‘The Enforcer’. If you’re a film buff you may immediately think of Clint Eastwood in the third of the ’Dirty Harry’ series – or possibly of a 1951 film of the same title with Humphrey Bogart playing a district attorney. Alternatively, if you are a fan of Marvel Comics, ‘The Enforcers’ are on the other side of justice – a criminal gang that appeared in some of the early Spider-Man stories.
What has this to do with the usual subject of this column – buildings and matters civic? Neither Mr Eastwood nor Mr Bogart (nor, indeed, Spider-Man) has appeared on the streets of Ripon to enforce the law and capture the criminals who haunt its mean streets. Yet there is – or should be – enforcement going on all the time.
One strand of this continuous enforcement comes from the employment of civil enforcement officers; you may know them better as traffic wardens. Employed by the county or other councils – or on contract to them through private companies – their job is to enforce traffic regulations (a job done by the police until ten years ago); they can give penalty notices, inspect and confiscate blue badges, may issue penalties for traffic violations, including driving in bus lanes and driving the wrong way on a one way system. They may also immobilise vehicles with wheel clamps.
The work of the traffic warden (sorry, CEOs) is quite well known – the more so because to undertake their duties legally they must be in uniform. But there are other enforcers at work in the community who are not so visible. Among them are the planning enforcement officers, whose role is wide-ranging and important.
Readers of this column, being law-abiding and aware of the rules and regulations that surround the planning process, may not have come across planning enforcement officers. But they play an important role in ensuring that the local environment is protected and that development is always legal and proper. So they deal with breaches of planning control. This may be when building work is carried out without the necessary planning permission, or where permission has been given with conditions but the conditions are not met. They can also act when the use of a building or site is changed without planning permission – for example, if a barn is turned into a house without planning permission.
Of course, not every new building or change of use needs planning permission. Some work can be carried out under the rules of ‘permitted development’ – but such work is always subject to certain conditions. Planning enforcement is there to see that any permitted development comes within those conditions.
Planning enforcement officers have the power to investigate allegations about planning breaches, can negotiate action to put any breach right, will check that any enforcement notices they issue as a result of their investigation are complied with – and can prosecute if they are not. They should be liaising with other council departments to ensure that there is a consistency of approach in planning matters. And they can institute prosecutions where negotiation fails.
What sort of things come under the eye of the planning enforcement officers? And what are their decisions based on? Among the factors they take into account when deciding on enforcement action are whether the development is causing harm by, for example, noise nuisance or disturbance, pollution, increased traffic or loss of privacy. These are generally straightforward matters. They can instigate enforcement action if they consider that poor design or inappropriate materials have a detrimental impact on the look of the area. They can also take action where there is untidy land and run-down or derelict buildings.
None of this is earth-shattering stuff, and one would expect any reasonable council to be able to take action on these matters. Where there is some contention is in whether enforcement is active or reactive – and how much enforcement there should be. In an ideal world any breach of planning, whether by neglect, by purposeful flouting of the law or through ignorance of the rules, should be investigated. So whether it’s the building of a house on a plot entirely without planning permission, or the appearance of an advertising banner or road-side notice without authority, the enforcement officers should be on the case.
But with the recent heavy cuts to local authority spending, there have been severe losses among enforcement officers, with staff leaving and not replaced. The service has, generally, ceased to seek out breaches and now relies much more on action on complaints. And even when action is taken it can sometimes be ineffective; there are examples in Ripon, like the three properties that the Civic Society has dubbed ‘The Three Disgraces’ on the corner of Water Skellgate and Low Skellgate that some years ago were forced to smarten up their frontages, but which remain in a very unsatisfactory state behind. There are occasional purges on illegal banner advertising, but new banners soon reappear.
Does all this matter? Certainly it does, because the more rogue owners, developers or others believe that there is no enforcement and that they can get away with breaches of regulations, the more they will do so – to the detriment of the look of the area. Planning laws were introduced when it was realised that free-for-all was severely damaging large parts of the country; we do not want to go back to such a state of affairs.
Of course local authorities are stretched, and in an ideal world it would not be necessary for planning enforcement to exist; we would all respect the law, make sure we have permission for all our actions, and not put up or alter buildings, chop down protected trees or put up advertising without leave. But until this utopian state arrives, we must support enforcement, make sure that that the officers are aware of breaches and take action – and be constantly vigilant.
