectural sketches – but had a good office manager and some outstanding pupils, including the designers and architects CR Ashbee, Ninian Comper, Walter Tapper and Robert Lorimer – the last three eventually being knighted. In his private life he delighted in music – he played the organ and piano – and published a small book of verse.

But it is his great churches that are his monument, and which are worth seeking out and studying, as a lesson in how to handle Gothic, sometimes thought of as a rough style, with grace and delicacy.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.