John Francis Bentley, the fourth in this series of Yorkshire-born architects, was an outsider. Never really part of the group of famous Victorian designers (Gilbert Scott, George Edmund Street, George Frederick Bodley . . .) he began as a conventional Gothic architect but is now best known as an architect in what came to be called the Byzantine style. His most famous building, the Roman Catholic Cathedral in Westminster, was admired and hated in equal degrees by his contemporaries – and even his appointment as its architect caused much comment.
Bentley was born in Doncaster in January 1839. His father Charles was a wine merchant (his mother had the appropriate maiden name of Bacchus) who educated him at home for the first few years of his life. In 1853, when he was 14, John made a model of the medieval St George’s Church in Doncaster; the church had been destroyed by fire in that year and was soon being rebuilt to designs by Sir Gilbert Scott. Bentley was often on site and came to know the workmen very well, and in 1854, when they were also working on the restoration of the church at Loversall, south of Doncaster, they used him as a voluntary superintendent, and let him try his hand at stone-carving there.
Bentley’s father disapproved of the idea of an architectural career and John was first apprenticed, in 1855, to a firm of mechanical engineers in Manchester, but later that year went to London as an apprentice to a building firm – perhaps a compromise by his father. Bentley senior died the next year; by this time John’s employers had recognised his ability as a designer and in 1857 sent him to work with architect Henry Clutton. Clutton was in partnership with William Burges (architect of the churches at Studley Royal and Skelton-on-Ure), and Burges made sure that Bentley was thoroughly grounded in drawing, particularly of full-sized architectural details and sculpture.
In 1860 Clutton offered Bentley a partnership in the firm, but Bentley wanted to set up on his own. He spent the next few years undertaking a variety of commissions, including designs for stained glass, metalwork, sculpture, embroidery and organ cases. In 1862 he took an important step – one of the steps that made him an architectural outsider. He converted to Roman Catholicism, and was baptised by Cardinal Wiseman.
Although his conversion cut him off from some of the more mainstream Anglican architectural commissions, it did give him opportunities in the Catholic Church. Over the next few years he designed a seminary in Hammersmith, furnishings for a church in Marylebone and a new baptistery for St Francis’ Church, Notting Hill, where he was received into the Church. These were Gothic in style, but he also built a school in the Renaissance style in Old Windsor. Of the five churches that were built to Bentley’s designs, most are of simple brick construction in the Gothic style. The best is the Church of the Holy Rood in Watford, which combines a strong – perhaps heavy – exterior with an impressive interior.
In his native Yorkshire Bentley’s work is represented by the interior designs he did for the state rooms at Carlton Towers, south of Selby, for Lord Beaumont. He spent much time and effort on the work, which combines Venetian Gothic and Renaissance styles. His designs demonstrate that Bentley was open to new ideas – and that openness led to his most important commission.
In 1894 the Roman Catholic Church, having been viewed with some suspicion in Britain since the Pope had restored its hierarchy of bishops and archbishops here in 1850, felt confident enough to look at having its own cathedral in London. Cardinal Vaughan, archbishop of Westminster since 1892, invited Bentley, as a leading Catholic architect, to design Westminster Cathedral. There was no competition for the design, as there might have been for other prestigious buildings; Bentley never entered competitions. Other architects grumbled, especially as Bentley was not well known outside Catholic circles, but Vaughan was insistent. The Cardinal was also determined that the new cathedral should not be Gothic, so as not to compete with Westminster Abbey.
Bentley decided on the Byzantine style, and immediately set off for a tour of Italy, taking in Milan, Pavia, Florence, Rome and Venice. He was unable to get to Constantinople because of an outbreak of cholera there. When he returned to London he submitted his design for a basilica with shallow domes, lit by both round-headed and semi-circular windows, plenty of side chapels, and a tall, landmark tower. The building is largely of brick, with stone dressings. It remains unfinished, for the marble adornment of the interior, part of Bentley’s design, is incomplete – though the bare brick arches and domes of the nave are perhaps the more impressive in this state.
Bentley’s fellow architects were impressed; Norman Shaw wrote that it was ‘beyond all doubt the finest church that has been built for centuries’, while W R Lethaby said, ‘inside , the instant impression is that of reality, reason and power, serenity and peace.’ Other people – mostly anti-Catholics – were less impressed; the 6th Earl Fitzwilliam thought he would have to change bedrooms in his Grosvenor Square house to avoid seeing the cathedral’s tower.
Bentley did not live to see his masterpiece finished. The tower was still lacking its top 50 feet, and few of the interior fittings had been put in place; it was not consecrated until 1910. He died in March 1902, the day before he was to be nominated by the Royal Institute of British Architects (which he never joined) for the Royal Gold Medal in Architecture. At his funeral Cardinal Vaughan paid tribute to Bentley: ‘All through his life John F. Bentley had been guided by two principles—one, love for his art and fidelity to its principles . . . His second guiding principle was that what he did for God must be of the best. The honour of God was ever before his mind.’
