THE BRUTALIST SMITHSONS

Are you a Brutalist? Or perhaps a Neo-Brutalist? This is not a column in which to cast aspersions on your behaviour, or to launch a new political party (‘Vote Neo-Brutalist’ as a slogan would hardly appeal to most people in Britain, perhaps). No – as you’d expect about a column that regularly deals with architecture, Brutalism is an architectural movement, popular between the 1950s and 1970s; we are still living with its results.

In this, the last of the summer’s series on six Yorkshire-born architects, we are dealing with a particularly divisive matter – those great concrete buildings that went up, especially, in the 1960s. They were uncompromisingly stark, lacking in any decoration and, many would argue, any sort of good taste. And one of the leading architects of the Brutalist school is the subject of this column. She is Alison Smithson.

Alison Gill was born in Sheffield in June 1928; her father, a graphic artist, became Principal of South Shields School of Art the following year. After schooling in Sunderland and Edinburgh she went on in 1944 to study at King’s College School of Architecture in Newcastle, then part of the University of Durham. There she met Peter Smithson, five years older, whose architectural studies had been interrupted by war service. They married in 1949 and both got jobs that year as architects in the schools division of London County Council.

Both Alison and Peter, who was born in Stockton, were both ambitious modernists. Like other contemporary architects they rejected what they saw as the light and frivolous architecture of the 1930s and 40s for something more ‘honest’. The change to a more monumental style was heralded by the Swiss-French architect le Corbusier’s residential housing scheme in Marseilles called Unité d’Habitation, put up between 1947 and 1952 , and especially one of its buildings, Cité Radieuse – Radiant City. Made of rough-cast concrete, it is uncompromisingly rectilinear, has balconies for each of the 377 apartments and incorporates shops, doctors’ surgeries and schools. It was known locally as ‘The Nutter’s House’.

This was early Brutalist architecture – though the term was coined for a building of 1949 in Upsala by the Swedish architect Asplund. The architecture critic Reyner Banham, who did much to promote Brutalism, defined the style as ‘a tough-minded reforming movement within the framework of modern architectural thought [with] the implicit intention to return to fundamental functionalist principle.’

Alison and Peter Smithson were fully committed to the style; as a student Peter announced that he would become ‘the world’s greatest architect’ – and Alison was to be up there with him. Success came early to them. In May 1950, when Alison was 21 and Peter 26, they won a competition to design a new school at Hunstanton in Norfolk. Smithdon High School, as it is now, is not a concrete block but a light, simple box of steel and glass, much influenced by Mies van der Rohe. Set around two courtyards, it is impressive architecture; it was described in 1965 as ‘one of the first and purest statements of the New Brutalist Movement in England. On its completion in 1954 the Smithsons were hailed by the Architects Journal as ‘the bright young hopes of the profession’.

The Hunstanton School was a model for many, less-well-detailed, educational buildings of the 1950s and 1960s. But it was impractical as a school. There have been endless problems with maintenance and the glass walls were soon found to be impractical, making the place too hot in summer and freezing in winter. One former teacher said it was ‘more suited to a prison that a school’ – though he survived teaching there for 37 years.

The Smithsons were also influential in the movement toward providing social housing in blocks – the so called ‘streets in the sky’ – that were supposed to replicate traditional estates by piling them high. Their first (unbuilt) scheme was designed in 1952 for a site in the City of London; the only one built came later, at Robin Hood Gardens in Docklands; it was demolished last year, having been refused Listed Building status. The idea, though, was influential; among the many buildings that followed the concept was the Park Hill flats in Sheffield, which, first praised, then derided for the social problems they created, have now been refurbished as expensive apartments for the upwardly mobile.

Much of what we today think of as Brutalist architecture – buildings of exposed and now-stained concrete like Harrogate House in Parliament Street in Harrogate (referred to as ‘a half-witted practical joke’ by Bill Bryson and now being refurbished), London’s Hayward Gallery or any number of 1960s car parks – is not really what the Smithsons were about. Much of their work was smaller-scale and more finely detailed, and even when, like their building for the Economist magazine of 1959, they built on a bigger scale, the result was a less vulgar building than many imitators managed. Yet the Smithsons still have a reputation for being the most brutal of the Brutalists – perhaps because of their fierce zeal for promoting the style.

One building that would have made – or broken – their reputation, had it been constructed, was their entry in 1951 for the competition to build the new Coventry Cathedral. Very unlike the much-more traditional winning design by Basil Spence, the Smithson’s entry had a huge tilted concrete canopy with an interior showing sculptural forms around which the liturgy would been celebrated. It could have been wonderful – but it was far too avant-garde for the Church of England in the 1950s.

Alison Smithson died in 1993, and Peter in 2003. Both, having been reviled for a couple of decades, are now regarded as pioneers of architecture, even if their style might be seen as a bit of a cul-de-sac. In 1956 Alison designed ‘The House of the Future’ for the Ideal Home Show; mostly of plastic and capable of mass production, it incorporated ideas such as remote-controlled lighting and a self-cleaning bath. So perhaps, even if we’re not enamoured by Brutalism, she has a place as a leader in household automation. The ‘greatest’ architects? No; but an interesting way to end this brief survey of Yorkshire-born architects.

Copyright © 2020 Ripon Civic Society. Hosting sponsored by HostPresto.