We’ve come a long way in our appreciation of Victorian buildings since the days when the general attitude was ‘Pull it all down – it’s ugly and grimy and needs replacing.’ Now there is much more appreciation of its qualities and vigour. But what of its successor architecture – the buildings designed and erected in the reigns of Edward VII and George V? Who are the great architects of that period?
Did you say ‘Edwin Lutyens’? Certainly his is the best-known name, though for many people their appreciation of his work stops at the Arts and Crafts houses that he built relatively early in his career, with their tile-hanging, mullioned windows and gardens designed by Gertrude Jekyll. Not so many will know his later, more classically-inspired buildings – though there may be a recollection of pictures of New Delhi, some of which was designed by his contemporary Herbert Baker, who also rebuilt the Bank of England. But what of Lutyens’ classical-style office buildings, like Britannic House and the former Midland Bank in the London thoroughfare called Poultry?
Lutyens wasn’t alone in building classical office blocks and public buildings. By the beginning of the 20th century other architects were turning to the classical style – and particularly classical as used by the 17th –century baroque masters like Wren, Hawksmoor and Vanbrugh and their continental contemporaries. Most notable among these architects were John Belcher, designer of the influential Colchester Town Hall and of the Wren-inspired Ashton Memorial in Lancaster, which Ripon Civic Society visited a few years ago, and Aston Webb, who re-fronted Buckingham Palace and built Admiralty Arch in the baroque style.
Yorkshire-born architect Edwin Cooper was another who built in the classical style. Like Lutyens, Belcher and Webb he was knighted for his architectural work. Born at 44 Nelson Street, Scarborough, in October 1874, where there is now a Scarborough Civic Society blue plaque, Cooper’s father, a carriage proprietor, died when he was small, but his mother, recognising her son’s talent, arranged for him in his teens to be articled to a Scarborough architectural firm, Hall and Tugwell; he later studied with Walter Brierley in York before moving to London to work with Goldie, Child and Goldie, another firm with Yorkshire connections.
In 1893 he returned to his home town, where he set up in practice with a fellow student, Herbert Davis, and with John Hall, from Hall and Tugwell. In Scarborough Cooper designed what was Westwood School and is now part of the Yorkshire Coast College, and the buildings of Scarborough College on Filey Road; both have more than a touch of Brierley’s influence. In the late ‘90s Cooper travelled in France and Italy, where he was influenced by architects who were turning to an elaborate form of classicism, especially for public buildings.
He became a member of the Royal Institute of British Architects in 1903; by then he was in partnership with Samuel Benjamin Russell in London. Seven years later he set up on his own; by then he was already successful. In 1905 he had won the competition to design a new Guildhall for Hull. It was built between 1906 and 1914. His design coped admirably with a narrow, constricted site, and had sufficient gravitas and pomp, especially in its row of attached Corinthian columns on the Alfred Gelder Street façade and the monumental groups of statuary, to please the Aldermen and Councillors of Hull.
In 1910 he entered, but lost, the competition to build London’s County Hall; part of the design he submitted reappeared as the tower of the Port of London Authority (POLA) building, not far from the Tower of London, which he designed in 1912. His style had by now changed a little from the baroque classical to a freer style, influenced by contemporary United States’ public buildings, but still with splendid massing and beautifully-detailed interiors.
Among Cooper’s other London buildings are Marylebone Town Hall, now Westminster Council House, the foundation stone of which was laid in July 1914; because of the War the building was not completed until 1919.
Many of Cooper’s buildings still exist, though some have been adapted, like the POLA building, to other uses. One that does not was once one the most famous of the capital’s buildings, Lloyd’s of London. Cooper was commissioned in 1925 to provide a new HQ for the organisation; again, it was on an awkward site. Most of the building was hidden behind others; only a grand entrance on Leadenhall Street suggested the large building, including a spacious trading floor, that lay behind. The site was redeveloped with an even more iconic building by Richard Rogers, built between 1978 and 1986.
All that is left of Cooper’s design is the imposing entrance front, now dwarfed by glass and steel – all, that is, except for his elaborate Greek-style wooden ‘temple’ inside the new building, which still holds the famous Lutine Bell, originally rung to herald the fate of ships, but now limited to denote the death of a member of the Royal family, to mark the Two Minutes’ Silence and to commemorate disasters.
Cooper, ‘a pink-faced, silver-haired man of episcopal appearance’, died at his desk in June 1942. By then he had been knighted (for the POLA building) and elected a Royal Academician. In 1931 he received the Royal Gold Medal in Architecture, and six years later he succeeded Lutyens as President of the Incorporated Association of Architects and Surveyors; oddly, he could never officially describe himself as a ‘registered architect’ as throughout his life he refused to pay his annual subscription to the Architects’ Registration Council; it was all of six shillings and nine-pence a year. Perhaps he was just being true to his Yorkshire roots.
